Almost Killed All My Fish

ReefSCTim

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
May 2, 2018
Messages
59
Reaction score
28
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have 9 fish: 2 Chromis, 3 pajamas, 2 clowns, 1 lawnmower blenny and 1 file fish. I originally had about 13 corals. Had just tested my water yesterday am and all parameters were spot on except magnesium which was 1680. My 75 gal tank is 6 months old and is cured, with good coralline growth. 35 gal sump with roller, skimmer and refugium.

Later in day, I went to LFS for second test and to ask about magnesium. Parameters matched but they don’t test for magnesium. They suggested bringing alk and calcium up slightly to reduce mag. They were having a 50% off coral sale so I thought why not?

I bought five corals. 2 chalice, 1 Zoa, 1 flavia, and a flower pot coral. As always, I did my dipping process. 10 mins in Bayer insect killer, 5 in saltwater, 5 in RODI water, 5 in separate new saltwater three times. I swish them around in the process. Then added them directly to the display. I know some will say this is where you quarantine but I don’t. Never have.

I also added for first time a sample of the LFS's Reef lemonade. And fed the guys Reef Frenzy for first time as well, in place of their usual mysis shrimp.

I then left for dinner for the evening. Got back late and tank lights were almost out. Almost missed it, but noticed a Chromi darting around the tank which was suspect. Turned up lights. All the other fish except blenny were acting strange as well. A few quick tests including copper were fine.

Suspected Bayer insect killer. I am thinking that one of the chalices was recently fragged and absorbed the Bayer? It is the only coral that died during the evening.

Stayed up to middle of night. Added charcoal filters and did numerous water changes. This morning all fish are still alive. May do another water change but suspect that time needed to heal wounds. Fish appear calmer today. Worried about clowns since they are so small. All other corals appear ok now.

Feel bad enough so go easy. Hate they suffered and hope there are no long term effects. Really like those guys. Any thoughts?
 
I would never put corals in rodi (or any freshwater), that probably killed the chalice. Corals can't take freshwater dips for that long. Otherwise everything looks fine. I would be surprised if any bayer got through after that. Just keep an eye on it and you did everything right except the rodi bath. Bayer may hurt invertebrates, but fish shouldn't be affected.
 
I would never put corals in rodi (or any freshwater), that probably killed the chalice. Corals can't take freshwater dips for that long. Otherwise everything looks fine. I would be surprised if any bayer got through after that. Just keep an eye on it and you did everything right except the rodi bath. Bayer may hurt invertebrates, but fish shouldn't be affected.
What are you talking about???Bayer will kill fish.
 
Doesnt really sound like anything was wrong to be honest... sounds like the fish was spooked and the other fish were acting weird because they were all ready for night and you turned the lights back on. You do that entire dipping process 5 times?? Definitely never dip coral/inverts in RODI water. That will kill them, especially more delicate corals. A Bayer dip and rinse with saltwater should be as good as itll get.
 
First off, while your mag was slightly high, no big deal at all, and that would have come back down on it's own.

Many people have raised mag much higher to combat bryopsis, including myself a number of times higher than your number.

I don't know why your LFS would suggest raising alk and Cal for this reason, and in fact alk swing would do more harm than high mag. (I also think they got it backwards, pretty sure lower alk would drop mag levels, as usually we have problems raising mag if alk is low)

I don't see any issues other than I agree to not dip corals in RO/DI
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top