Coral beauty and marine betta.

  • Thread starter Thread starter LadyMac
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

LadyMac

Freshwater sage fish whisperer
View Badges
Joined
Apr 30, 2017
Messages
4,818
Reaction score
21,449
Location
Easley
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Ok so I don’t have either. However I have questions.

So I would love a marine betta ( I’m not the crazy betta lady for nothing lol) however I’ve read they are 8 inch fish and need 50 gallons. I’ve also read they can become aggressive to other smaller fish. So I am getting the waterbox 70.2. It’s 24x24x22 I believe. I also have a lawnmower blenny and a pair of clowns. Would it be too cramped for one? FWIW I keep wild species of bettas and while I know it’s not anywhere near related I am confident in my ability to care for one. I just want to make sure he would be happy in there is all. If not it’s not a big deal.

Second, my lfs has right now a coral beauty. The called it a banded butterfly which I looked and it’s nothing like that. It’s only 25.99. Would he fit in the tank with my mates? Again not a big deal if not just looking at options. I read they need 70 gallons but is that total or display? I couldn’t get him yet, as I would most definitely need to qt seeing as the tank he is currently in is not clean and I feel really bad for him.

Thanks in advance :)
 
So I'll give you some input just for thought. The marine betta isn't necessarily aggressive more than it will eat whatever it can get down, some people confuse this with being aggressive. You can get captive bred marine bettas that are pretty small and they do grow rather slowly. Captive bred ones are also easier to feed, a wild one sometimes needs live food to adjust, but will eventually come around to taking common tank fare. In captivity they will likely not reach more than 6" and most of that fin. They are really not a large fish and would likely not threaten the blenny or clowns. Your tank being a cube does limit my expertise, while the betta is rather crypic and really doesn't use alot of real estate, I would still be mindful of the 24" lateral swim line. This is why I would not recommend a coral beauty in that tank, they would require more lateral swim space.
 
Sounds good. I’ll research more on the betta. Definitely understand about the room, that’s what I was most concerned about. They didn’t seem very mobile but I don’t want one that’s cramped for sure.
 
I had a marine beta and it was my absolute favorite fish!! I never had any issues with him and other fish but they will go after shrimp in the tank, so keep that in mind. Also I was able to get mine to eat large marine pellets. Just keep it well fed and you shouldn’t have any issues. I had to give mine away when I moved but he’s still alive and well. He’s going on 10 years. This fish also had PERSONALITY. They say they are nocturnal but whenever he’d see me, he would swim toward me wanting to be fed. I would try to find a small one but I say do it!!!
 
I had a marine beta and it was my absolute favorite fish!! I never had any issues with him and other fish but they will go after shrimp in the tank, so keep that in mind. Also I was able to get mine to eat large marine pellets. Just keep it well fed and you shouldn’t have any issues. I had to give mine away when I moved but he’s still alive and well. He’s going on 10 years. This fish also had PERSONALITY. They say they are nocturnal but whenever he’d see me, he would swim toward me wanting to be fed. I would try to find a small one but I say do it!!!
So the 24x24 footprint would be ok? How about hides? Lots of rock or would they be ok with more open areas?
 
So the 24x24 footprint would be ok? How about hides? Lots of rock or would they be ok with more open areas?
Lots of hiding areas preferred. They aren’t really an open swimmer. They are usually hiding. I would think the size is fine as long as you get a small one to begin with.
 
Lots of hiding areas preferred. They aren’t really an open swimmer. They are usually hiding. I would think the size is fine as long as you get a small one to begin with.
Awesome! I’ve found my centerpiece then :)
 
They will grow to 8", doesn't they will and they are not necessarily aggressive but will eat anything that will fit in their mouths.
Thety tend to be bashful so should not be a threat in a community setting
 
I had my betta in a 24" cube for 6 years and I agree they do grow very slowly but 8" is definitely possible going by how big mine is. It looked very happy in there tbh and skulked about the whole tank, i never had trouble with other fish but it did eat a couple of cleaner shrimps that were about as big as it was (I think more because they annoyed it than because it was hungry) . I had two rock pillars which connected half way up, the bases were caves and they had a shelf onto where I grew my corals. As the tank was essentially shadows and dimmer light areas I got to see the betta all the time.
I've since moved it to a sunlit 5x2x2' and it continues to be out most of the time and actually basks in the sunlight. 2/3 of the tank gets direct sun most of the day and I have the other third blocked off with the bettas main cave, yet it spends more time in the lit areas under a massive arch.

For me the key to a happy betta is less about space but more about safe retreats and non threatening fish (I had to temporarily house a tang in the new tank and my betta hid for three weeks and wouldn't eat even though it's three times the size).

I really love mine and if I could only have one fish then it would definitely be him.
 
Awesome! I’ve found my centerpiece then :)
As mentioned by others, bettas like to hide... I’ve had bettas for the past ~50 years, current one for past 16 yrs. IME, ‘view time’ is minutes per week, that very few visitors have rarely seen.
 
As mentioned by others, bettas like to hide... I’ve had bettas for the past ~50 years, current one for past 16 yrs. IME, ‘view time’ is minutes per week, that very few visitors have rarely seen.
Thanks for the reply :) I’m ok with that, I keep pallifinas, who are shy also. And we don’t really have visitors so that’s not a worry either.

FWIW I’m still reading up on them, and I do worry with the length of the tank as well as my clownfish. I don’t want them to be a snack.

Can you tell me a little more about them?
 
Currently in a 500g 6’x5’ softie reef... many small damsels, clowns, chromis and grammas over the years that the Betta has never chased or tried to eat.
Even being in 450g and 500g for past ~15 yrs, I don’t think he had grown at all and is about 6” long.
Got him about 16 yrs ago from a friend that was moving and he had the fish for about 5 yrs.
 
