Adding T5 / T5HO to 47" tank with 2 Kessil A360WE's

TinyChocobo

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
May 11, 2016
Messages
708
Reaction score
352
What state or country do you live in
Indiana
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello!

I have a Red Sea Reefer XL 425 which is 47" by 23" and I'm thinking I would like to add at least a couple of T5 bulbs. My old 29 Gallon ran with this:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002LTL4SK/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I loved how my corals grew / the tank looked but the issue was that it was very bulky and made doing any real work on the tank a pain. I was often taking it off the tank and setting it aside to do anything at all beyond looking at the tank.

I have been looking at the Aquatic Life hybrids and, while they look good on paper, I'm seeing a lot of reviews that it's 'cheaply made' or 'not built to last' and that the T5 fixtures are 'cheap'.

Don't get me wrong - cheap is good from the saving money standpoint - but anything I set-up I want to last as long as possible. I do understand that the bulbs have to be changed from time to time - but - this hybrid setup does look the cleanest.

If I were to not go with the hybrid set-up - what advice would you have in regards to adding T5 to the tank? I imagine I could get a pair of dual T5 fixtures and build some sort of mount for them but I can't help but guess that my DIY solution would likely not look as neat/clean as the hybrid setup from AL.

Is AL really the only hybrid out-of-the-box option?
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
That is the only one that I know of... but I am not tuned into this stuff. I saw some at a show recently... they are fine units... not built like a tank or anything, but seemed fine.

There are 2 bulb T5 retrofit kits - you could get one or two of them. They have semi-rigid reflectors and can mount pretty well to a structure that you make.

You could make a structure of your own out of T Track, or the like. You can build a wall-mount, or floor mount rack to raise and lower the lights if you want.

I would not go all-in on this setup at first... once you see what the T5s can do, you might start to wonder why you are supplementing your T5s with such expensive Kessils and might just want 2 more T5 bulbs and then get a 6/8 bulb ATI. ...or you might hate the T5s and want to just get a few more Kessils for better coverage. While people oft think that this is "best of both worlds" it does not work out that way and can be "worst of both worlds" where you are not invested all the way in anything... kinda like having a football team with 2 quarterbacks. ...or you just might love the hybrid and want to upgrade it. Everybody is different here, but if you are unsure, then don't tie yourself down with too much cash at first.
 
I liked my AquaticLife T5HO setup a lot - but did not like that I could not ramp up and ramp down - which I missed from my freshwater LED setups.

That said I also really like the shimmer of the Kessil's and my SPS seems to be doing well under them - I just don't have the even coverage I'd like to have.

What I imagine I'd do with the hybrid setup is ramp up the LEDs, then turn on the T5's, and then turn off the T5's and ramp down the LEDs. I'd leave the LEDs on while the T5's were on to add that 'shimmer' you don't really get from T5s alone.

The alternative was to just go all-in with more Kessils for more even lighting and just turn down the intensity a bit - but I'm thinking that would intensify the shimmer quite a bit as that seems to really come from the point lighting where as the T5s are more of a diffuse source that won't result in as much shimmer.

I like the shimmer - but would be OK if it was tuned down a bit :P.
 
Hello!

I have a Red Sea Reefer XL 425 which is 47" by 23" and I'm thinking I would like to add at least a couple of T5 bulbs. My old 29 Gallon ran with this:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002LTL4SK/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I loved how my corals grew / the tank looked but the issue was that it was very bulky and made doing any real work on the tank a pain. I was often taking it off the tank and setting it aside to do anything at all beyond looking at the tank.

I have been looking at the Aquatic Life hybrids and, while they look good on paper, I'm seeing a lot of reviews that it's 'cheaply made' or 'not built to last' and that the T5 fixtures are 'cheap'.

Don't get me wrong - cheap is good from the saving money standpoint - but anything I set-up I want to last as long as possible. I do understand that the bulbs have to be changed from time to time - but - this hybrid setup does look the cleanest.

If I were to not go with the hybrid set-up - what advice would you have in regards to adding T5 to the tank? I imagine I could get a pair of dual T5 fixtures and build some sort of mount for them but I can't help but guess that my DIY solution would likely not look as neat/clean as the hybrid setup from AL.

Is AL really the only hybrid out-of-the-box option?
The aquatic life is the only hybrid option that I know of that allows you to add your own LED module instead of coming with leds already built in. Aside from building something. I currently have the 36 inch AL fixture with the Kessil ap700 and it's been doing great. No issues to speak of. And the fixture, while it may seem cheaply built, is actually pretty sturdy. The only complaint I have about the unit is the cord configuration. But I've since modified that :)
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
What modifications did you do to the cabling? My cabling 'behind the scenes' is a mess but I try to keep what is visible clean/neat.
 
I have seen way cheaper and less sturdy builds than the AL hybrid fixture. You can certainly do worse. I would not let build quality steer your decision on this option.
 
