Got it. If you didn't change anything around, the IN will actually read into the DI resin. That 40-60 number would be extremely high. If you confirm that to be the case, here are a few things to check.
1- Double check that you have adequate pressure (at least 50 psi)
2- Make sure you have the flush valve in the closed position when you're making water
3- You may also want to measure your waste to product ratio to make sure that your membrane is functioning as intended. If you have a single membrane, you should see about 3-4 gallons of waste water per 1 gallon of product water. If you have a water saver system, you'll see about 1.5-2 gallons waste to 1 gallon product. The exact amount of waste may vary slightly with higher or lower pressure, but you should be pretty close to that range.
One last note if you don't find any of those issues...Making short bursts of water like a gallon or two at a time will increase the DI consumption dramatically. When you first turn on the system, there will be a little TDS creep. All that means is that there is a little burst of higher TDS water that enters the DI resin upon startup. If you turn the system on and then immediately look at the TDS meter, you'll likely see a higher TDS reading than you would if you let the system run for an hour.