Kalkwasser help!

Actually 2 teaspoons is the max that will dissolve in a gallon of water. If 2 teaspoons per gallon doesn't maintain your levels you should switch to 2 part

been a long time since i mixed kalk.. i was almost positive i was using tablespoons (and heaping ones too) before i switched to a reactor.... now i just put a cup in the reactor every few weeks...

OP should consider getting a reactor... less hassle
 
I have raised my Kalk to2 teaspoons per gallon and alk is still dropping after 1 1/2 more weeks. Does this mean Kalk isn’t for me and my tank?

2 teaspoons per gallon is the maximum solubility of kalk in water, but to keep the solution saturated, there should always be some undissolved kalk on the bottom of the container.

If your evaporation rate is low and you have a fair amount of stony corals, kalk in top off water likely won't do the job alone.

You could always look at a kalk reactor.i have never used one, but on came with my new to me set up- I plan on connecting and dosing from my apex for more precise dosing, but they can run via ATO pump and always have saturated limewater. You set them to mix the kalk that settles out to the bottom.

This is exactly what I did. I tried putting kalk right in the ATO reservoir at first. This becomes really messy really fast, with calcium carbonate forming a crust on the water surface, then collapsing and floating down toward the bottom. I also had concerns about premature pump failure and clogging of the anti-siphon valve, either of which would be bad news.

So I got the TLF KW300 kalk reactor. It has no electrical stirrer; it stirs whenever water is being pumped through it, keeping the solution saturated. I hooked it up to my Apex and ATK. It doses kalk for 10 seconds every 30 minutes, which is slightly higher than my evaporation rate, with limits set by the ATK optical sensors. I also put a solenoid in the line to act as protection against a pump malfunction or siphon.

Yeah but I don’t see the point in using Kalk if I’m gonna have to dose 2 part also. My ph hasn’t really changed since dosing Kalk.

You know, I really expected my pH to rise when I started dosing kalk too. And it did, briefly, but then came back down to the previous range. It has allowed me to cut back on my two part use somewhat, but I was really hoping to see some persistent pH rise as well. ;Meh
 
Update: Just got a CO2 meter yesterday. Indoor reads high, around 600. This accounts entirely for my tank pH being persistently 0.2 units lower than I'd like it to be. Sadly, ato kalk isn't going to overcome that.
 
@rkpetersen Which meter did you buy?

This one. It's not necessarily the best, but it suits my specific purposes; namely, a fairly attractive and low profile unit that I can set up permanently on an end table in our family room near the aquarium, without my wife objecting. :)

Although in all seriousness, it's easy to use as a portable unit as well. Just connect it to a cell phone battery pack. Outside on the chilly deck in back of my house, it reads 350.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Can you run a fresh air line to outside? I have one connected to intake of my skimmer.

As for me, this wouldn't be easy, but I may have to figure something out. Or start CO2 scrubbing, which is a hassle and expensive.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top