I measured mine when I moved it and it was just under 8" from nose to the tip of the tail. The fins make up quite a good chunk of that but I've never had problems with other fish. I'd avoid tiny species like evoita, canna or similar bite size species but other fish shouldn't be an issue at all if you add them before the betta and they arent bite size.

As to their behaviour, it is really down to the individual fish. I was lucky and chose mine from about 50 or so at the wholesalers but if they are hiding constantly in the shop it's likely that will continue in the tank, if it's more out in the open then you have a better chance of seeing more of it.
I trained mine to take food from some tweezers (the long ones for planted aquariums) so it's become extremely tame and comes out to feed (I can even feed it from my fingers) and when I have my hands in the aquarium I can brush against it and it doesn't care.

The biggest thing is to keep a good portion of your tank slightly dimmer and more importantly avoid larger fish. They do become more cryptic as they age but I think alot of the reason that they hide is because people tend to keep them with large species that bother them, if they are king of the tank you get a much better response.
 
Ok so I don’t have either. However I have questions.

So I would love a marine betta ( I’m not the crazy betta lady for nothing lol) however I’ve read they are 8 inch fish and need 50 gallons. I’ve also read they can become aggressive to other smaller fish. So I am getting the waterbox 70.2. It’s 24x24x22 I believe. I also have a lawnmower blenny and a pair of clowns. Would it be too cramped for one? FWIW I keep wild species of bettas and while I know it’s not anywhere near related I am confident in my ability to care for one. I just want to make sure he would be happy in there is all. If not it’s not a big deal.

Second, my lfs has right now a coral beauty. The called it a banded butterfly which I looked and it’s nothing like that. It’s only 25.99. Would he fit in the tank with my mates? Again not a big deal if not just looking at options. I read they need 70 gallons but is that total or display? I couldn’t get him yet, as I would most definitely need to qt seeing as the tank he is currently in is not clean and I feel really bad for him.

Thanks in advance :)

Unfortunately this is the perfect example of the dimensions vs gallons argument. Even though the waterbox technically has the gallons it's dimensions are poorly suited for all but the Clownfish and Blenny. Dwarf Angels should ideally have a 4 foot horizontal space as they are very active fish and can be somewhat aggressive, especially in a tank only 2 feet long. Dwarf Angels are also a gamble for coral nipping so be aware of that. Banded Butterflyfish would be similar in that they need at least a 4 foot long tank (if we are talking about the Spotband Butterflyfish) and 6 feet with most other butterflyfish. They are also very likely to eat your corals and inverts. The Marine Betta doesn't need a ton of space since it isn't a super active fish and is only aggressive to fish it sees as food (aka what will fit in it's mouth) and possibly some shrimp, but it does get pretty good sized and still would likely be cramped in a tank less than 4 feet in length in the long run.

I would strongly recommend getting a drilled standard 75 gallon as that would be a good home for most of the fish you mentioned (except possibly the butterflyfish).
 
Unfortunately this is the perfect example of the dimensions vs gallons argument. Even though the waterbox technically has the gallons it's dimensions are poorly suited for all but the Clownfish and Blenny. Dwarf Angels should ideally have a 4 foot horizontal space as they are very active fish and can be somewhat aggressive, especially in a tank only 2 feet long. Dwarf Angels are also a gamble for coral nipping so be aware of that. Banded Butterflyfish would be similar in that they need at least a 4 foot long tank (if we are talking about the Spotband Butterflyfish) and 6 feet with most other butterflyfish. They are also very likely to eat your corals and inverts. The Marine Betta doesn't need a ton of space since it isn't a super active fish and is only aggressive to fish it sees as food (aka what will fit in it's mouth) and possibly some shrimp, but it does get pretty good sized and still would likely be cramped in a tank less than 4 feet in length in the long run.

I would strongly recommend getting a drilled standard 75 gallon as that would be a good home for most of the fish you mentioned (except possibly the butterflyfish).
Thank you! See that was my concern, the actual length vs gallonage. With that in mind, what can I put with the two clowns and blenny? I’m definitely not looking for overstocking. As mentioned I don’t have to have either, was just curious. Since I keep wild freshwater bettas, I know all too well about space constraints.
 
For a cube type tank I would look at the following:

Royal Gramma Basslet
Cardinalfish
Small Blenny (ie Harptail since it is quite different from a Lawnmower Blenny and occupies a different part of the tank)
Possum or Pink Streaked Wrasse

Also if I might make a suggestion I would look at the Starry Blenny over the Lawnmower. It has a bit more color and the LMB can be a pain to keep up with it's dietary requirements (regular algae tab feedings to keep it alive).
 
For a cube type tank I would look at the following:

Royal Gramma Basslet
Cardinalfish
Small Blenny (ie Harptail since it is quite different from a Lawnmower Blenny and occupies a different part of the tank)
Possum or Pink Streaked Wrasse

Also if I might make a suggestion I would look at the Starry Blenny over the Lawnmower. It has a bit more color and the LMB can be a pain to keep up with it's dietary requirements (regular algae tab feedings to keep it alive).
Thank you!

I honestly don’t mind the tabs, if she doesn’t have plenty of algae I’ll gladly supplement. I’m quite attached :) I mean, look at this adorable face.
59B19071-7FC6-43AE-BD43-5715C62AA094.jpeg


I also have a pistol shrimp and thought of a YWG. I like cardinals and wrasses. I will look into all that you have suggested.
 
The thing I love about LMB are the way they press up against the glass and sit on their tails while they stare at you.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top