Closed Loop or Circulation pumps for 4 sided 260g Display?

PiscesExoticPets

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 11, 2018
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I am ordering an 84" x 30w x 24"h 260gallon reef. It is viewable on all 4 sides. I am trying to decide if I should go closed loop: with minimal, powerheads, cords and wires on the viewing glass. And for installment of a large UV on the closed loop for direct sterilization of the display. I plan to install a UV on the closed loop.

Reasons to do closed loop/ benefits:
1. Cleaner appearance of the tank. Since this is viewable on all 4 sides, I don't want to have 4+ powerheads with magnets and cords floating in space. Maybe just 2 Tunze, or 2 MP40.
2. I have 2 large UV's {TMC 110w uv (effectively kills parasites at 1,000GPH), and Pentair 80w Smart HO UV that effectively kills parasites around 1,000 GPH} I believe in sterilization of a tank. I can plumb one on the return line and one inline with the closed loop. Or both onto the closed loop.
3. I believe the sucking force of a closed loop with 1 or 2 inlets effectively moves water. Yes powerheads, have wide broad flow; but the small inlet sucking in 2,000GPH pulls in a large volume. Put in a UV and you have direct sterilization.
4. Can also install the chiller on the closed loop for direct cooling of the tank.

Reasons no to do closed loop/drawback
1. The company im ordering the tank only has 1.75" drill bit for standard 1" bulkhead. I will use 3/4" SCH 80 bulkheads which usually call for slightly smaller than 1.75" but I've been told a SCH80 3/4" will work fine in a 1/75" hole
2. Risk of a leak... If the bulkhead start leaking for whatever reason, or if I accidentally crack or shift the bulkhead while moving around rocks and aqua scaping, I will have to take all 260g and sand out! I would feel better if I could install the inlets/outlets on the back wall, but the bottom panel is the only option.
3. More electricity costs to power a closed loop pump.
4. Limited adjustability.
 
On top of the other downsides, the closed loop outlets always stand out from a tank to me...at least as ugly (or ignorable as I prefer to say ;)) as powerheads.

IMO I'd go with a standard return setup, incorporating the (apparently) full-flow UV there.

Then I'd plan out some places for some Tunze Rocks to hide your powerheads as needed.

Check out the assortment...(some are for frags or other purposes)


Delta Rock

Corner stone with a great indentation for the placement of corals or plants in a corner of the aquar... mehr

0104.840

116.67 USD

spacer.gif


Nanostream® Rock

for Turbelle® nanostream 6015, 6025, 6045 and 6055. Consisting of a highly porous ceramic stone with... mehr

6025.250

53.06 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Stream 3 Rock

with special insert for Turbelle® stream 3. Consists of very porous ceramic stone with Live Rock fun... mehr

6150.250

77.51 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Stream Rock

with special insert for Turbelle® stream 6095 to 6155. Consists of very porous ceramic stone with li... mehr

6200.250

77.51 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Coral Rack long

Growing stone for the placement of corals. Consists of a highly porous ceramic stone with a Live Roc... mehr

0104.820

84.49 USD

spacer.gif


Coral Rack nano

Growing stone for the placement of corals. Consists of a highly porous ceramic stone with a Live Roc... mehr

0104.800

65.63 USD
 
Although I had a bottom drilled tank for many years, I would not do it again. Lots of bulkheads, all that equipment in the flow path .... No thanks. Will there be no overflow in the tank?
 
On top of the other downsides, the closed loop outlets always stand out from a tank to me...at least as ugly (or ignorable as I prefer to say ;)) as powerheads.

IMO I'd go with a standard return setup, incorporating the (apparently) full-flow UV there.

Then I'd plan out some places for some Tunze Rocks to hide your powerheads as needed.

Check out the assortment...(some are for frags or other purposes)


Delta Rock

Corner stone with a great indentation for the placement of corals or plants in a corner of the aquar... mehr

0104.840

116.67 USD

spacer.gif


Nanostream® Rock

for Turbelle® nanostream 6015, 6025, 6045 and 6055. Consisting of a highly porous ceramic stone with... mehr

6025.250

53.06 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Stream 3 Rock

with special insert for Turbelle® stream 3. Consists of very porous ceramic stone with Live Rock fun... mehr

6150.250

77.51 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Stream Rock

with special insert for Turbelle® stream 6095 to 6155. Consists of very porous ceramic stone with li... mehr

6200.250

77.51 USD


Plus costs of delivery

Coral Rack long

Growing stone for the placement of corals. Consists of a highly porous ceramic stone with a Live Roc... mehr

0104.820

84.49 USD

spacer.gif


Coral Rack nano

Growing stone for the placement of corals. Consists of a highly porous ceramic stone with a Live Roc... mehr

0104.800

65.63 USD
Those are rock caves are a really good idea. I will have a center overflow. I'm thinking, I could use several Tunzes, magnet attach them to the center overflow box and then cover the overflow and pumps with live rock allowing space for the flow to emit out. I plan to have a 2-3 rock columns and this could be the main "tower" that goes almost up to the surface. Certainly that will work. My concern is the Tunze magnets on the dry side inside the overflow. I wonder if the magnet will eventually corrode and contaminate the tank? Doing this I could also have an extra hole drilled in the overflow, stick a pipe in there and then run the Tunze power cords down that pipe in the overflow... so no openly visible wires!
 
Although I had a bottom drilled tank for many years, I would not do it again. Lots of bulkheads, all that equipment in the flow path .... No thanks. Will there be no overflow in the tank?
Yes there will be an overflow box in the center of the tank. I'm thinking I could attach Tunzes to the overflow box, build up the rock structure to hide the overflow (which I was going to do anyway) and also hide the pumps but allow openings and caves to allow water movement. My concern are the dry side magnets, they will be submerged in the overflow. I'm concerned they may corrode and contaminate the tank?
 
O know this his an old post but Tunze has reassured me in the past that the magnet would not corrode. Having some ideas about building something similar to what you are doing so keen to see the progress . Do you have a build thread?

Best of luck
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top