A thread for the dead.... RIP corals

  • Thread starter Thread starter SAPPER
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

SAPPER

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 14, 2018
Messages
362
Reaction score
779
Location
Durham, UK
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
What LPS corals where you proud of owning but lost them. I made a huge mistake of using some salt from a reefer that shut his tank down. My eyes lit up thinking free salt, but after doing two water changes my nitrate went over 100ppm. I lost candy canes and a Euphyllia hammer and two Acan Lord frags etc... straight away. My two Acan Echinata corals tried to hold on. But by the time I got my nitrate down to around 25ppm it was too late. All I have left of the LPS I had are these photos.

20160925_215129-01.jpeg


20170206_175005-01.jpeg


20170116_143701-01.jpeg


20170402_173638-01.jpeg


20170703_213602-01.jpeg


20170722_182117_004_01-01.jpeg


20160731_193502-01.jpeg
 
I have never seen a prettier Acan Enhinata as the one in the last image. Those were some stunning LPS. :-(.
 
I think of myself as a strong who did 9 years in the British Army..... I cried less when I stubbed my toe and made my nail bed bleed, but I was absolutely gutted that I lost them. They were well looked after and fed well.
 
What LPS corals where you proud of owning but lost them. I made a huge mistake of using some salt from a reefer that shut his tank down. My eyes lit up thinking free salt, but after doing two water changes my nitrate went over 100ppm. I lost candy canes and a Euphyllia hammer and two Acan Lord frags etc... straight away. My two Acan Echinata corals tried to hold on. But by the time I got my nitrate down to around 25ppm it was too late. All I have left of the LPS I had are these photos.

Absolutely stunning photographs, btw. Well done, and I'm sorry for your loss. So, my question is; what brand of salt caused your nitrates to shoot up to 100ppm? If this were a commercially available brand, this is something the rest of use would like to know. Did you test a batch of newly made saltwater (mixed with 0 tds rodi) to verify that it was indeed the salt?
 
Absolutely stunning photographs, btw. Well done, and I'm sorry for your loss. So, my question is; what brand of salt caused your nitrates to shoot up to 100ppm? If this were a commercially available brand, this is something the rest of use would like to know. Did you test a batch of newly made saltwater (mixed with 0 tds rodi) to verify that it was indeed the salt?

No doubt. Assuming a 20% water change, the salt must have been at 500 ppm!
 
It was salt I would never think of using, Kent. It had lumpy salt in and I removed them and gave it no thought. It probably soaked up water and went bad. When I went back to Red Sea salt after a few changes it came down.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top