Another Dino victim....Finally getting the upper hand

DenverSaltyFarm

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 16, 2018
Messages
635
Reaction score
2,149
Location
Denver
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Well over a year and I finally found out what I have Dino’s!! I wouldn’t wish this on my worst enemy’s tank. This all started a year ago beginner reefer had a 25 gallon tank that had. I bought some coral frags from a local show and my nightmare began.
I always dip my frags in coral Rx and does a great job killing bugs it does not kill Dino’s. After about a week of placing frags into tank I got what I thought was brown algae I religiously did weekly water changes scraping the brown algae off only to have it come back a day later in full effect. I thought my tank was just a dirty tank and this is what I would live with.
My corals had the colors but did not extend very well or grow a whole lot, but they were alive and still had colors. I eventually upgraded to my current tank a 125 gallon and went all out with the equipment. I seeded the tank with a big chunk of rock “big mistake” and seeded my tank with a healthy dose of Dino’s from my old tank. I thought I was getting new tank syndrome and brown diatoms, but found a pic of Dino’s I knew this was the plague I had. I looked under microscope and sure enough this is what I have.

TREATMENT,
I tried what I feel like is everything. Dirty tank method, blackouts, manual removal, uv sterilizer, clean tank method and nothing was working. I finally switched to hydrogen peroxide 1ml to every 10 gallons and thought hell ya I’m finally killing them by knocking the outbreak down by half then a complete stall happened they slowly started to spread again so I upped my dose to 3ml every 10 gallons and nothing got better. The dosing all happened at night where they are supposedly free swimming and still not working. I also tried scraping everything in my tank trying to get it all in the water column and then heavy h2o2 dose thinking I would wipe them out but started growing all over again. This strain of Dino’s puts a nasty smell in the water that I can guarantee is toxic. I read that Dino’s when attacked can form a cyst and protect itself from treatments which I feel happened. At this point I have 5 corals and 3 fish and ready to break everything down to get out of the hobby, I read the risky treatment of using bleach. People say there is no escaping bleach for Dino’s you just have to hope you don’t lose livestock. I’m just about 4 days in and finally see an end to this nightmare. I did however lose 2 small fish but everything else seems to be doing fine. The horrible smell in the water column is gone for a first time and everything is opening up again. I will have to reseed my bacteria and pods when I’m done treating the tank but well worth it to get this cured.

I just wanted to share my story in hopes of keeping someone ready to pull the plug on everything to give the bleach method a shot if you got nothing to lose (your last resort), you will get through the battle. I think I have the worst type of Dino’s possible that nothing could kill

From now on every piece of coral I buy gets a bleach dip. This was a hard lesson learned and something I hope you all don’t have to go through
 
Well over a year and I finally found out what I have Dino’s!! I wouldn’t wish this on my worst enemy’s tank. This all started a year ago beginner reefer had a 25 gallon tank that had. I bought some coral frags from a local show and my nightmare began.
I always dip my frags in coral Rx and does a great job killing bugs it does not kill Dino’s. After about a week of placing frags into tank I got what I thought was brown algae I religiously did weekly water changes scraping the brown algae off only to have it come back a day later in full effect. I thought my tank was just a dirty tank and this is what I would live with.
My corals had the colors but did not extend very well or grow a whole lot, but they were alive and still had colors. I eventually upgraded to my current tank a 125 gallon and went all out with the equipment. I seeded the tank with a big chunk of rock “big mistake” and seeded my tank with a healthy dose of Dino’s. I thought I was getting new tank syndrome and brown diatoms, but found a pic of Dino’s I knew this was the plague I had. I looked under microscope and sure enough this is what I have.

TREATMENT,
I tried what I feel like is everything. Dirty tank method, blackouts, manual removal, uv sterilizer, clean tank method and nothing was working. I finally switched to hydrogen peroxide 1ml to every 10 gallons and thought hell ya I’m finally killing them by knocking the outbreak down by half then a complete stall happened they slowly started to spread again so I upped my dose to 3ml every 10 gallons and nothing got better. The dosing all happened at night where they are supposedly free swimming and still not working. I also tried scraping everything in my tank trying to get it all in the water column and then heavy h2o2 dose thinking I would wipe them out but started growing all over again. This strain of Dino’s puts a nasty smell in the water that I can guarantee is toxic. I read that Dino’s when attacked can for a cyst and protect itself from treatments which I feel happened. At this point I have 5 corals and 3 fish and ready to break everything down to get out of the hobby, I read the risky treatment of using bleach. People say there is no escaping bleach for Dino’s you just have to hope you don’t lose livestock. I’m just about 4 days in and finally see an end to this nightmare. I did however lose 2 small fish but everything else seems to be doing fine. The horrible smell in the water column is gone for a first time and everything is opening up again. I will have to reseed my bacteria and pods when I’m done treating the tank but well worth it to get this cured.

I just wanted to share my story in hopes of keeping someone ready to pull the plug on everything to give the bleach method a shot if you got nothing to lose (your last resort), you will get through the battle. I think I have the worst type of Dino’s possible that nothing could kill

From now on every piece of coral I buy gets a bleach dip. This was a hard lesson learned and something I hope you all don’t have to go through

Sorry you had to go through this but THANK YOU for sharing your experience cause it can help others for sure.
 
Hey Jamie I found the formula on an old thread here I forgot who wrote it. I used the formula .003/.06* gallons in your system. The .003 is the constant and the .06 is the rating you will find on chlorox bleach. Very important not to use the anti drip bleach or with added scents. Just use the normal chlorox. My water volume is 125 gallons and math works out to 6.25 ml of bleach dosed to my tank every 12hrs. This is pretty much the max dose I would use. Instantly after dosing the corals will close up but will recover within the hr. I did lose 2 small fish but nothing else and like I said a total last resort and might be worth starting at a lower dose. After I pretty much killed all the Dino’s I have started to dirty up the tank to get other algae’s to take a foot hold and prevent the Dino’s from coming back. I used sodium nitrate solution to get my nitrates very high around 80 and also dosing Red Sea reef energy. Coral looks great and now growing lots of diatoms so will be getting a strong clean up crew in the next few days to keep things healthy.
I did notice when my Dino’s were at their worst my phosphates were at .02 an nitrates at 0 nothing feeding the tank heavy never made a dent on those numbers so using something like sodium nitrate I think is a fast solution to get nitrates to climb so other organisms can compete. I also am holding off on dosing nitrifying bacteria because I need this water dirty
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top