Carbon/gfo reactor recommendations?

[CK00020]

I have a 120 with a basement fish room, don’t want to go too small or too cheap that I will be buying a different one right away.
Space isn’t a problem any thoughts?

 

[joseserrano]

Aquamaxx is good and will lasts for a long time. Easy to service. If you can find one, vertex had great built reactors

 

[CK00020]

What size aquamaxx are you thinking?

 

[joseserrano]

Sm is fine for your size tank

 

[CK00020]

Ok thanks for the input, I was also thinking ro

 

[sixline]

I'd go Aquamax FR-M (the m is for medium). It is a great reactor for the price, just make sure you buy some sort of bag for the carbon or pack it carefully. It comes with two pieces of sponge that are supposed to hold the carbon in place, but it can leak on occasion. And on occasion is too much for me. Nothing uglier than pieces of carbon in your sand bed.

FR-M Internal GFO Carbon and Biopellet Filter Media Reactor with Sicce Pump

The AquaMaxx FR-M is a great multi-purpose internal Media reactor designed for use in smaller marine and reef aquaria. Insert your media of choice to help eliminate organic pollutants, water discoloration, odors, and algae-fueling nutrients. Great for use with Carbon, GFO and even BioPellets!The...

www.marinedepot.com

 

[Rick.45cal]

I’ve got a GEO and an aquamaxx both 10” reactors with external Sicce 1.0 pumps (for my 190) and the quality is comparable between the two, the caveat being the Aquamaxx I got right away and the GEO I had to wait for at least 6 weeks before it was made and shipped too me. The GEO is very nice and didn’t require any plumbing on my part, but the aquamaxx is getting used because it came quicker.

If it was me, I would choose one that the pump isn’t inside the reactor, as it will be easier to service the pump and the reactor.

 

[Anthony Scholfield]

I use the BRS deluxe carbon/GFO reactor on all my tanks (3) and am very satisfied

 

[Matt Winstead]

I use the BRS deluxe carbon/GFO reactor on all my tanks (3) and am very satisfied

With which pump? The sicce 1.5 that comes with it doesn't have enough power to push flow through my reactors after 4 days it's a trickle.

 

[Anthony Scholfield]

With which pump? The sicce 1.5 that comes with it doesn't have enough power to push flow through my reactors after 4 days it's a trickle.

I use the sicce 1.5 that it comes with and never have a problem. I also use a valve to restrict the flow because the pump at full flow is to much for the media. Not sure why you would experience a trickle......

 

[Matt Winstead]

I use the sicce 1.5 that it comes with and never have a problem. I also use a valve to restrict the flow because the pump at full flow is to much for the media. Not sure why you would experience a trickle......

Gets clogged with build up. Running NOPOX in my sump and it creates a bacteria sludge

 

[Anthony Scholfield]

Gets clogged with build up. Running NOPOX in my sump and it creates a bacteria sludge

So the pump isnt the problem, guess i would recommend not using nopox. Can only imagine if this "sludge" hinders that pump in only a few days, it is hindering other more vital equipment.

 

[merkmerk73]

I'd go Aquamax FR-M (the m is for medium). It is a great reactor for the price, just make sure you buy some sort of bag for the carbon or pack it carefully. It comes with two pieces of sponge that are supposed to hold the carbon in place, but it can leak on occasion. And on occasion is too much for me. Nothing uglier than pieces of carbon in your sand bed.

FR-M Internal GFO Carbon and Biopellet Filter Media Reactor with Sicce Pump

The AquaMaxx FR-M is a great multi-purpose internal Media reactor designed for use in smaller marine and reef aquaria. Insert your media of choice to help eliminate organic pollutants, water discoloration, odors, and algae-fueling nutrients. Great for use with Carbon, GFO and even BioPellets!The...

www.marinedepot.com

I know this is old, but the problem I have with using mesh inside of a reactor is that it doesn't seem to actually flow through the material very well

I noticed this particularly with GFO where it wasn't flowing through the material much at all, and thus wasn't effective

When I went back to no mesh it was effective immediately