Thanks everyone. I ended up returning the bottle then finally heard back from Redsea today that it’s normal. Although the seal on my bottle was not broken, there was a bit of leakage and when we looked at the rest of the bottles at the LFS, they all had signs of leakage as well. In the end I’m sure it’s fine but a little concerning that the product needs to be refrigerated but the packaging contains enough exposure to the air that a small amount of liquid can leak out. The LFS told me that their last shipment was even worse in that all the bottles has significant leaking.