Algae Turf Scrubber -vs- Algae Reactor

I just don't get how, if an ats grows gha, none of the spores end up in the display, unless you're running uv also. It seems like it's lacking containment of the algae. Because micro can travel and grow wherever.

You had low nitrates and phosphates to begin with in general. So I get that the ats is taking that up. But for someone with higher nitrates, the display would easily be able to start growing any released spores of the gha.

A turf scrubber lets water pass right through, right? There's no foam or fine mesh screen in place to block anything released? Because anything short of a foam pad will let spores through, unless it's harvested before it can spore? I don't know, which is why I'm curious. How does it keep the micro algae from spreading?

My NO3 was 20ppm and PO4 at 0.04 prior to putting my Atlantis on I don't consider those figures "low" I was running another much cheaper ATS but the lighting wasn't up to the job and growing algae quickly enough to bring my nutrients down to acceptable levels, well acceptable to me and where I wanted them to be.
The idea behind an ATS is to outcompete GHA outside of it as in the DT using lighting targeted at growing algae IE lots of red in the spectrum. BTW I don't run UV.
Water is passed over the screen in a thin layer rather than through it. The interface of water and light creates ideal conditions to grow algae much better than in the DT and in doing so reduces the nutrients. The whole idea is to grow algae where you want it and where it can easily be harvested.
I grow at least 3 types of algae on the screen of my ATS not just GHA ones of those algae I have not been able to identify the other is Ulva intestinalis a very quick growing algae which appears to take up nutrients extremely quickly EG it grows on my screen at the rate of at around 1.5" in 24hours. Outcompeting for the available nutrients is the key to keeping GHA out of the DT or reducing/eliminating it in the DT.
 
For those running ATS, what lights are you using on yours?

Many come with the lights. I have a Turbo scrubber and like many it comes with the LEDs preinstalled and ready to run. If you mean lights on a DIY ATS then there are many to choose from.
 
I liked everything about my algae reactor, apart from service time... trying to empty and service it was always a nightmare of puddles and towels! Ended up dropping it out... ATS look like much easier maintenance if you can fit!
 
I liked everything about my algae reactor, apart from service time... trying to empty and service it was always a nightmare of puddles and towels! Ended up dropping it out... ATS look like much easier maintenance if you can fit!
Takes me 4 minutes ( yes I have timed it) to harvest my waterfall ATS.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top