4’ 100 gallon stock list thoughts.

Tiki Reef Joshua

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 27, 2020
Messages
666
Reaction score
581
Location
NOVA
What state or country do you live in
Virginia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
All,
My current tank is 48”x24”x20”, 100 gallon display, 35 gallon sump. Stock list is:

1 yellow tang
1 Helfrichi Fire Fish
1 clown
1 yellow coris wrasse
1 six line wrasse (very small)
1 tangoran goby (very very small and my oldest fish)
1 diamond goby
1 cleaner shrimp

I’m not planning on anymore fish as I’ve had most of them a while now.... just general thoughts on the bio load and *if I was going to do one more what it should be.... another type of firefish?, flame angel probably too much with a yellow tang already in there..... blenny? Or keep as is since I’m already pushing it? I will say everyone in the tank is friends. They all hang together and I see 0 aggression. I feed 2 times per day most days, once a day occasionally. Weekly 15 gallon water changes (sometimes bi-weekly)

mahalo!
 
you have a nice mix so far and it's great they are all getting along so well.

A Midas Blenny is really peaceful and would probably mix well if you decide on another fish down the road. There are some other blennies that are peaceful as well.
 
Molly Miller Blenny - awesome janitor and so much fun to watch them...FAST movers!
Niger Trigger - probably one of the hardiest and most active ever.
 
well.. for comparison i have the same size tank and i have 17 fish so far and i'm still adding more.. :D

i did overdo the filtration to handle an overstocked tank, though. and i've been careful to not add stuff that is not compatible. so i'd say you need way more wrasses, but the sixline is prohibitive of more wrasses, at least to me. a blenny seems like a must, but i'd stay away from the herbivore type blennies as the tang will probably not appreciate another vegan in his territory. so the midas or a meiacanthus would be pretty nice. if you're willing to risk a flame angel i'd say they're totally worth it. but if you value meaty lps and acans and zoas and stuff like that, save yourself the trouble and just get a genicanthus angel

things to consider for overstocking the tank: the fish getting along and having space, filtration, enough places for the fish to sleep at night. if you have a decent skimmer, a good amount of rock/biomedia, a big fuge or algae scrubber, i think you can add way more to that tank. especially considering the firefish and goby are tiny little fish that barely add much to the bioload.
 
well.. for comparison i have the same size tank and i have 17 fish so far and i'm still adding more.. :D

i did overdo the filtration to handle an overstocked tank, though. and i've been careful to not add stuff that is not compatible. so i'd say you need way more wrasses, but the sixline is prohibitive of more wrasses, at least to me. a blenny seems like a must, but i'd stay away from the herbivore type blennies as the tang will probably not appreciate another vegan in his territory. so the midas or a meiacanthus would be pretty nice. if you're willing to risk a flame angel i'd say they're totally worth it. but if you value meaty lps and acans and zoas and stuff like that, save yourself the trouble and just get a genicanthus angel

things to consider for overstocking the tank: the fish getting along and having space, filtration, enough places for the fish to sleep at night. if you have a decent skimmer, a good amount of rock/biomedia, a big fuge or algae scrubber, i think you can add way more to that tank. especially considering the firefish and goby are tiny little fish that barely add much to the bioload.

Yea I have a pretty big skimmer and a very easy water change system. 35 gallon sump. I run carbon also. I’m pretty good as far as maintenance. I love a flame angel, but I’m primarily LPS. Acans, elegance, Duncan’s, euphilia. I dunno. Just wondering for the future. I’m also thinking about a few cool inverts. I love my tiger conch. But I may add some kind of cool crab or star. I dunno. Still thinking. Not rushing.
 
Yea I have a pretty big skimmer and a very easy water change system. 35 gallon sump. I run carbon also. I’m pretty good as far as maintenance. I love a flame angel, but I’m primarily LPS. Acans, elegance, Duncan’s, euphilia. I dunno. Just wondering for the future. I’m also thinking about a few cool inverts. I love my tiger conch. But I may add some kind of cool crab or star. I dunno. Still thinking. Not rushing.

the acans would probably get wrecked by the angel, but the others seem to fare well with the with caution fish. i'm aiming to go sps only tho so i'm taking it a bit further with multiple angels and butterflies in the plans

honestly if i were you i'd catch and get rid of the sixline and then add a whole mess of wrasses.

i also like conchs. i'm conchless right now and my sandbed looks conchless :D
 
Diamond goby + conch = nice sand

Yea i love my LPS. I love my six line too. He is tiny, but he and the yellow coris pick at stuff all day on rocks. The tang is funny and copies everyone like he’s trying to fit in. I don’t want another clown because ehhh.... but maybe if mine gets hosted I’ll reconsider. I have enough yellow. .... I dunno. Definitely something to think on.
 
I would skip the six line and add a potters wrasse and a mystery wrasse. Maybe add a flasher wrasse, Royal or McCoskers. I would also add a kole tang or white tail bristle tooth tang
 
1 Ocellaris Clown- Pair him lol. Hurts me when I see Clowns kept as singles unless it’s a Maroon.

1 Yellow Coris Wrasse- Great. Active and controls pests. (How deep is your sand bed by the way? Just curious.)

1 Six-Line Wrasse- Not sure about yours but from many experiences that I’ve read they become a bully as they get older, your Yellow Coris may be threatened. I wish they were a lot more peaceful because they do look good and control pests.

