As for making sense. I have used a trap for a gorilla crab, left it in there for a couple of days, nothing. Time line of events points to the chromis, as when that fish was added that is when things started to go MIA. The only other fish in there are 2 clowns that host the freaking return, a goby, and a benggai cardinal. Not long after the chromis was added, the star gets demolished, then a peppermint shrimp goes missing, then the hermits killed each other off for wanting each other's shells, then I buy a skunk shrimp and it goes MIA a couple days later. Finding pieces of it in a little cavern where the chromis hangs out. BTW, this chromis goes complete application **** over mysis. There are no crabs in my tank at all, so there is no chance of a crab doing this, nor is there a mantis shrimp in there either. The clowns hardly ever leave their return, the cardinal is lost in it's own little world. Which leaves 1 culprit, the Chromis.