HELP Ammonia :(
- Thread starter eric.20
- Start date
- Tagged users None
MnFish1
10K Club member
Corals can not do well for lots of reasons so without knowing many other things thats hard to answer
. I would suggest that ammonia is 'less likely' because ammonia would kill them at those levels - not just make them 'not look well'. And if you used the Prime correctly - the ammonia should not be an issue. In any case - I was just suggesting that depending on the test kit you're using - you cant tell (at all) the level of toxic ammonia in your tank. But you seem to be focusing on ammonia.I have had GSP for example stay closed for up to a couple weeks after a problem. Zoas as well.
BeejReef
2500 Club Member
On the bright side, if your corals are holding themselves closed, there's at least a reasonable chance they're still alive.
Lots of things changed for them along with the chemistry issues you're having. Are you running the same lights as the old setup?
Either way, might not be a horrible idea to soften the lights slightly for a few weeks and just be extra gentle all around
Lots of things changed for them along with the chemistry issues you're having. Are you running the same lights as the old setup?
Either way, might not be a horrible idea to soften the lights slightly for a few weeks and just be extra gentle all around
Brett S
Valuable Member
I really don’t think that’s the case for the following reasons... you moved your rock from your established tank and unless something weird happened to the rock, like it was left out of the water for a long time or washed in freshwater there would have been a bacteria population in that rock that should have been more than enough to support the tank without the bacteria that was in the sock.
Additionally, with your light bioload even if there wasn’t any bacteria in the rock and almost all of your bacteria was in the sock then your ammonia shouldn’t have risen so quickly and to such a high level. A few corals and some hermits just aren’t going to be producing that much ammonia.
I really think that there was something else that triggered all of this.
Brett S
Valuable Member
Because the damage was done when the ammonia climbed to 2.0 before you added prime the first time. Ammonia will give the corals a chemical burn, so think of it this way... if you were put in acid then it would burn your body. Even if the acid was then neutralized the damage would already be done and you would still have acid burns on your body that would take time to heal. If the acid was weak (low levels of ammonia) then the burn wouldn’t be too bad and wouldn’t take too long to heal, but it would still take time. If the acid was strong (high levels of ammonia) then the burn would severely injure you and take much longer to heal... or it could even kill you.
All you can do now is keep the ammonia neutralized so there is no further damage and allow the corals time to heal on their own. Their stress response is to close up while they heal, so they will stay closed and not look well until and if they are able to recover from this.
post a full tank shot of this tank and from that we can tell if there's an ammonia issue. not from a test kit from the pic, post away. I looked but didn't see any on prior pages.
A picture and a known submersion history is all it takes to trace out ammonia, ok lessgo
it w be mighty fun when Seneye gets more popular to make predictions about the state of ammonia and then have it measured after the prediction.
Titration kits merely mislead for ammonia and nitrite work, tank pics beat them currently.
from the pic, post away. I looked but didn't see any on prior pages.A picture and a known submersion history is all it takes to trace out ammonia, ok lessgo
it w be mighty fun when Seneye gets more popular to make predictions about the state of ammonia and then have it measured after the prediction.
Titration kits merely mislead for ammonia and nitrite work, tank pics beat them currently.
OP
OP
eric.20
Active Member
We just did the water change but ran out of salt we put the power head on and put the heater in the display tank. Return pump is just out as we still have 20% to refill. I have to work now and on the way there I bought salt. I will be back home in few hours. But we did a test again (API test kit) and the ammonia was at 1.0.
MnFish1
10K Club member
We just did the water change but ran out of salt we put the power head on and put the heater in the display tank. Return pump is just out as we still have 20% to refill. I have to work now and on the way there I bought salt. I will be back home in few hours. But we did a test again (API test kit) and the ammonia was at 1.0.
Nice tank - and what percent of the water did you change?
OP
OP
eric.20
Active Member
OP
OP
eric.20
Active Member
Before the ammonia was high the corals where doing good, they had good Color and also they were growing. So since the ammonia spike a few of them closed up, specially the zoa sand our green star polyp
Mattman1977
Active Member
- Joined
- Nov 27, 2018
- Messages
- 242
- Reaction score
- 181
That’s the million dollar question right now.
if I'm not mistaken the top shot is the current tank, and the bottom closeups are from a prior time?
both are zero ammonia condition due to opened corals, I can't zoom in on that smaller full tank pic but I see an open anem on the left, they'll close tight with true burning free ammonia present/no current ammonia issue is at hand if that's the most recent pic.
we'd have to know where a strong source of ammo
Even people who disagree about base cycling specifics can agree the hallmark of a completed cycle is the ability to manage ammonia from compounding daily. Further proof you don't have an ammonia issue is in the fact you don't have any room left to be compounding if the 8ppm was real, your lady w boot you due to home stench/ the real level is zero ammonia and every day would add more and the water would be cloudy, with lost animals days ago.
this is another reason why claimed .25 ammonia systems don't hold up...that number has to be compounding daily to be real, not just holding. Holding means the bac are there...
Whether or not there was an ammonia event upon setup of this tank has to come from detritus moved over, if any. Looks too clean to have been a messy tank transfer, all cloudy from pent up waste put back into suspension (and stink)
I bet it was a no ammonia event the whole time, its a testing confound somehow
both are zero ammonia condition due to opened corals, I can't zoom in on that smaller full tank pic but I see an open anem on the left, they'll close tight with true burning free ammonia present/no current ammonia issue is at hand if that's the most recent pic.
we'd have to know where a strong source of ammo
Even people who disagree about base cycling specifics can agree the hallmark of a completed cycle is the ability to manage ammonia from compounding daily. Further proof you don't have an ammonia issue is in the fact you don't have any room left to be compounding
if the 8ppm was real, your lady w boot you due to home stench/ the real level is zero ammonia and every day would add more and the water would be cloudy, with lost animals days ago.this is another reason why claimed .25 ammonia systems don't hold up...that number has to be compounding daily to be real, not just holding. Holding means the bac are there...
Whether or not there was an ammonia event upon setup of this tank has to come from detritus moved over, if any. Looks too clean to have been a messy tank transfer, all cloudy from pent up waste put back into suspension (and stink)
I bet it was a no ammonia event the whole time, its a testing confound somehow
Last edited:
OP
OP
eric.20
Active Member
The close up pictures are from before. When I will come home I will take pictures of the corals now. I dimmed the light now to 50%.
The pictures I just posted just shows how happy the corals where before
The pictures I just posted just shows how happy the corals where before
MnFish1
10K Club member
So - it makes sense that the ammonia (with prime in the water) is reading 1 ppm. I assume. I would do another change soon? not for ammonia - which I think is not now an issue - but incase there are other toxins etc - that may be irritating the corals. Im sorry I cant remember - are you using carbon> (activated). Sometimes when corals/zoas/LPS are moved - they release toxins (oh and anemones as well) which can cause this. Carbon will help remove any problem issues.
OP
OP
eric.20
Active Member
we dont have carbon as people told us our tank is too new to use it..
we have purigen and chemi pure.
also I just did a 50-60% water change
