Clean up crew question..is it okay to only have snails?

Deadlocked

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 14, 2021
Messages
260
Reaction score
122
Location
New York
What state or country do you live in
New York
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello all i hope your holidays were fun. From my experience, hermit crabs and sexy shrimp have caused more harm than good. It is possible that im not feeding them enough, but at the same time i barely have any algae in my tank besides on the glass. Is it okay to just have snails as your CUC? Thanks in advance!
 
I would say that having “only” snails won’t harm anything or cause a problem, if that’s the main question. As it is with diversity in general, however, the more you expand your CUC, the more ‘junk & gunk’ will get cleaned up. ;)
 
I only have snails as my CUC works great with no issues. just try to mix different species since each targets different varieties of algae.
 
I would say that having “only” snails won’t harm anything or cause a problem, if that’s the main question. As it is with diversity in general, however, the more you expand your CUC, the more ‘junk & gunk’ will get cleaned up. ;)
Well that's the thing i don't really have much gunk in the tank
 
There is no law against it. Quite a few people avoid hermit crabs and other crustaceans because they tend to murder each other and snails especially if they think that they MIGHT be hungry or MIGHT get hungry sometime in the future.

I run a snail based system and it works fine.
 
Hello all i hope your holidays were fun. From my experience, hermit crabs and sexy shrimp have caused more harm than good. It is possible that im not feeding them enough, but at the same time i barely have any algae in my tank besides on the glass. Is it okay to just have snails as your CUC? Thanks in advance!
Absolutely
I’ve ran snails only more than 5 years now.
 
Hermits are kinda worthless imo. Variety of snails ftw
 
Absolutely. I gave up on crabs a while back. Never again. They're buttholes. Knocked coral over all the time. Kill each other and snails for the shell then find out they don't fit in them. No more for me!
 
I had snail only in my tank for a long time. I still don't have hermit crabs but I do have emerald crabs. There pretty much isn't anything a hermit crab will do that I can't find a snail to do. So to answer your question yes it is fine to only have snails. I am in the boat that its better to just not have hermit crabs. Other clean up crew members besides hermit crabs is my answer to this. So a peppermint shrimp if you end up with aptasia or emerald crabs if you need someone to eat bubble algae. Just no hermit crabs lol.
 
Emeralds like others are opportunistic as well. I’ve had a monster one that went after fish. After that no more. Well maybe I’ll try and for smaller ones, but will rehome before they get too big.
 
Dude totally fine, my tank is very clean and I only have snails and conchs, I’ve heard bad things about crabs.
 
Yeah, in fact I would recommend only snails. The problem is that sometimes hermits will just kill off the snails for their shells, even if there is an abundance of food in the tank. If you don't mind adding more snails a few times per year then I guess it's not an issue
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top