1 fish 2 fish red fish blue fish

  • Thread starter Thread starter rich524
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

rich524

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 5, 2023
Messages
31
Reaction score
57
Location
Rochester
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
How many fish is too many? 120 gallon w/40gal sump. Totally water volume lets say 150. Fish size all smaller then 4". I don't want technical i want good opinions and best at that. Have fun with your answers and if they are wrong and funny i prefer it.
 
It's not just "total fish", but what type of fish. Also not total gallons, or even display gallons, but length and to an extent width. You could even get crazy and start considering coral density. That said, if I had a 120, I would do something like this as a MAX stock.

1 Small Tang, likely a Tomini
2 Clowns
1 Small Wrasse (Lubbocks or Solar)
2 Cardinal Fish
1 Goby or Blenny
3 Talbot Damsels

Currently my 220 is understocked with a Purple, Yellow, Tomini, 2 Clowns, 2 Talbots, 1 Orange Spot Goby, Melanurus Wrasse, Lubbocks Wrasse, two Aiptasia Eating File Fish (of which only one eats Aiptasia) and 2 Lyretail Anthias
 
It's not just "total fish", but what type of fish. Also not total gallons, or even display gallons, but length and to an extent width. You could even get crazy and start considering coral density. That said, if I had a 120, I would do something like this as a MAX stock.

1 Small Tang, likely a Tomini
2 Clowns
1 Small Wrasse (Lubbocks or Solar)
2 Cardinal Fish
1 Goby or Blenny
3 Talbot Damsels

Currently my 220 is understocked with a Purple, Yellow, Tomini, 2 Clowns, 2 Talbots, 1 Orange Spot Goby, Melanurus Wrasse, Lubbocks Wrasse, two Aiptasia Eating File Fish (of which only one eats Aiptasia) and 2 Lyretail Anthias
 
I've got a 120g and you're going to hear all different answers, especially when it comes to tangs. There are factors you need to consider like how often you want to do water changes and what kind of setup you're working with. Then there's the fact that this is a 48" 120g, which is going to rule out some fish...depending on who you listen to. I've got 9 fish in mine so far and will probably only add a few more.

2 Clowns
3 green chromis
1 yellow coris wrasse
1blue tang
1 possum wrasse
1 yellow watchman goby
 
Sure load it with corals and invertebrates as well. The chat is whats too much. If i tell true whats actually in there imo it's loaded with all of the above sponge included. Slowly thinning out but im looking for new reefers all the time and i also have a friend with the eventual larger tank to rehome larger animals.
 
How many fish is too many? 120 gallon w/40gal sump. Totally water volume lets say 150. Fish size all smaller then 4". I don't want technical i want good opinions and best at that. Have fun with your answers and if they are wrong and funny i prefer it.
Keep growth rate and aggression in mind but 7-8 small medium comfortably
 
I've got a 120g and you're going to hear all different answers, especially when it comes to tangs. There are factors you need to consider like how often you want to do water changes and what kind of setup you're working with. Then there's the fact that this is a 48" 120g, which is going to rule out some fish...depending on who you listen to. I've got 9 fish in mine so far and will probably only add a few more.

2 Clowns
3 green chromis
1 yellow coris wrasse
1blue tang
1 possum wrasse
1 yellow watchman goby
Call it 10% weekly or nopox and dosing. More to whats to much. If i have 22 fish variety of sizes all happy all places to hide is it to much? I love opinions and chatter. So its fun to hear how and what others have and run. Ty
 
I have a 125G long as it is 72"x18". No corals.
Tons of Live Rocks

Fish are
1 hyppo tang 3+ years
7 green Chromis 5+ years
1 sixline wrasse 3+ years
1 Eibli angel 8+ years
1 foxface rabbit fish 8+ years
2 clowns, one around 10 years, other maybe 8
1 fourstrippe damsel over 12 years.... came with the tank.
A few cleaning crew, including very old hermits and a turbo snail. other cleaning crew are much younger.

Now for all the "wrong" thing you want to hear:
I do not quarantine,
I use tap water
I do not own a test kit.
At least I am not dumb enough to try corals.
 
Call it 10% weekly or nopox and dosing. More to whats to much. If i have 22 fish variety of sizes all happy all places to hide is it to much? I love opinions and chatter. So its fun to hear how and what others have and run. Ty
Honestly, I doubt I will go past 15 fish and that to me will be pushing it. I'm running a 30 gal wet/dry sump, with a protein skimmer and hang on fuge. I don't wanna be doing a water change every week so that's gonna limit the type and number of fish I have. It's not always about size either. Some fish are poop monsters and that has an effect on the number of fish you could have. Bioload and space.
 
20230408_111709.jpg
 
Never ever tested water?
When I started I took water sample to my LFS and had them checked. They usually told me I needed a water change, as my nitrate or my phosphate were a little high. I complied.
But I realized that my fish were doing well, and my chromis were spawning many times a year, and therefore must be doing well.
So I stopped checking and just do water change around once a month and add MacroBacter7 on occasion.
I also do not have a skimmer. I use a good HOB filter (Tydal), a heater, LED light and a power head. I posted this mainly because I am often astounded by the number of equipment people buy for their aquarium. I personally think that the reason I succeeded though very ignorant at the begining, was that I had a ton of Live rocks and many, many hiding places for my fish, which prevented stress. I also realized, that corals must be harder to grow, and I am not going to try.
My tank is not a work of art, but I enjoy my fish and they seem happy. That is enough for me.
In a smaller 40G aquarium, I have started macro algae. The fish in it and the plants are doing well too, though It took a while before the macro took off. I now have enough to feed my rabbit fish and my angel fresh macro once in a while.
Same equipment, HOB filter, heater, LED light and small power head. These fish are 2 firefish, 2 pajama cardinal and 2 scissor tail gobbies. These are younger fish, as I had to rehome my 4+ year starry blenny to be able to have macro. So the firefish are only 1year, pajama 9 month and scissortail 6 months.
 
Gardening in salt water monitoring parameters trying to stay stable is typically how i have found my corals to grow. For the average slacker probably not. But not hard just stability is kinda key.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top