I have seen way cheaper and less sturdy builds than the AL hybrid fixture. You can certainly do worse. I would not let build quality steer your decision on this option.
I'm more concerned with durability than the appearance of high build quality TBH. I.e. I don't want to deal with having to replace the ballasts, etc. While I can do that - I don't want to have to :).
 
I am setting up a 120 gallon and I am going to run Two Kessil A360WE and two double bulb retrofit t-5. There are several retrofits out there made by Giesemann, reefbrite etc.
 
What modifications did you do to the cabling? My cabling 'behind the scenes' is a mess but I try to keep what is visible clean/neat.
Basically with the AL fixture it has two cords, one for each fixture. You open up the unit and bridge one cord to the other fixture, making it one cord for both lights.
All done! Now I have just one cord for the t5 and one for the AP700. Thank you @Behnken for the inspiration and @Fudsey for finding the information for me :)
VmTDwAfh.jpg

nPw4Yg6h.jpg

7bOWiTwh.jpg

hA7hwNYh.jpg

qyTKidJh.jpg

4WL3J1ih.jpg

cuGjZ2mh.jpg

Nj28I4Qh.jpg

Wd6MjSah.jpg
 
I can take pictures of my Kessil 360/T5 lighting monstrosity if you'd like. lol
Sure :).

I am setting up a 120 gallon and I am going to run Two Kessil A360WE and two double bulb retrofit t-5. There are several retrofits out there made by Giesemann, reefbrite etc.
I'll Google it but if you have any links handy, it's appreciated :).
 
Basically with the AL fixture it has two cords, one for each fixture. You open up the unit and bridge one cord to the other fixture, making it one cord for both lights.
Excellent - I'll definitely do this if I get this fixture - I'll do it before installing it :).
 
I have two, 2 bulb aquatic life fixtures that I bought about 10 years ago. I then slowly transitioned to LEDs a few years ago, but I really like what T5s bring, so I have been running a hybrid system for the last 2+ years (using my old T5 fixtures). The aquatic life T5 fixtures aren't top notch like an ATI or Giesmann, but they are good overall units considering the cost. I would not call them cheap or be concerned about the build quality. If you're wanting the T5 to supplement your LEDs, you don't necessarily need the very best. If you were wanting your T5s to be your main light and just have some LED to provide shimmer and dusk / dawn type effects, then I think it would make more sense to get a better end unit and more bulbs (like an 8 bulb ATI). But if you're wanting the T5s to tone the shimmer down, reduce some shadowing, and just provide some additional par, the aquatic life hybrid would be a fine option.

In retrospect, I wish I had went with an 8 bulb ATI unit and merely added some LED strips to provide some shimmer versus being so LED heavy (so I think @jda comments earlier are valid and worth considering).
 
I have two, 2 bulb aquatic life fixtures that I bought about 10 years ago. I then slowly transitioned to LEDs a few years ago, but I really like what T5s bring, so I have been running a hybrid system for the last 2+ years (using my old T5 fixtures). The aquatic life T5 fixtures aren't top notch like an ATI or Giesmann, but they are good overall units considering the cost. I would not call them cheap or be concerned about the build quality. If you're wanting the T5 to supplement your LEDs, you don't necessarily need the very best. If you were wanting your T5s to be your main light and just have some LED to provide shimmer and dusk / dawn type effects, then I think it would make more sense to get a better end unit and more bulbs (like an 8 bulb ATI). But if you're wanting the T5s to tone the shimmer down, reduce some shadowing, and just provide some additional par, the aquatic life hybrid would be a fine option.

In retrospect, I wish I had went with an 8 bulb ATI unit and merely added some LED strips to provide some shimmer versus being so LED heavy (so I think @jda comments earlier are valid and worth considering).
I’m not heavily invested in LED and could go with a T5 fixture that incorporates LEDs for dusk/dawn and some shimmer.

I’ll have to look and see what’s out there. I’ll look at ATI and Geissman for sure.
 
Im running aquatic life t5 hybrids with my 4 mitras and love the setup.
 
I’m not heavily invested in LED and could go with a T5 fixture that incorporates LEDs for dusk/dawn and some shimmer.

I’ll have to look and see what’s out there. I’ll look at ATI and Geissman for sure.

I'd highly recommend you go look at other people's tanks IN PERSON. I wouldn't worry about which fixture at this point. You want to try to figure out if you want to go T5 only, hybrid, or maybe LED only. Pictures on here are good but can't replace looking at a tank in person. Find someone in your area running a T5 / LED hybrid system and go take a look. Try not to focus on the "color" of the tank, as you can fine tune the tank to a color you want with a proper T5 bulb combination and / or by tuning your LED's how you want. You want to try to view the tank with an eye for the diffuse nature of the light source, the shimmer effect, shading, and so on. For example, some people think T5's look "flat", some people think LED shimmer is too much, some people don't like the shading of LED only, etc... You can look at the tank with just the T5's on, just the LED's on, and the combination. It will help solidify which route you want to go (i.e. T5 only or hybrid or maybe you will decide to go all LED).
 
I’ve had tank with T5 HO and a tank with LED only but never hybrid.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top