anyone on R2R do FW & SW?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Devaji
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
425 litre salt.
90 litre fresh.
21000 litre Koi pond.

The FW tank is a basic planted set up. Virtually zero maintenance other than occasional water changes and as it's not hit by sunshine, very occasional glass cleaning.
Koi pond has filter cleans/purges every couple of weeks. Other than that and feeding it looks after itself.
Both of the above highlight the effort involved in saltwater!!
 
Three salt and three fresh. Fresh are American cichlids, two fowlr and a reef.
nice!
It all started in FW, then i started dabbling in SW, and as of a couple of years ago it's now fully SW.

Funny thing is, I find SW infinitely easier than FW. Easier to keep nutrients under control... maybe a bit too easy if my recent dino troubles are any indication.

as I learn more about planted FW I had the same thought.
 
I have three salt tanks, one being a 125 with butterflies. On the freshwater side, I have a 125 with Lake Malawi mbuna cichlids and a 70 with small Malawi Haps. There is also a small pond outside with goldfish.

and there is my delemia I got the 200 for a FOWLR that was going to focus on butterflies. something I have wanted to do for years.

but aslo wanted to nice FW planted. I think the FW planted might be a bit less work in the long run, maybe right now it feels like a lot more.
 
Yeah, you could say I have some freshwater tanks… only 4 of them! They are just so easy to take care of that it it really nice! And if you aquascape them nicely they can be really beautiful!!
 
any of you Fw guys run a sump with your system?
can you show me what do did with it?


Yeah, you could say I have some freshwater tanks… only 4 of them! They are just so easy to take care of that it it really nice! And if you aquascape them nicely they can be really beautiful!!
well show em I love the look of aquascaped FW planted tanks.
 
I’m the process of trying to add some red to my tank. I love this tank, I haven’t had to clean the glass in over a year, this tank basically manages itself.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1637.png
    IMG_1637.png
    726.5 KB · Views: 40
  • IMG_1636.png
    IMG_1636.png
    724.9 KB · Views: 34
  • IMG_1635.png
    IMG_1635.png
    757.8 KB · Views: 33
My wife and I set up a 90g planted cube about 9 years ago. We set it up for livebearers and Cardinal tetras. Ha ving seen some of the stunning planted tanks I went all in and invested in all the "kit" for the 90g cube.

6 Months in of C02, fertilizers and vitamins and the planted tank was more maintenance then a 400g reef. I had lots of stem plants and they could grow 10" in 10 days. Even with a 28" tall tank it was constantly and overgrown jungle and not the tank I envisioned.

2016-07-30 21.20.25.jpg



So I stopped all the additives and CO2. I have an RO/DI dedicated for the tank and it turns on for 20mins every morning acting as a topoff and at the same time a water change. I have a pipe in the overflow that drains to the sewer.

With the automated feeder on this tank I only touch this tank every month to refill the feeder and do equipment maintenance once a year.


When we redid our floors this past winter in moving the 90g out of the house a seam opened up on the tank. Interestingly with the tank drained to move it the tank leaked. We filled it back up with water to save the plants and stuff while we figured out what to do with a leaking tank (it was outside on a back patio) and when the tank was filled back up the seam closed itself up and the tank was water tight. Not even a seep.

But it was too much of a risk to bring it back into the house so we had a new 113g cube built out of starfire.

Dave B
 
any of you Fw guys run a sump with your system?
can you show me what do did with it?



well show em I love the look of aquascaped FW planted tanks.
No, I do not run sumps, I am in the process of reaquascaping 2 of them, I will post the other two
Edit: here they are!
IMG_0919.jpeg
IMG_0920.jpeg
IMG_0921.jpeg
 
any of you Fw guys run a sump with your system?
can you show me what do did with it?



well show em I love the look of aquascaped FW planted tanks.
I ran sumps in both my high tech planted and my low tech piranha tank. Not a whole lot to show though.....I basically used it to store the heater, probes, and filter media. It removed a lot of Co2 which I was using a lot of, but it was worth it to be able to hide as much equipment as possible and have a place for the biological media.
 
My wife and I set up a 90g planted cube about 9 years ago. We set it up for livebearers and Cardinal tetras. Ha ving seen some of the stunning planted tanks I went all in and invested in all the "kit" for the 90g cube.

6 Months in of C02, fertilizers and vitamins and the planted tank was more maintenance then a 400g reef. I had lots of stem plants and they could grow 10" in 10 days. Even with a 28" tall tank it was constantly and overgrown jungle and not the tank I envisioned.

