AQuarium Depot reviews

Kinda wish they were on here so we could actually here from them. I know one of their big problems on BBB is they often don’t respond to problems and complaints. They have an awesome selection and crazy prices, but their stocks health is often worse than getting all dead corals because of all the disease on them, on top of that they’re really difficult to deal with.
Agree 100% +++ I told her not to send the second shipment. She went ahead and did it anyway with no coordination. I got to where I couldn't even look at the tanks without bawling. I know, I'm a big baby. When I sent the pics they asked for of my setup, I relayed the same and said I was in the process of breaking down my tanks. After waiting and saving and planning and scrapping for almost 30 years, my dream of reefing became a nightmare. Christine told me "happy reefing." Hopefully she's just oblivious or illiterate and not actually that horrible. How's it possible to be that f@#! $&* cruel? I did finally get a refund for the shipment though.
 
I emailed them about how unliked they are and why they have such a bad reputation, they actually called me about it and we spoke on the phone for a while, they said they realized they had a been pretty bad and were going to turn it around. They said within 6 months they’d have it ready, I may try them again then, depends on how reviews of them are then.
 
I got amphipods from them. They were HUGE and plentiful. They were shipped overnight. Anything for livestock that isn't overnight shipping I would highly question. They are only 1 of like 3 sellers I know online that sells amphipod (the other being Premium Aquatics & Sustainable Aquatics). I wish another seller like Algaebarn would step it up and sell Amphipods.

I thought about getting Florida Shrooms from them, but there are a ton of negative reviews that now I'm hesitant to do so :eek:
 
I’m watching a build thread where a guy just introduced some corals from them, he didn’t dip them either. So we will see what happens I guess.
 
I bought from them twice first time was 2 day shipping and the Acro was dead the rest survived well . they quickly refunded the dead Acro ($10-)
The second order was next day shipping and all survived well
I did dip them all and had no hitchhikers
I would use them again but go with next day shipping , but that’s all sources so....
 
Well now they've jacked up their prices a lot, if they are better now I probably wouldn't use them. The intrigue was that their prices were so good.
 
I bought my clean up crew for the nano that got killed by flea spray from them. Arrived healthy all alive and well until the incident.

I just ordered from them yesterday again and it will be here tomorrow. I suspect just as good as the last order.

I will post here and let ya know!
 
Fantastic! UPS messed up and killed 4 of the snails and AD promptly refunded that amount.

Everything else worked out great.
 
Aquarium depot I’m not impressed. The box smells like horrible nasty water. I actually wanted to puke. My shrimp arrived dead and beheaded. The snails are micro which I did not know they were going to be that small. I’m afraid to add any of this to my tank! The water in the bags are green and dirty.
 
Anyone else order corals from Aquarium Depot recently? I wonder if they are actually getting any better.
 
Most of my tank has come from them. Some hit and miss. Overall for the price I can't complain
Thanks. Yeah those prices are pretty hard to beat.
Have you had to get things refunded/credited? Are they good with customer service?
 
Thanks. Yeah those prices are pretty hard to beat.
Have you had to get things refunded/credited? Are they good with customer service?
I got my candy cane and a gorg refunded. No issues but not the most polite. For me it's about shipping costs and their inventory. I'm in Florida so it's cheap shipping. Most frags are smaller than advertised. I think they are OK for what they are. My shipping has been fine. Except a few frags that were recently cut and glued came loose. Big zoa selection. Some corals look nothing like what's pictured but I hear that often about other places.
 
I got my candy cane and a gorg refunded. No issues but not the most polite. For me it's about shipping costs and their inventory. I'm in Florida so it's cheap shipping. Most frags are smaller than advertised. I think they are OK for what they are. My shipping has been fine. Except a few frags that were recently cut and glued came loose. Big zoa selection. Some corals look nothing like what's pictured but I hear that often about other places.
It's good that they did refund you, makes me feel a little better about ordering.
I've been buying a lot of Zoas lately, their selection was appealing for sure. You're right about zoas not matching pictures, thats why I try to order only from WYSIWYG sections when possible.
Thanks again for sharing your experiences.
 
It's good that they did refund you, makes me feel a little better about ordering.
I've been buying a lot of Zoas lately, their selection was appealing for sure. You're right about zoas not matching pictures, thats why I try to order only from WYSIWYG sections when possible.
Thanks again for sharing your experiences.
RDE and their passion fruit are nice. I've ordered a bunch of zoas from them verdict is still out on them. Could be my new tank and most of my corals are just now settling in. Hard to beat their 9.99 zoas.
 
Thanks. Yeah those prices are pretty hard to beat.
Have you had to get things refunded/credited? Are they good with customer service?
I've ordered many many times from them and had very good experiences. As long as you go through their process for refunds, they always give a refund for DOAs.

I am far more offended by the other online retailers selling stuff at 2-10 times the price, than I am by the occasional DOA from Aquarium Depot. It is one of the very few retailers that is not overpriced. Looking at pulling the trigger on an order right now...
 
There are 2 horrible outlets out of Florida I will personally avoid forever, no matter how enticing are their offerings, prices or promises of atonement: reef2go (or whatever name of the day) from Clearwater, FL and saltwaterfish.com from Vero Beach, FL. I don't know if these business are related, however they employ almost identical scammy business tactics. I am going to describe their modus operandi based on previous personal experience.

They offer very enticing items on their web sites at almost too good to be true prices and free shipping for orders of $150 give or take. They both give you a "DOA refund" and a 2 weeks guarantee for a store credit but NOT A REFUND in this instance (this is an important part of the scam). In addition the store credit is only redeemable with a second order. If there is a dead animal in the order where a credit has been claimed, they will deduct the price of the dead animal from your claimed credit money before giving a refund.

So here is how the scam works:

You are a first timer there, you love their offering and their incredibly "competitive" prices. You place an order for corals/fish high enough to get free shipping. They will ship the order with some decent animal, but they will make sure there are at least some in such a bad shape that will not survive.
These animals as expected will die, you are disappointed but report the loss, claim the credit and they will happily give it to you.

These store credits usually expire within 18 months, so this is usually the time frame you will place a second order to redeem your credit. Your purchase will be high enough to cover free shipping.

Again you will get a shipment of a few decent items plus some of the dead/almost dead animals they have in their tank. You will get some DOA on this subsequent order and the price of the DOA will be deducted from your claimed credit.

I suspect this is how they unload their sick/dead fish/coral to cut their cost and their losses.

In addition to the DOA you will get some almost dead items that will die within 15 days. You claim the credit and their cheerful customer service representative will again happily give it to you.

You are more than disappointed, maybe mad but... you hate to let the credit go, so you will place a new order after some time when the burn hurts less...

Bad psychology at work here...

Before you know you are hooked on an endless chain of credit/new orders until you realize that the animals you thought you were getting at incredibly low price, if they even survive, they are costing you a lot more than if you had bought from reputable places in the first place.

At this point you decide to say hell to them and the credit and hopefully you cut your losses and never return there.

In short: They do not care or have no regard whatsoever for the animals they sell/ship. They kind of count on part of the order not surviving. In this regard the ridiculous 3 days free shipping plays right into their scheme. They try to hook you up in a chain of credit-new order that never ends until you start adding your losses and you realize that those advertised great prices were just a bait.

My personal advice: Stay Away!! Don't get tempted by those nice pictures and too good to be true prices. Who will be paying the price will be you and those poor animals kept and sold with no care or regards by these unscrupulous businesses
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top