A lesson learnt.

  • Thread starter Thread starter atoll
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

atoll

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
4,754
Reaction score
8,155
Location
Wales UK
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
After 36 years in this hobby, I find I still make the odd mistake.
Case in question. Most the many fish in my reef tank are small to medium size, sizes range from 1.1/2" to around 3.1/2" some of which will grow larger with time. The fish that seems to like to think itself as number one in the tank is my Midas blenny although my Regal Angel might challenge that not that there has ever been any confrontation between them. About 6 weeks ago I made a mistake purchase by buying a Purple tang. I have always liked Purple tangs and when I saw a nice one advertised for sale on another forum I agreed to buy it. Now when I saw it it was much bigger than I anticipated and bigger than described which is something of a first IME. Anyway, I still bought it and introduced it into my tank.

This, as it turned was a mistake not that the tang bothered any other fish nor anything challenged it far from it, it settled in well quickly but something was just not right. Firstly the tang was out of proportion with the rest of the inhabitants, secondly, it spent a lot of time bathing in the output of my Tunze pump, thirdly it just didn't fit in with the rest of my fish. What was particularly strange was that the Midas blenny which spent most of the time cruising around out in the open area of my reefscape became reclusive rarely venturing out from the rear of the reefsacpe and I hardly saw it apart from when the tank was fed. I repeat I never witnessed any aggression between the tang and the Midas nor any other fish. However, you could tell my other fish were in awe of the tang and always moved out if it's way.

After a few weeks, it became clear I had made a mistake buying the tang and that it would be best if I could find a new home for it. Luckily I found a guy with a. 8' tank who was looking for such a fish and after I had a few chats with him to make sure he was a suitable owner I sold it on to him. Once gone my tank almost instantly went back to being more harmonious, the Midas returned to normal and the tank is so much calmer and in proportion again. I am not proud of my mistake as I let my heart rule my head so I hope I have learnt my lesson once and for all.
 
Been there, done that. (And of just this past weekend) Went to my trusted LFS looking for a wrasse for my tank and came home with one, not the one I was wanting, but a blue star leopard. It's doing really great, eating flake and frozen with gusto, but I my wife wanted a Mandarin and I came home with one of those too. Doing well also.

Case in point, sometimes we do things we just hadn't planned on, in my case it worked out, but I've been down that road were I got a fish I knew wasn't right and paid for it big time in the long run.
 
Been there, done that. (And of just this past weekend) Went to my trusted LFS looking for a wrasse for my tank and came home with one, not the one I was wanting, but a blue star leopard. It's doing really great, eating flake and frozen with gusto, but I my wife wanted a Mandarin and I came home with one of those too. Doing well also.

Case in point, sometimes we do things we just hadn't planned on, in my case it worked out, but I've been down that road were I got a fish I knew wasn't right and paid for it big time in the long run.
In my case I should have known better. When I went to collect it I should have let the guy down. The fact it was a beautiful specimen and a bargain ruled my head. At least it was easy to catch and went to a good home.
 
I appreciate an experienced reefer that is willing to admit to making mistakes. I'm new and have so much to learn.

Your at the right place. We all have made mistakes, some unplanned and ill informed and others planned and just wasn't right. Having a plan "B" is always a good thing.
 
I should have simply have known better, in fact, I did but ignored my head when I went to collect it. My tank is far from small (100gallons) However in truth, I am disappointed in myself as purchasing such a large specimen (around 5" plus) it went against my ethos towards reefkeeping. We all make mistakes and learn from them or at least should do, it won't happen again.
 
I should have simply have known better, in fact, I did but ignored my head when I went to collect it. My tank is far from small (100gallons) However in truth, I am disappointed in myself as purchasing such a large specimen (around 5" plus) it went against my ethos towards reefkeeping. We all make mistakes and learn from them or at least should do, it won't happen again.
it will probably happen again. But even in 300 gallons a fish not the right size may cause an abnormal balance. I keep thinking I want to add another tang to my six I already have. I had a Kole tang bought at the same time as a couple others. He seemed to be doing okay but there seemed to be a nervousness in the activity of all the fish. The kole starting hiding in a corner only a few days after I get it. He would leave to eat and go right back. about six days after feeding I seen him eating but less than 2 hours later found him dead under some rock. Got it pulled out then all the nervousness in the tank disappeared. So no more tangs for me.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top