monkeyCmonkeyDo
7500 Club Member
If ur tank was another 100 or 150gals id say yes do it.
I suggest finding another diffrent type and smaller.
Hths
D
I suggest finding another diffrent type and smaller.
Hths
D
BaysEndReef
Anthony
Welcome to R2R!! Always here to help!!
IKD
2500 Club Member
Welcome! Can’t offer any additional advice than was already stated. Adding them at the same time seems to give people the best odds of success. Not sure you would see a new tang of any kind be added successfully.
bpbonds
Active Member
I generally add all Tangs at the same time cause that way they do not have an established territory yet, the tangs you already have most likely have territory established. 2nd the tank is a bit small for that many Tangs they need lots of room to swim, I would add some smaller fish keep it safe.
Fish Think Pink
5000 Club Member
Welcome! Glad you joined.Hi everyone, I have a 1-2 inch blue tang, 2 inch yellow tang and a 4-5 inch powder brown tang and I’m looking to add a 5-6 inch purple tang. They say to add the most aggressive last but I’m worried he might bully my other tangs…… can it be done without him killing my other tangs?? I have a 400 litre (105 gallon) tank with plenty of rock and coral to hide in? Any help with this will be much appreciated
I share below, because while you might get away with what you have now, they'll all grow, all become adults, and typically more aggressive as they age. When something happens, have a plan B. Sometimes you also need plans C-Z (rehome, additional tank(s), etc).
I have just 2 tangs, they've become Death Dealers. I was very afraid when one had to leave DT during Reef Flux treatment that it would be killed or kill the other tang upon return. When Reef Flux was done, I moved Sailfin tang to sump for 1-2 weeks to help break territorial hold as yellow tang had 'vacationed' in QT for 3 weeks. I used an acclimation box (The Shu) with magnets so I could move the fish into various territories within tank. Had mirror handy and used as well. It was a successful re-add (measured in no deaths, they healed). I hope someday to add a brand new to tank fish also with no deaths (many sad stories and they were not even tangs).
tbrown
Nominated Cronie Intern - Might be failing?
Welcome!Hi everyone, I have a 1-2 inch blue tang, 2 inch yellow tang and a 4-5 inch powder brown tang and I’m looking to add a 5-6 inch purple tang. They say to add the most aggressive last but I’m worried he might bully my other tangs…… can it be done without him killing my other tangs?? I have a 400 litre (105 gallon) tank with plenty of rock and coral to hide in? Any help with this will be much appreciated
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Thanks for all your suggestions, he has come out of a tank with a blue and yellow tang, also my tank is exactly the same as the one he’s coming from, do you think that will make a difference?
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Thanks for your reply, rule of thumb is to add the most aggressive last…….
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
ThanksHello and welcome to R2R!
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Thanks, great to be here
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Thank you
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Thanks! Do you think it’s worth giving it a go? I have a QT tank if everything turns to custard hi , welcome to the reef...
just my opinion,but think 5-6" purple too big for tank,would most likely leave blue and yellow alone ,just by size difference,but may be prob with p brown. nice reef, happy reefing
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
Hey! Thanks for your comment, I upgraded the skimmer pretty early in the hobby to be fair. No I’m in New Zealand
fishguy242
Cronies..... INSERT BUILD THREAD BADGE HERE !!
Partner Member 2024
Reef Tank 365
Photo of the Month
Hospitality Award
Midwest Reefer
Fish Medic
R2R Secret Santa 2023
FIREBUG
hi, i'm sorry but think is bad option,too big,just going to get bigger...Thanks! Do you think it’s worth giving it a go? I have a QT tank if everything turns to custard
OP
OP
Kbangaa
New Member
So a smaller one would be ok?hi, i'm sorry but think is bad option,too big,just going to get bigger...
