Best way to keep nitrate and phosphate in check

Burrito

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 1, 2018
Messages
990
Reaction score
788
What state or country do you live in
New Jersey
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I bottomed out on phosphate back in December and had a Dino break out. Since then I added a UV and feed a lot heavier and have have stable po4 at around .03-.06 I do keep worrying about bottoming out again though. (Still have the uv running).

My nitrates have always been zero due to my fuge but things seemed out of whack the past week and my nitrates are registering now at 16 (Red Sea).

My export methods to tinker with are automatic water changes, skimmer, fuge, marinepure and socks/floss (I go back and forth on this)

What should I do to bring nitrate back down a bit without bottoming phosphate to zero.

Any levers I should “pull” to help?

Tank is 100g with 30g sump


As an aside

my sps seem to just not grow much at all, or they grow good for a few weeks, encrust or shoot up new branches and then stop and slowly get algae tips. Is this related to above? My alk stays between 9-10 with a lot of flow
 
Do you have sand or a lot of live rock? If well maintained, both can reduce nitrate with the anoxic bacteria down inside. If you have both than a basting of the rock might remove some surface detritus that might be "gumming up the works." I like to sometimes siphon stuff off of the rocks when I do larger water changes - or use a powerhead to get the gunk off in the hard to reach places... then change a good amount of water.

Pruning your chaeto might help. I have found that smaller balls grow faster than large masses. You might need to dose iron to get it growing again.

For me, the 3" of sand, live rock and heavy skimming along with somewhat routine water changes keep my nitrate very near 0 and phosphate around .01 to .03. There is nothing that I can do to get the nitrates up since the sand bed would just turn them into N gas very quickly.

I would not chase anything too fast with N of 16 - this is not that bad, but I would work on lowering it if it were my tank. I would not do anything with the P at .03-.06. I would not use any organic carbon or media... just go natural and take your time.

Some SPS might not be fast growers with N at 16, but most should not care too much and even if they slowed a bit, they should be growing. If they did not grow when it was near zero, then this is definitely not your issue. Most SPS growth issues are light related, but not all. "Algae tips" are concerning and this could be from your phosphate bottom out incident... if this keeps up, this might need it's own thread.
 
Thanks @jda for the detailed reply. I’ll start with a pruning of cheato, I actually haven’t done this all yet and my small golf ball is now filling about an 11g chamber fully and thick. I have about an inch of sand which I am considering removing and 60-80 lbs of rock along with 3 8x8x1 plates of marinepure

I’ve never tried blasting my rocks before but they are definitely full of funk. I’m not sure if these is an algae problem on the rocks but a lot recently is covered in patches of whatever this is.
95FE330A-8A2E-4B6B-B83C-3A31B23F4BFD.jpeg

5E6A3F2F-A6DC-430D-A428-A330C7EF751D.jpeg

Fts for reference. Photo above was in the circles area of the tank
2464D90E-A152-4E5F-9159-AF916209D0F4.jpeg


301F7538-DCBF-43E9-AB71-C6B53F1DEAB0.jpeg
 
That all looks like bacteria, algae and sponge. Good things. I would not scrub any of that off, or anything. If a turket baster will get some of it off, then cool. Most of that looks like good diversity.

Once the chaeto doubles in size, I remove half of it and kinda pull the ball apart so that it can breath - if that makes sense. Of course, not golf ball sized, but if 5 inches becomes 10, then cut it down. Dense chaeto seems to go dormant for me.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top