Anyone out there with a damsel only/heavy tank?

I have two evil fish in my tank: a YTD and diadema dottyback. They get along great and have been together for almost 2 years in a 15g. Seems like fish just have a unique personality and it's always a gamble.
 
Ok I heard that Azure Damsels were not as aggressive and I really liked their color so I bought three for my 110. About a week later two decided to pick on one I finally net the fish wasn’t hard he was exhausted and quite torn up. I put him in my 28 JBJ cube LPS grow out and observation tank. A day or two later the two remaining squared off and I netted the loser in same state as one previous and put him in my 22 nano. Now I have three Azures one in each of my tanks LOL
 
Ok I heard that Azure Damsels were not as aggressive and I really liked their color so I bought three for my 110. About a week later two decided to pick on one I finally net the fish wasn’t hard he was exhausted and quite torn up. I put him in my 28 JBJ cube LPS grow out and observation tank. A day or two later the two remaining squared off and I netted the loser in same state as one previous and put him in my 22 nano. Now I have three Azures one in each of my tanks LOL
I am sorry to hear that.
I must admit, I have never had an issue like that from my azures. Even in the confines of the QT they were fine (a 20gL with 6 azures). I have had them in frag tanks, but then it was just one due to size of tank.
What fish did you already have in there? In a 110g there should have been plenty of hiding spots for them to find right away and not bother each other.
Fish are individuals.
 
What is your favorite damselfish species?

Mine is either the springeri

1650727356676.png


or the tuxedo.

1650727390931.png


It seems like the tuxedo is peaceful too. I wonder why we never see them?
 
I tried a trio of tuxedo, but they did not make it out of qt. It was my last ever order with liveaquaria a couple years back.

Edit: not made it out of qt is overstatement as they died before day 2.
 
What is your favorite damselfish species?

Mine is either the springeri

1650727356676.png


or the tuxedo.

1650727390931.png


It seems like the tuxedo is peaceful too. I wonder why we never see them?
Springieri vivid and also yesterdays daily newsletter feature was a tank full of damsels
 
The funny thing is this is what most of us had back in the 80s when we were first starting out.
My first 55g reef was in 1988, at 14yrs old. I had dozens of different damsels as I could afford them lol. Them and also lyre tail anthia ( about a dozen) the movement in there was a sight to behold.
 
I have a blue devil all alone in my tank for about 8 months. I added a lyretail anthia and he picked on him for a few weeks then they were swimming buddies and did fine. The anthia ended up jumping but I have had that happen quite often so now keeping a lid on tank. I am thinking of adding a lemon and a azure. Only because I am placing an order and they are on sale pretty cheap. I cant decide on making a damsel only tank or adding the azure to my other tank only because I dont want two blue damsels in one because they look so similar and only want 4 fish. Would it be a problem to add 2 more other fish like my 2 clowns to the tank after having the lemon and the figi blue devil? Or would it be smarter to keep the lemon, azure blue devil and maybe down the road pick up one more of the more peaceful ones. The blue devils arent considered one of the more peaceful ones and will bite my hand sometimes but honestly he was fine when the tank was a community and also calmed down after a few weeks with the anthia.
 
I have a blue devil all alone in my tank for about 8 months. I added a lyretail anthia and he picked on him for a few weeks then they were swimming buddies and did fine. The anthia ended up jumping but I have had that happen quite often so now keeping a lid on tank. I am thinking of adding a lemon and a azure. Only because I am placing an order and they are on sale pretty cheap. I cant decide on making a damsel only tank or adding the azure to my other tank only because I dont want two blue damsels in one because they look so similar and only want 4 fish. Would it be a problem to add 2 more other fish like my 2 clowns to the tank after having the lemon and the figi blue devil? Or would it be smarter to keep the lemon, azure blue devil and maybe down the road pick up one more of the more peaceful ones. The blue devils arent considered one of the more peaceful ones and will bite my hand sometimes but honestly he was fine when the tank was a community and also calmed down after a few weeks with the anthia.
You didn't mention the size of your tank. Adding one or two other damsels to a tank with a single established blue may prove difficult. I personally would try to overwhelm that blue by adding as many additional fish as possible at the same time. That will spread the aggression and cause it to minimize the area it trys being territorial about.

I currently have 2 figi blues in qt waiting to go into my 400g.
 
I have 2 Fiji blues , 6 Azures and 3 Rolands in my 500g and +/- 20 yellow tail, 1 azure, and 1 Talbots in a 130g. Haven’t lost a damsel in over a year.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top