Best calcium reactor for my tank?

  • Thread starter Thread starter P_tang
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

P_tang

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 31, 2019
Messages
18
Reaction score
10
What state or country do you live in
Kansas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi! I am new to the forum and hoping to get some good opinions about a calcium reactor. I have a Waterbox 230.6 tank running that will be sps dominant once I start adding corals. I have used kalkwasser in my ATO on my smaller tank, but based on my reading I think a calcium reactor would be best for this setup....But i've never used one before and really would appreciate some input on which reactors are best/most reliable, where to get equipment for best price, any other recs. Thanks!
 
I don’t currently have one but am planning to get one eventually. My research has pointed me to the Geo reactors. He’s got different models based on tank size.

I have a Geo kalk reactor and it’s top notch stuff.
 
Thanks for the reply! Do you put the same media in the second chamber? Just curious how that works...

Running the large reborn media with 10% of ZeoMag in Stage one

Running the regular "ARM" media in sage two

Running those medias per GEO, going on two years. Great combo.

The ARM is the best at ph rebound, and contains a lot of Strontium.
 

lol
I would have went that way too.

But, I don't like that man made media's low ph melting point, that you have to run with it.

If I went that route, may have needed to do kalk dosing too for ph.
 
I have the vertex unit. I love it. Awesome easy to clean and use. Works perfectly.

20181223_121803.jpg
 
MRC or geo. Reef octo isn't bad either
 
I use a TUNZE 3171 for a 133 gallon RSR 625XXL. It just works. It's insanely simple. It's ridiculously quiet. Nothing fancy except the performance is outstanding! It's my most invisible piece of equipment in my tank! It's a shame more people don't consider it because it's a game changer for consistency and it would improve many tanks considerably.

TUNZE also makes a larger 3172.

You never hear of them but mine just works.
 
Here it is...

I clean it every 6 months...

Tunze.jpg
 
If you are willing to wait 8 weeks for delivery, take a look at the Aquarium Engineering ACR, It is fully automatic and does not require a perilastic pump or PH probe.

Fully made in the USA with a lifetime warranty.
 
I have the vertex unit. I love it. Awesome easy to clean and use. Works perfectly.

20181223_121803.jpg

I have read that changing the media on this one is a pain...what are your thoughts?
 
It's just big and heavy when full of water. And honestly I've never changed it. I've just added more when it was about 50% used... it stays really clean. I guess if your not used to the hoses and ph probe on tip of the unit I can be intimidation. But you really only need to remove 2 or 3 hose connections to remove the lids
 
It's just big and heavy when full of water. And honestly I've never changed it. I've just added more when it was about 50% used... it stays really clean. I guess if your not used to the hoses and ph probe on tip of the unit I can be intimidation. But you really only need to remove 2 or 3 hose connections to remove the lids

Any ideas why some folks have complained about leaking? Sorry for the specific questions. This unit is what I initially planned to get (based on the BRS recommendation and the fact they put it on the BRS 160) until I saw the reviews weren't that great...
 
Any ideas why some folks have complained about leaking? Sorry for the specific questions. This unit is what I initially planned to get (based on the BRS recommendation and the fact they put it on the BRS 160) until I saw the reviews weren't that great...
I've never had a leak with it. People have complained about the reactor leaking too. They are threaded top, which I actually like... dont cross thread them, keep the threads clean and I've never had a leak. Had it running for about a year and a half 24/7 without a drop of water.

The only think that doesnt work is the flow meter, now sure why you would even need one on a calcium reactor as I go by drip rate and internal ph. I actually bypassed the flow meter as it just wasnt needed. Another thing that works great is the really large secondary chamber, it really stabilizes ph before it hits your tank, my tank runs 8.4 without a problem. It has a drop in top chamber I'd assume for mag if extra is needed.

