2 Hydra 26 hd's or ATI t5 fixture

Can you control when the lights turn on and off with the non *dimmable fixture without an apex?
Yes, the ATI fixture has a clock setting, you can set it to turn on and off when you want for the non dimmable.
Yes. But be aware of the 50 hour burn in period for your bulbs.
+1. This is a pain. Every time you change bulbs you have to run them like this; I just cover my tank up, but a non dimmable doesn't have this limitation since you are running 100% all the time.

I would go with the ATI fixture, especially if you are unsure. I run the hydra's on one of my tanks along with halides, and the fine control of the hydra's is nice, but if you are unsure of what percentages to use for each spectrum, and more importantly, what combinations of percentages to run, T5's are plug and play, buy the bulbs that give good growth and color and just let it do its' thing
 
Soooo you may want to hold on just a second with the ATI. I have a set of Hydra 52 HDs over a 450 reefer and hated them at first - once I stopped fiddling with them all of the time everything started growing just fine. If you really like the look of the Hydras I wouldn't hesitate. I think success with LEDs has as much to do with balancing nutrition against par as much anything else. Lots of beautiful LED tanks as you can see from the tank that @hart24601 posted above. Heck WWC just flipped a bunch of their tanks out to LED.

Don't get me wrong, ATI fixtures are great. Matter of fact I have a brand new 8 x 54" Sunpower I just got through powder coating black that's going on a new reefer 525 xl as well as a Giesemann Spectra MH/T5 combo with 2 Reefbrite XOs over a 80 at home. So I'm a bit of an agnostic when it comes to light.
 
Thanks man! As you probably know I don't mess around with the colors, 2:1 blues (UV,V,DB,RB) to white (W,R,G) as AI said for 20k and I don't fuss with it. I am starting a 60 cube now with radion g3s - as I got some G1 for free and just got them upgraded.

I think what my tank really shows is that lighting isn't really what makes or breaks a reef tank. Of course you need a min of PAR but after that you gotta pick what you like.

Personally I can't stand changing bulbs, I know it's silly. And I really like top down view of the tank and am not a fan of big T5 banks over the top and how low many people put them - although there are of course exceptions. But that is just me.

Either way you go, with T5/hybrid/AI 26s you don't need to worry about the lights holding you back.
 
Thanks man! As you probably know I don't mess around with the colors, 2:1 blues (UV,V,DB,RB) to white (W,R,G) as AI said for 20k and I don't fuss with it. I am starting a 60 cube now with radion g3s - as I got some G1 for free and just got them upgraded.

I think what my tank really shows is that lighting isn't really what makes or breaks a reef tank. Of course you need a min of PAR but after that you gotta pick what you like.

Personally I can't stand changing bulbs, I know it's silly. And I really like top down view of the tank and am not a fan of big T5 banks over the top and how low many people put them - although there are of course exceptions. But that is just me.

Either way you go, with T5/hybrid/AI 26s you don't need to worry about the lights holding you back.
*OP - sorry for the off topic data*
Hey Man, thanks for sharing the 2:1 info. Ive been running without the R/G at all. Think I should kick the R/G/W up to 40% and forget it?
lights.png
 
Basic summary of this thread - get the lights you want. You can grow anything as tech is at a point where LED, T5 are both viable options. Best of both worlds would be cool, but not necessary. Lighting is just one part of the equation.

I agree 100%

*OP - sorry for the off topic data*
Hey Man, thanks for sharing the 2:1 info. Ive been running without the R/G at all. Think I should kick the R/G/W up to 40% and forget it?
lights.png

That is what I did! All 2:1 and I really like how it looks.
 
Soooo you may want to hold on just a second with the ATI. I have a set of Hydra 52 HDs over a 450 reefer and hated them at first - once I stopped fiddling with them all of the time everything started growing just fine. If you really like the look of the Hydras I wouldn't hesitate. I think success with LEDs has as much to do with balancing nutrition against par as much anything else. Lots of beautiful LED tanks as you can see from the tank that @hart24601 posted above. Heck WWC just flipped a bunch of their tanks out to LED.

Don't get me wrong, ATI fixtures are great. Matter of fact I have a brand new 8 x 54" Sunpower I just got through powder coating black that's going on a new reefer 525 xl as well as a Giesemann Spectra MH/T5 combo with 2 Reefbrite XOs over a 80 at home. So I'm a bit of an agnostic when it comes to light.
Great response, there is a balance that has to be achieved between PAR, nutrient levels, flow, etc. and when you understand how much of each your tank needs, it starts to get dialed in. The only reason why a T5 fixture of any kind is good is that it is easy to figure out what your PAR will be before even turning the light on. ATI bulbs give a specific PAR at 100% and that's a known. It just gets harder when dealing with LED's, which I love, and sounds like you and I have some similar lighting and beliefs (I'm lighting agnostic as well); hydra's with MH on a RSM 500, ATI with ReefBrites and Kessils on a JBJ, so it just depends on how much someone knows about all of the components in play. I'm all for making it look good to my eyes and if the hydra's are what nanoreefer likes, then definitely get them, but understand what you said about "success with LEDs has as much to do with balancing nutrition against par as much anything else". Not many people connect those two things....
 
Well I checked out some coral shops today and asked for opinions and they all recommended ATI six bulb with reefbrite XHO. So, I've decided to go that route. Thank you for everyone's help!
 
Great response, there is a balance that has to be achieved between PAR, nutrient levels, flow, etc. and when you understand how much of each your tank needs, it starts to get dialed in. The only reason why a T5 fixture of any kind is good is that it is easy to figure out what your PAR will be before even turning the light on. ATI bulbs give a specific PAR at 100% and that's a known. It just gets harder when dealing with LED's, which I love, and sounds like you and I have some similar lighting and beliefs (I'm lighting agnostic as well); hydra's with MH on a RSM 500, ATI with ReefBrites and Kessils on a JBJ, so it just depends on how much someone knows about all of the components in play. I'm all for making it look good to my eyes and if the hydra's are what nanoreefer likes, then definitely get them, but understand what you said about "success with LEDs has as much to do with balancing nutrition against par as much anything else". Not many people connect those two things....
Thanks Man! So what's the deal with the Hydra and MH?
 
Thanks Man! So what's the deal with the Hydra and MH?
Good question. Red Sea put the hydra's on the new tanks, and I love MH, and esp reefbrite, so i got their dimmable 250W double ended 14K bulb on the red sea 500 and it's awesome. I can put my hand on top of the fixture at the end of the day and it's hot but doesn't hurt. So fell into the hydras and bought the MH. I love this combo I have to say, although I'd go 20K or 21K MH and more white on the LED....
 
Good question. Red Sea put the hydra's on the new tanks, and I love MH, and esp reefbrite, so i got their dimmable 250W double ended 14K bulb on the red sea 500 and it's awesome. I can put my hand on top of the fixture at the end of the day and it's hot but doesn't hurt. So fell into the hydras and bought the MH. I love this combo I have to say, although I'd go 20K or 21K MH and more white on the LED....
Very cool! That 14k MH will certainly give you a nice growth bump as well.
 
I would just go with Hydra 26s and I did... I don't really see what I am missing not having T5s:

1.jpg
2.jpg
3.jpg
I for one don't like the shimmer from led lights. looks like a disco club. This is where the t5 light come into play. I wish the led lights did not have the shimmer I would opt for led light then..
 
Bought everything last week. I am not disappointed with my choice.
8f093207df03af6b17603c82d15d8654.jpg
looks a little blue to me.. but again everyone has their personal taste when it comes to these setups. do you notice a big difference when you add the reefbrite ?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top