Brightwell Fish Recover M?

Spare time

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 12, 2019
Messages
13,208
Reaction score
10,672
Location
Here
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Anyone know what is in this and how safe it is in general? I have used koral recover which is reef safe but it made trochus snails leave the water
 
Anyone know what is in this and how safe it is in general? I have used koral recover which is reef safe but it made trochus snails leave the water
To me the problem with this is that its just called 'botanicals'. Just because its 'botanicals' doesnt mean 'safe' - I would call Brightwell - which has an excellent customer service - and ask them.
 
To me the problem with this is that its just called 'botanicals'. Just because its 'botanicals' doesnt mean 'safe' - I would call Brightwell - which has an excellent customer service - and ask them.


Well the reason I ask here is that koral recover was supposed to be safe but it is seemingly unfaforable to my trochus snails so I wanted to see what the general consensus was here.
 
Well the reason I ask here is that koral recover was supposed to be safe but it is seemingly unfaforable to my trochus snails so I wanted to see what the general consensus was here.
Yes - this was why I answered - I do not trust ingredients that are 'botanicals'. For example - willow bark is 'salicylic acid - ie aspirin' - you could say - contains only botanicals (a product containing willow Bark)... But in reality it would be like adding aspirin to your tank. So (sorry if it wasn't clear) - there is no way to know - since the ingredients are unknown)? BTW the other question(s) would be 'why are you wanting to use it' and 'what else have you considered'?
 
Yes - this was why I answered - I do not trust ingredients that are 'botanicals'. For example - willow bark is 'salicylic acid - ie aspirin' - you could say - contains only botanicals (a product containing willow Bark)... But in reality it would be like adding aspirin to your tank. So (sorry if it wasn't clear) - there is no way to know - since the ingredients are unknown)? BTW the other question(s) would be 'why are you wanting to use it' and 'what else have you considered'?


I have a clownfish that got a bacterial lesion on him (talked to jay about it) and it will be incredibly difficult to catch him if I want to QT him. I am willing to tear my rockwork down to catch him if he doesn't heal but I am looking for any alternative. I was thinking rally pro but jay had some concerns about the ingredients and it being reef/invert safe or just being too diluted.
 
I have a clownfish that got a bacterial lesion on him (talked to jay about it) and it will be incredibly difficult to catch him if I want to QT him. I am willing to tear my rockwork down to catch him if he doesn't heal but I am looking for any alternative. I was thinking rally pro but jay had some concerns about the ingredients and it being reef/invert safe or just being too diluted.
My guess is that with a 'fish trap' - which you can either buy - or rent (from an LFS) - or online - you can catch it
 
Just wanted to update and say that my tank didn't have any issues with it.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top