I mix the zeovit mag with 2little fishes reborn media in the first chamber and the smaller arm crushed aragonite media in the second chamber. I have the milwakee pg controller and run my unit at 6.7ph, it maintains my tank at 10dkh 450 calcium and 1400 mag with a ph of 8.4, at a drip rate of one drip per second.

Another thing I can tell you is this unit is a beast, its huge and it takes up alot of room, I have mine in my basement under my tank and run a water line from my manifold down to it and a line backup to the sump with a pinpoint valve at the sump to adjust the drip rate.

It took me about 6 months to actually get the ph this low in the chamber. I had to actually start at 7.4 ph inside the chamber and as consumption went up I lowered the ph to keep up.. I made the mistake of starting at 6.8ph and my alk shot up to 16, so be careful with the setup. Start slow and start with a higher ph than youd think. Test adj adjust often until your comfortable its stable. I only test alk once a week now..

Hope this helped. If you have any more questions let me know.
 
I've never had a leak with it. People have complained about the reactor leaking too. They are threaded top, which I actually like... dont cross thread them, keep the threads clean and I've never had a leak. Had it running for about a year and a half 24/7 without a drop of water.

The only think that doesnt work is the flow meter, now sure why you would even need one on a calcium reactor as I go by drip rate and internal ph. I actually bypassed the flow meter as it just wasnt needed. Another thing that works great is the really large secondary chamber, it really stabilizes ph before it hits your tank, my tank runs 8.4 without a problem. It has a drop in top chamber I'd assume for mag if extra is needed.

I mix the zeovit mag with 2little fishes reborn media in the first chamber and the smaller arm crushed aragonite media in the second chamber. I have the milwakee pg controller and run my unit at 6.7ph, it maintains my tank at 10dkh 450 calcium and 1400 mag with a ph of 8.4, at a drip rate of one drip per second.

Another thing I can tell you is this unit is a beast, its huge and it takes up alot of room, I have mine in my basement under my tank and run a water line from my manifold down to it and a line backup to the sump with a pinpoint valve at the sump to adjust the drip rate.

It took me about 6 months to actually get the ph this low in the chamber. I had to actually start at 7.4 ph inside the chamber and as consumption went up I lowered the ph to keep up.. I made the mistake of starting at 6.8ph and my alk shot up to 16, so be careful with the setup. Start slow and start with a higher ph than youd think. Test adj adjust often until your comfortable its stable. I only test alk once a week now..

Hope this helped. If you have any more questions let me know.


Okay, thank you for the reply! I don't have the luxury of being able to put whichever reactor I get in a separate room...and I definitely want one with 2 chambers (just makes sense to try to increase effluent pH as much as possible). So I will probably have to place my reactor to the side in a separate storage cabinet or something.
 
I’m glad yours is working well. I have had nothing but problems with my parents Vertex. We’ve had to replace the motor once and can’t get the second one to work correctly either. I believe the alignment is off on the main chamber with the pump intake.

I’m taking my Geo reactor to his house today to get it set up then calling Vertex to get it replaced.
 
I’m glad yours is working well. I have had nothing but problems with my parents Vertex. We’ve had to replace the motor once and can’t get the second one to work correctly either. I believe the alignment is off on the main chamber with the pump intake.

I’m taking my Geo reactor to his house today to get it set up then calling Vertex to get it replaced.
Wow that sucks... I had an issue with the pump when I first ran it, but it wan my fault as a piece of plastic from the mixing volute got aucked in a jammed the pump. After that it's been running for a year and a half non stop. I've had nothing but good.luck with vertex, I've used their 1.5l zeovit reactor, their larger 3.0 zeovit reactor and their 1L media reactor, so when I reD the eh reviews about the calcium reactor I was surprised. I took the chance in buying it (they're pretty expensive) but I've been happy with mine. I do want to chance the co2 regulator as it's a cheap ebay one and it doesn't always have a steady bubble rate. But it's not too bad bc its run by a controller, not just bubble rate
 
Geo makes a great unit
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top