Clean Up Crew

Gary Ellis

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 26, 2018
Messages
732
Reaction score
180
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My tank has only been up and running for about 20 days. There is not much algae yet but everyone says get a clean up crew. I want to get some Astraea and Trochus snails but worried they will starve. What do I get to eat the left over food that falls to the bottom?
 
My tank has only been up and running for about 20 days. There is not much algae yet but everyone says get a clean up crew. I want to get some Astraea and Trochus snails but worried they will starve. What do I get to eat the left over food that falls to the bottom?
I would get a few hermit crabs, the small blue-leg/zebra hermits are very good at cleaning up extra food :)

Or a shrimp will work as well
 
I would let it go another month or so, unless you just get 3-4 snails and a couple hermits for something to look at. Anything more and they will starve before you get something established.
 
Just just a few snails, 3 or 5 maybe?
I'm not sure about the hermits ,if they are real hungry they will start eating any snails or themselves.
 
What for?

If you have no algae for them to eat, why would you be in a rush to get a bunch of algae eaters?

Relax. No rush. I'm _not_ a fan of buying a huge number of snails and crabs in some 'clean up crew' package. In my experience, the vast majority of such packages end up dead within a few months, which does nothing to help 'clean up' your tank. IMHO, you're much better off selecting individual or small groups of animals for a specific task, when and if you find your tank in a position to need their services. Got some hair algae? You might get some Trochus, Astrea, or Turbo snails... or you might get a rabbitfish or tang... depends on your tank, your preferences, and your needs. Want to help break up detritus in your sand? Pick up a handful of Nassarius, or maybe a sand tiger conch, sand sifting starfish... There's a variety of critters that might help.

My point is, rely on your tank to tell you when to add clean up crew, how many, and what kinds... and use your own judgement and preferences to determine what you'll add... not some 'sold by the gallon' clean up crew. I have no way to back this up, but I've long suspected that some of the diseases that plague our systems come in from these wild collected, cheap, high volume clean up critters.

Oh, and I'm real cautious about adding crabs to a reef. I have a few small hermits... and I'm always looking for the next one that's made himself at home in the middle of one of my LPS or Soft coral colonies. IMHO, all hermits are opportunistic feeders, and may one day decide that your prize Hammer coral tastes better than hair algae. I do like a big old rock crab, gorilla crab, or overgrown emerald crab as a sump monster, but aside from that, I'm real cautious with crabs.
 
You definitely don't have to do hermits, I was just recommending doing very few if you were going to do them.
 
20 days is really young. I am about two months into starting my tank.

Early on I got a large diatom bloom then it went it away quickly. Now a couple months later I have much more algae growth again and am planning on starting my cleanup crew.

Last thing you want is to put them in and die them further add to the current nutrient issue

It's tough to be patient looking at an ugly tank there's no doubt about that
 
So what is good for eating food that goes to the bottom? My 2 green Chromis is the only thing in my tank and don't eat off the bottom.
 
So what is good for eating food that goes to the bottom? My 2 green Chromis is the only thing in my tank and don't eat off the bottom.
Nassarius snails, most any kind of shrimp (coral banded, probably being the best for this IMHO), certain fishes (I have a Bi-Color Goatfish that is excellent at cleaning up leftovers), several types of crabs (sally lightfoot are real good for this, if you can stand looking at them!), bristle worms, a healthy population of marine amphipods...

Higher flow, so it doesn't settle in the first place :) Lots of options here!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top