Buying fish and corals - LFS or Online?

cleverrev

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 3, 2022
Messages
34
Reaction score
9
Location
South Florida
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've been to 3 or 4 local fish stores in my area and have seen some nice specimens. I was really just window shopping but I'm hoping to add fish in the next few weeks and was hoping to get some advice on where and how to purchase.

The 2 LFS that had decent stock, both had some Aiptasia and Bubble Algae present. I know these are things we all struggle with but is this a red flag? One even had a couple dead small tangs in the fish only tank. Are these things common, or cause for concern?

I also saw an episode on YouTube where Top Shelf Aquatics was featured and their facility and setup looked absolutely incredible. Everything looked immaculate and hearing what they go through to keep their operation in top form was impressive. They are only a couple hours away from me so they seem to be a viable option.

Are there any other online shops that have a stellar reputation? Am I overreacting about the LFSs, as I would love to support a local business as well? Any thoughts or feedback would be awesome as I start to zero in on the fist occupants of my tank. TIA!
 
So I have a list that sounds just like yours. Always dead fish just hanging in the tanks. They used to be the only lfs. Now we have 2 others and I will never use that first store again. If they won't take time to do small maintenance like remove a bunch of dead fish, they probably don't take good care of things. I will always spend my money where the company cares about their livestock because I care about mine.

So if there is a good lfs, I say support that! I have heard great things about tsa though. I don't like to buy fish online but having bought fish from Biota I will always recommend them to anyone now.
 
I personally like to shop in person at the lfs. This way you can see exactly what you are buying, and can cherry pick the best fish/frags. You can also get to know the employees and owner, and they can be a good resource if you ever have an issue with your tank, especially if you buy from them regularly. Even though you can buy wysiwyg frags online, the pics of the frags on the website "may" be enhanced by the seller. Bubble algae and aiptasia are hard to avoid, but if a lfs has "alot" of it in their tanks I will not buy from them. It shows that they are not taking care of their livestock, and you will not get the healthiest corals and fish from them. The lfs problems can and will become your problem.

All this being said, the premium lfs will be expensive, very expensive, and alot of them target newbies with crazy high prices on common corals. There are some online stores with reasonble prices that are worth purchasing from though, you just have to do you research first. I have had good luck with Cultivated Reef in the past. But again, if you can find a good lfs, this is the way to go imo.
 
Personally I would not buy from an LFS that had aptaisia and bubble. My aptaisia infestation came from an LFS coral.

I have seen several LFS's that have immaculate set-ups, no pests that I can see, and have never received any pests, so that's my standard for LFS.

I'm not bothered too much by a dead fish in the tank, unfortunately they die all day long, the staff can't check every second of the day. If the fish has several days decay, thats a different matter, but a freshly dead fish will be taken out once the staff do the rounds.

I will order corals online from across the country, but I will not order fish online. But thats more about geography, I have lots of great LFS's near me, but others living in rural area's might have no choice but to order online.

Just my 2 cents
 
I've been to 3 or 4 local fish stores in my area and have seen some nice specimens. I was really just window shopping but I'm hoping to add fish in the next few weeks and was hoping to get some advice on where and how to purchase.

The 2 LFS that had decent stock, both had some Aiptasia and Bubble Algae present. I know these are things we all struggle with but is this a red flag? One even had a couple dead small tangs in the fish only tank. Are these things common, or cause for concern?

I also saw an episode on YouTube where Top Shelf Aquatics was featured and their facility and setup looked absolutely incredible. Everything looked immaculate and hearing what they go through to keep their operation in top form was impressive. They are only a couple hours away from me so they seem to be a viable option.

Are there any other online shops that have a stellar reputation? Am I overreacting about the LFSs, as I would love to support a local business as well? Any thoughts or feedback would be awesome as I start to zero in on the fist occupants of my tank. TIA!
I have an online website if you would like to take a look. I handle your orders all the way thru. This gives you an option when your local fish store doesn’t have what you’re looking for.
Been doing this a long time and now helping hobbyist. It’s my pleasure.
 
Are there any other online shops that have a stellar reputation?
I've heard really good things about Dr. Reefs Quarantined Fish and Blue Zoo Aquatics recently - Biota is great for aquacultured fish too (I've heard mostly good things; the only negatives I've really heard tend to be related to the fact that some of the fish are pretty young when shipped out, so they may not be quite as colorful or hardy just yet as the older, wild caught specimens).
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top