Are Copperband Butterflies reef safe?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gabeb
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

gabeb

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 8, 2018
Messages
88
Reaction score
54
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I see some conflicting info online and was wondering what some of the issues are with them and if you would recommend them in a reef or not. Also how aggressive are they? Thanks!
 
I see some conflicting info online and was wondering what some of the issues are with them and if you would recommend them in a reef or not. Also how aggressive are they? Thanks!
The main issue with them is survival, it's kind of a 50/50 chance if they'll eat and/or live
 
The main issue with them is survival, it's kind of a 50/50 chance if they'll eat and/or live

Yeah but if I observe one eating at my LFS, then there shouldn’t be an issue with that right?
 
The main issue with them is survival, it's kind of a 50/50 chance if they'll eat and/or live

Yeah but if I observe one eating at my LFS, then there shouldn’t be an issue with that right?
 
Your chances will definitely go up but it's still a bit of a gamble

What’s the gamble at that point? They stop eating?
 
What’s the gamble at that point? They stop eating?
They could, some people get lucky with their first one and it lives for years, other people don't get lucky until their 3rd or 4th one. I'm definitely not trying to discourage you from getting one, they just have a higher mortality rate than a lot of other hardier fish in the hobby
 
What’s the gamble at that point? They stop eating?
They may stop eating from the stress of being moved. They are more sensitive then other fish. I recently moved my 2 clownfish from one tank to another and it took them 4 days to start eating again and resume their normal behavior towards each other. Up to that point they ate like pigs. They are just now getting back to normal.
 
I got one (Australian Copperband) after hearing the same warnings as above. I had aiptaisia. Copperband lived & thrived in reef tank, aiptaisia died and has not been seen since!
 
They will devour your feather dusters. Not sure if you have any of those.
If you have aptasia they will hopefully get rid of them.
May not. :-(


They are difficult to acclimate.
Would recommend they are the largest fish in your tank.

They make firefish seem mean and ornery. :-(

Make sure it is eating heartily at the LFS.
Buy whatever they are feeding it.

For long term survival, more than a year, they need lots of clams.

Ours is small and I spend 10 minutes a night cutting them up and hand feeding him bits of clams off my fingertips.

If you are used to tossing in a cube of frozen then calling it good, this is not to fish you are looking for. :-)

If hand feeding your annoying, finicky fish sounds like fun then definitely recommend it. :-)
 
They will devour your feather dusters. Not sure if you have any of those.
If you have aptasia they will hopefully get rid of them.
May not. :-(


They are difficult to acclimate.
Would recommend they are the largest fish in your tank.

They make firefish seem mean and ornery. :-(

Make sure it is eating heartily at the LFS.
Buy whatever they are feeding it.

For long term survival, more than a year, they need lots of clams.

Ours is small and I spend 10 minutes a night cutting them up and hand feeding him bits of clams off my fingertips.

If you are used to tossing in a cube of frozen then calling it good, this is not to fish you are looking for. :)

If hand feeding your annoying, finicky fish sounds like fun then definitely recommend it. :)

Mine started out on mysis shrimp only & now eats LRS Reef Frenzy like candy too...
 
...to answer the reef-safe question...

No, they are not reef safe. Some folks do keep them in reefs, knowing the risk. They should be pretty safe with sps, less safe with lps and clams. They will eat any worms; they do that for a living.
 
Hm yeah I have a maxima clam. Also lots of softies (zoas mainly) and some lps (mainly euphilyia)
 
Many people keep copperbands in reefs with no issue, but they are listed as "With Caution" for a reason (as pointed out above). If you want a reef safe butterflyfish though a Pyramid Butterflyfish is the way to go.
 
I've seen them fade away slowly even if eating. had a few of those and only one made it past a year. its key to properly quarantine and dewrom them and make sure they get used to prepared food and fatten up before introducing to display. even with that I had one that would go eat from my hand everyday but it stillw asted away and dies at the 6-7 months mark.
reefsafe is not a sure thing with those some would nip at clams, LPS and zoas even if they don t do so initially.
beautiful fish I am tempted to retry.
 
i believe there was a copperband thread a week or so ago and people said it was hit or miss whether they'd go after acans mostly
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top