2016-07-30 21.20.25.jpg



So I stopped all the additives and CO2. I have an RO/DI dedicated for the tank and it turns on for 20mins every morning acting as a topoff and at the same time a water change. I have a pipe in the overflow that drains to the sewer.

With the automated feeder on this tank I only touch this tank every month to refill the feeder and do equipment maintenance once a year.


When we redid our floors this past winter in moving the 90g out of the house a seam opened up on the tank. Interestingly with the tank drained to move it the tank leaked. We filled it back up with water to save the plants and stuff while we figured out what to do with a leaking tank (it was outside on a back patio) and when the tank was filled back up the seam closed itself up and the tank was water tight. Not even a seep.

But it was too much of a risk to bring it back into the house so we had a new 113g cube built out of starfire.

Dave B

wow crazy I have never heard of a tank sealing it self. I hear ya on the maintenance it can get out of hand. my tank will ne non co2 and easy slow growing plants.
 
My wife and I set up a 90g planted cube about 9 years ago. We set it up for livebearers and Cardinal tetras. Ha ving seen some of the stunning planted tanks I went all in and invested in all the "kit" for the 90g cube.

6 Months in of C02, fertilizers and vitamins and the planted tank was more maintenance then a 400g reef. I had lots of stem plants and they could grow 10" in 10 days. Even with a 28" tall tank it was constantly and overgrown jungle and not the tank I envisioned.

2016-07-30 21.20.25.jpg



So I stopped all the additives and CO2. I have an RO/DI dedicated for the tank and it turns on for 20mins every morning acting as a topoff and at the same time a water change. I have a pipe in the overflow that drains to the sewer.

With the automated feeder on this tank I only touch this tank every month to refill the feeder and do equipment maintenance once a year.


When we redid our floors this past winter in moving the 90g out of the house a seam opened up on the tank. Interestingly with the tank drained to move it the tank leaked. We filled it back up with water to save the plants and stuff while we figured out what to do with a leaking tank (it was outside on a back patio) and when the tank was filled back up the seam closed itself up and the tank was water tight. Not even a seep.

But it was too much of a risk to bring it back into the house so we had a new 113g cube built out of starfire.

Dave B
I had a similar issue with growth, I backed the CO2 down significantly and was able to dial the growth to a manageable amount. I got a Milwaukee PH controller and can manage the growth by not driving the PH down to low via the CO2. The controller portion of that device has too much drift to be really accurate, but I now can figure out the bubble count needed to keep it in a certain range. I love how maintenance free this tank is. My reef tank isn’t anywhere this easy, lol. Unless you count that time I accidentally gassed my fish and had to bring them back to life… whooooopssssie.
 
and there is my delemia I got the 200 for a FOWLR that was going to focus on butterflies. something I have wanted to do for years.

but aslo wanted to nice FW planted. I think the FW planted might be a bit less work in the long run, maybe right now it feels like a lot more.
The 125 with butterflies and the 125 with Lake Malawi cichlids are the exact opposite when it comes to care. A lot of times, new butterflies are very picky when it comes to food and they cannot compete with the long time established fish. Mine get fed three times a day. Then, there is the sudden death, where they come in fat and happy for a few weeks then you find the new fish dead for no reason. With the Lake Malawi fish, once or twice a day, a hand full of food is thrown in, then you watch them go crazy. They do best overcrowded, about fifty fish. The big ones constantly breed, finding babies in the rocks every few days. As for decorations, there are rocks, big driftwood and Anubias plants.
 
Here's the bigger of the two FW tanks we have going :star-struck:
 

Attachments

  • WhatsApp Image 2023-09-22 at 14.25.45.jpg
    WhatsApp Image 2023-09-22 at 14.25.45.jpg
    276 KB · Views: 30
  • WhatsApp Image 2023-09-22 at 14.23.51.jpg
    WhatsApp Image 2023-09-22 at 14.23.51.jpg
    184.4 KB · Views: 37
My wife is into planted freshwater. There’s not enough to keep me busy with FW. Although I was considering setting up a pea puffer tank as I really like those guys.
 
Here's the bigger of the two FW tanks we have going :star-struck:
nice! I love the plant boxes I was thinking of having plants come out of the top of the tank too. classic looks good and helps with filtration. where did you get them or did you make '
em?
Me too. 2 salt, 1 fresh and 1 pond.
post what you got we all want to see. :)

My wife is into planted freshwater. There’s not enough to keep me busy with FW. Although I was considering setting up a pea puffer tank as I really like those guys.
yeah those guys are cool.
IDK with a heavily planted tank with steams and such seems like there's is a ton of maintenance. I guess one better like pruning if going that way. haha not a real option of large tanks. at least not a comfy one.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top