Ca effluent and BRS CO2 absorber

kevensquint

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 21, 2014
Messages
404
Reaction score
130
Location
montreal
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi, so I'm setting up a Ca reactor and I bought a second media chamber to attempt to increase pH of the final effluent. I was going to use the coral media as in the main reactor, but came across BRS CO2 absorbing media. Is there any negative reaction/ result by running Ca reactor effluent through this type of absorber?
 
Do you want to post a link to the stuff you mean? I think when you say CO2 absorbent you are talking about soda lime, which is only meant to be used for air - if you put it in your water, it will kill the tank in minutes if its that stuff. Its basically kalk mixed with drain cleaner (lye). I mean you could probably get away with a teaspoon in a large tank as it will raise the alk, but dump a couple of pounds in a calcium reactor and that will kill everything.
 
It says medical grade soda lime spheres.
Screenshot_2015-03-08-16-28-57.jpg
http://www.bulkreefsupply.com/brs-color-changing-medical-grade-co2-absorbent.html
 
Last edited:
No its got a use. Its used to scrub the CO2 from air that is sucked into the skimmer. So if you want to raise pH in your tank, you need to lower CO2. Normal room air going into a skimmer might have a CO2 level of well over 400 ppm, in my case during the day it seemed to calculate at about 1200 ppm, pushing my pH right down to 7.9. If I had put a cannister of the soda lime you linked to in line with my skimmer, so the room air went through the soda lime before it got to the skimmer, then the CO2 in the air would be reduced to much lower levels. With a large enough scrubber (IE enough soda lime), the air would have practically zero CO2. That air, going into the skimmer, will push tank pH right up.

In my case it turned out simpler to use outside air, by running the air intake for my skimmer through a tube to the outside of the house. That pushed my pH up to about 8.4.

If you want to remove the CO2 from the calcium reactor effluent, one way to do that would be to run it into a small skimmer fed with either outside air, or air that had been scrubbed by the soda lime. That way, the high CO2 calcium reactor effluent will run into a skimmer where it is contacted with lots of air which is low in CO2, and that will pull the CO2 out of the water.

Outside air is cheaper and easier for many people (me included). If your house is not well sealed or does not have many people living in it, you might not even need the outside air. You could try just running the calcium reactor effluent into your skimmer for instance.

Remember though that if you pull too much CO2 from the calcium carbonate rich water coming out of the calcium reactor, some of the calcium carbonate might precipitate, as its the CO2 which keeps it dissolved. If you want your tank to have a higher pH, just using outside air / scrubbed air on the intake to your main skimmer, and running the calcium reactor effluent back to the DT (not the skimmer) might be best to avoid that.
 
I bought a pail last year, wayfair sells soda lime in 5 gallon buckets for around $100. Much cheaper than brs when you consider the amount. I only use it during the cold months when ventilation is poor. 5 gallons lasted me last winter and this winter. I'll probably have some left to start next winter off as well. In the winter months I'll see a ph range from 7.8-8.1 without the soda lime/ With the range is 8.0-8.3.
 
Randy, I actually had a little mishap. My skimmer sucked some granules of soda lime into the intake. A small amount was dropped into my sump, which I removed. What can this do to the tank? The soda lime has probably been in the sump several days before I noticed it. I have had some stn on a few corals out of no where over the past week.
I am already running new carbon and make water for 25% WC. What do you think?
 
Randy, I actually had a little mishap. My skimmer sucked some granules of soda lime into the intake. A small amount was dropped into my sump, which I removed. What can this do to the tank? The soda lime has probably been in the sump several days before I noticed it. I have had some stn on a few corals out of no where over the past week.
I am already running new carbon and make water for 25% WC. What do you think?

I've been using a CO2 scrubber for several years. I use the 5 gallon bucket of soda lime as well. It did scare me that some got sucked up into my tank but from what I've read at that time it's made of calcium hydroxide, sodium hydroxide, H20 and potassium hydroxide. Most we dose anyway. When the scrubber was first set up I lost about 2 granules to the sump. I saw them get sucked in but unfortunately never found them. This I just some experience I've had. Randy should be able to help provide a better scientific point of view.

Side Note: Airgas has 5 gallon bucket from $70 to $90 buckets. Sometimes you can haggle. Also group buys can get the price down even cheaper.
 
Randy, I actually had a little mishap. My skimmer sucked some granules of soda lime into the intake. A small amount was dropped into my sump, which I removed. What can this do to the tank? The soda lime has probably been in the sump several days before I noticed it. I have had some stn on a few corals out of no where over the past week.
I am already running new carbon and make water for 25% WC. What do you think?

Assuming it is reasonably clean, it should be OK if it wasn't too much material. It will boost pH and alkalinity, and not much else you'd likely notice (some calcium, sodium, and potassium).

Have you measured alkalinity or pH?
 
Ok cool, thanks for the reply. Yes I monitor PH an that's been a normal range. Alk steady at 9dkh, same as its always been.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top