Bartletts and Lyretail Anthias together?

abinder

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
423
Reaction score
57
Location
los angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I currently have 5 barletts anthias (4 females/1 make) in my 100 gallon, 5ft long tank.

Would lyretail anthias get along with the barletts? (maybe adding 3 females?)

Thanks for any info or advice.



Allen
 
Yes, lyretails should work with bartletts, both can be a little feisty for anthias. I have kept the 2 species together on numerous occasions without issue.
 
I currently have 5 barletts anthias (4 females/1 make) in my 100 gallon, 5ft long tank.

Would lyretail anthias get along with the barletts? (maybe adding 3 females?)

Thanks for any info or advice.



Allen
Again, with respect to other anthias, they are a 4. They can be some of the more aggressive species available, especially with each other. With respect to other fish,they rate a 2. They can bully or intimidate small, passive fish such as firefish.
This is on a scale of 5 you must take caution mixing the two Anthias together as they're one of the most aggressive out of all of them this is an article out of fish keeper magazine the beginning part of my message to you
 
Here is the link that I get a lot of information from about mixing fish there are several sites that have the same warning

http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2008-07/fish/index.php

Again, with respect to other anthias, they are a 4. They can be some of the more aggressive species available, especially with each other. With respect to other fish,they rate a 2. They can bully or intimidate small, passive fish such as firefish.
This is on a scale of 5 you must take caution mixing the two Anthias together as they're one of the most aggressive out of all of them this is an article out of fish keeper magazine the beginning part of my message to you


Again, with respect to other anthias, they are a 4. They can be some of the more aggressive species available, especially with each other. With respect to other fish,they rate a 2. They can bully or intimidate small, passive fish such as firefish.
This is on a scale of 5 you must take caution mixing the two Anthias together as they're one of the most aggressive out of all of them this is an article out of fish keeper magazine the beginning part of my message to you
 
^ bartletts and lyretails rate similarly as far as aggression toward other anthias and other fish is concerned. The 2 species together make good tankmates.
 
^ bartletts and lyretails rate similarly as far as aggression toward other anthias and other fish is concerned. The 2 species together make good tankmates.
Yes I agree as all fish we always know that there is territorial rights to certain breeds over others and for the anthias they do have a few that are really not recommended to mix but as we all know we still do and usually never have a problem it is nice to see the combination of the different strains of them together it sure does make your aquarium very colorful at my shop I always do what most of the information sites say not to in mixing different fish together and or if they say reef safe or not safe, last with caution I experiment in a 60 gallon aquarium to see how everything fares I always find that as long as there's some hiding places everything gets along pretty well as long as there is not one person there that is oh lets use the black Hawaiian trigger and firefish together they say you can't do that but my fire fish and triggers get along just fine and the trigger is 10 inches long now and the silversides i feed the trigger with are bigger than the fire fish and or any other small fish pseudochromis and so on so there's always that if factor but I always think it's just the way you do the introduction to the tanks with the new fish
 
Would it be okay to have 1 male Bartletts and 1 male lyretail with 4 female Bartletts and 2 lyretails? Or would it be best to have only 1 male amongst all of the Anthias?
(I already have 1 Barletts male.)

Or maybe just get lyretails that are female and let them 'decide' if 1 of them wants to become a male?

Would it be best to start out with the same amount of lyretails as I already have Bartletts ?

Sorry about all of the questions and I really appreciate all of the info and suggestions.



Allen
 
Would it be okay to have 1 male Bartletts and 1 male lyretail with 4 female Bartletts and 2 lyretails? Or would it be best to have only 1 male amongst all of the Anthias?
(I already have 1 Barletts male.)

Or maybe just get lyretails that are female and let them 'decide' if 1 of them wants to become a male?

Would it be best to start out with the same amount of lyretails as I already have Bartletts ?

Sorry about all of the questions and I really appreciate all of the info and suggestions.



Allen
It would be best to get an equal amount of lyretails to the number of bartletts.

It would also be better to get all females and let them sort out if they need a male and which one will transition.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top