Ato water. Just RODI?

HawaiianReef

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
698
Reaction score
674
What state or country do you live in
Utah
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've been using RO/DI water to supplement the normal daily water loss.
I've been reading here, that some reefers are adding Kalkwasser to their top off water. Is this common practice?

David
 
I've been using RO/DI water to supplement the normal daily water loss.
I've been reading here, that some reefers are adding Kalkwasser to their top off water. Is this common practice?

David
It is for tanks that use alk and calcium at a high rate to replenish those elements. If you have a low demand tank (softies and lps) it's not necessary with regular water changes
 
So calcium and alk. loss is linear to the loss of the water? Or pretty close?
 
What ATOs should I be looking at? I just picked up an Apex and would like to use it for thus purpose. A breakout box and some sensors?
 
So calcium and alk. loss is linear to the loss of the water? Or pretty close?

You measure out the kalk depending on your alk and calcium consumption, up to 2 teaspoons per gallon. Generally speaking, once you know how much to dissolve per gallon it keeps the alk and calcium pretty stable, even with varied evaporation rates. It is a great way to maintain these major elements up to the point to where you have so many corals and growth that 2 teaspoons per gallon isn't enough.

Edit - changed tablespoons to teaspoons. The maximum amount of kalk that can be dissolved per gallon of rodi is 2 teaspoons.
 
Last edited:
So calcium and alk. loss is linear to the loss of the water? Or pretty close?
You dose it depended on your reservoir size, and consumption. So for example if you have say a 5 gallon reservoir, with an sps dominant tank using 2.3 alk per day, you put 50 grams of kalkwasser in your reservoir, as opposed to a mixed reef that's using 1.1 alk per day so you'd only dose 30 grams per day. I totally made up the numbers, but was using it for example purposes lol.
 
What ATOs should I be looking at? I just picked up an Apex and would like to use it for thus purpose. A breakout box and some sensors?

Well, Apex makes their own ATO kit, but not sure what the verdict is on it? Basically it has everything you need and makes it easy if you already have the apex.
 
What ATOs should I be looking at? I just picked up an Apex and would like to use it for thus purpose. A breakout box and some sensors?
A bob with sensors will work, I had that first and switched to the ATK which I like more
 
Wow... I love this site. Thanks for all the great info guys!
Yeah, I'm far from sps right now, but I love the overwhelming research this hobby demands.
I ordered some test kits for calcium and alk and mag. I'll be checking my tankwater hopefully tomorrow, if not, probably monday.
Cant wait to get more involved in my tank!
 
You can use kalk to keep calcium and alk up instead of dosing 2-part (for relatively low stony coral and clam bioload systems), or you can use it in addition to 2-part. Kalk will raise your pH more, which is a positive feature for many. There are several different ways to dose kalk. The simplest and cheapest way is just dissolving as much as possible in your ATO water and letting it dose with evaporation. This is handy, but can also be messy due to undissolved calcium hydroxide and a constantly forming skin of calcium carbonate where the water contacts the air. You also have to make sure your ATO pump and tubing are robust enough to handle this stuff without clogging or corroding. If you need a siphon break for your ATO reservoir, I wouldn't recommend using kalk this way at all. The other way is to use a kalk reactor of some sort. Pump the clean ATO water through the reactor, which typically has a stirrer to keep the solution saturated, and then out to your sump. I've found this is the most stable method for me.
 
A bob with sensors will work, I had that first and switched to the ATK which I like more
I have the apes one and i am pretty happy with it.

The biggest question is how much space you have for it. Its pretty flexiable and you can change it around some.

I use it on a small 32 gallon Biocube, i started with it just pulling from a 5 gallon water jug, but when i switched to a sump with a resevour, i used that. I now have the sump filling from a rodi system.

The apex system is made up of their small pump, 2 optical sensors and a float valve. If you have special needs tou can just get the parts and set up something direct in the apex. For example, if tou have a rodi system, you might get their sulinoid valve, two optical sensors. And a float valve instead.
 
I've been using RO/DI water to supplement the normal daily water loss.
I've been reading here, that some reefers are adding Kalkwasser to their top off water. Is this common practice?

David
I wouldn't add kalkwasser to your ATO reservoir, it seemed to clog my apex ATK up. or would coat the optical sensors very fast. Some use kalk reactors but that wouldn't help with the sensors. I decided to have a separate reservoir and pump to have kalkwasser dosed in a separate chamber of my sump.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top