1 Tangaroan Goby- Great. Are they part of a genus that pair with shrimp?

1 Diamond Goby- I assume yours is either taking prepared foods already or your sand bed is mature enough. It is a sand sifter while your Tangaroa is a traditional carnivorous goby that eats meat so the two will be fine together.

1 Helfrichi Firefish- Pretty colors. They’re hard to come across where I am. Red and Purple Firefish are abundant in my place.


I would not get another Firefish as unlike their non-Firefish Dartfish cousins, Firefish should be kept in multiples only if you can get mated pairs. Not sure why nature intended it to be this way with Firefish versus the Zebra, Scissortail and Blue Gudgeon Dartfish but Mother Nature works in mysterious ways I guess.

If I were you I’d pair the Clown, remove the Six-Line Wrasse if it gets a bit too aggressive and replace it with a basslet or Assessor type fish. That means a Royal Gramma, Blackcap, Swissguard, Swales, or if you’re really into rare fish maybe even Gramma linki or a Candy Basslet. Assessors the yellow ones are the most common, but there are also the Randall’s and McNeill’s Assessors. If you’re willing to take somewhat of a risk with fleshy and stony corals, a Coral Beauty, Flame, or one of the pygmy angels could work although you’ll have to ask whether the pygmies will harass the Firefish and the Yellow Coris Wrasses as they can also get a bit feisty. If you are okay with another semi-aggressive but not overly aggressive option (plus you’ll be adding it last), some of the Chrysiptera sp. damsels would also work. Azure, maybe the Yellowtail, Rolland’s, Starcki’s (more rare), Talbot’s, Rolland’s, Springer’s etc. If you’re okay holding out for a rarer fish among this genus then Rolland’s onwards. If not, a basic Azure will give nice colors. Maybe even two of them? Again though double check if you don’t want to lose that Helfrichi Firefish.

I’d say to play it safe pair the Clown, take out the Six-Line Wrasse if it starts harassing your other fish, and replace it with a Basslet or Assessor. If you’re OK taking somewhat of a risk with that Firefish and in the dwarf angel’s case, with corals, then a more peaceful kind of Damselfish or one of the dwarf angels I mentioned could be an option.

Yellow Tang will need at least a 125 Long (6’) Long-term. They get to 8” and while not hyperactive like Acanthurus and Paracanthurus, they’re still Tangs that swim long distances. Long-term I’d say at least a 150 gallon 6’ tank would be ideal for Zebrasoma Tangs. A smaller Bristletooth Tang like a Yellow Eye Kole, Tomini, Truncated Bristletooth or White Tail (6-7”) would be fine in your tank.

Cardinalfish (Bangaii, PJ, or what other ones you can find) would be yet another option but don’t keep more than one Bangaii or Flame unless they’re a known pair. PJs, Orbiculates, Yellow Striped etc. seem to do better when in a pair or group (though can be kept singly too). However you may find them boring lol.



Edit: Your Tangaroa Goby can pair with a snapping shrimp. Since it’s small I’d probably opt for a Randall’s over a Tiger Pistol but either will be fine, I think. Shrimp gobies don’t seem to do much on their own.
 
Last edited:
Man... everyone is hating on the 6-line. I’m keeping him. He has been great. Maybe he is fine because it’s not too small of a tank. The tang is not large at all. Great color, great appetite, 0 aggression, he must like it more that folks want him to. If he gets too large I will give him to one of many people with bigger tanks in my local club. It’s not like he is in a 50 gallon... he is fine.

Love the suggestions! I’ve done a tiger shrimp with a goby before, wasn’t too entertaining for me. My goby is always out, especially in the evening. He is my favorite. I don’t want to but a shrimp in there with him. Plus I was always rescuing the shrimp from the sock. The coris wrasse didn’t like him either.

On the diamond goby. Most of the sand is mature, but he eats pellets and reef frenzy too. All the fish are great eaters in the tank.

The stock list that is current won’t change, I was just curious on people’s thoughts. Got what I asked for. . Anyway, everyone in the tank is pals. I was more seeing one an additional recommendation might be. I wouldn’t remove one to add others, just not my thing. I’d keep it at the current load most likely.

Thanks everyone.
 
Man... everyone is hating on the 6-line. I’m keeping him. He has been great. Maybe he is fine because it’s not too small of a tank. The tang is not large at all. Great color, great appetite, 0 aggression, he must like it more that folks want him to. If he gets too large I will give him to one of many people with bigger tanks in my local club. It’s not like he is in a 50 gallon... he is fine.

Love the suggestions! I’ve done a tiger shrimp with a goby before, wasn’t too entertaining for me. My goby is always out, especially in the evening. He is my favorite. I don’t want to but a shrimp in there with him. Plus I was always rescuing the shrimp from the sock. The coris wrasse didn’t like him either.

On the diamond goby. Most of the sand is mature, but he eats pellets and reef frenzy too. All the fish are great eaters in the tank.

The stock list that is current won’t change, I was just curious on people’s thoughts. Got what I asked for. . Anyway, everyone in the tank is pals. I was more seeing one an additional recommendation might be. I wouldn’t remove one to add others, just not my thing. I’d keep it at the current load most likely.

Thanks everyone.

It's likely the 6 line is fine because it hasn't yet reached maturity. Once they mature they tend to get fairly aggressive and can be a pain to trap and remove because they are small and very quick/agile. People have had to remove them from 200-300 gallon tanks so the warning and concern is well deserved. They also tend not to take kindly to new additions once they get established so it can be a pain if you want to add more fish. Not saying it can't be done, just saying be aware.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top