- Joined
- Jul 27, 2018
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 53
- What state or country do you live in
- Other International
Hello everyone,
I have been reading and studying on this topic for so long but despite my efforts i still cant keep healthy and colourful sps. I have problem with some lps too. Softies do pretty well.
I have a Red Sea Reefer 170, i moved from a smaller system about 4 months ago. I had it for 1 year and a half (in which i had the exact same problem) for lighting i have the Ocean Revive leds at 30% blue and 10% whites, i have measured the PAR output and it is around 350 to 150 top to bottom. For flow i use a jebao rw-4 wich gives me around 40 times the volume of the tank per hour. In sump i have a coral box skimmer for roughly 300 liter and some carbon inside the filter sock. I have a dosing pump to replenish KH, Ca and Mg, and the values are really stable. I do 10% water changes monthly. I have done an ICP test recently and i had all parameters in good ranges except for Iodine which was pretty low. I have started dosing it and i will test it again soon. I recently added some Miracle Mud in the sump in the attempt to replenish all the elements slowly. I do not dose bacteria since the beginning of the system.
these are the parameters tested last week
salinity 1025
KH 8
Ca 430 mg/l
Mg 1290 mg/l
PO4 0,02 mg/l
NO3 4-8 mg/l
I have only 4 fish right now cos i had an ich outbreak about a month ago so I'm not adding anything else right now. I have a cleaner shrimp and many turbo snails. I feed twice a day different pellets.
Here are some pictures of the display, i will add some pictures of the sump too.
A month ago i have added 4 new corals, a healty deep purple milka, a orange montipora, a green caulastrea and a green motipora. All of them are slowly losing color and vibrancy. Strange thing is that some sps seems to do fine (for fine i mean not losing color and growing very very slowly) like a red motipora digitata and one anacropora. I have also a green pavona catctus which i thought it was dead but now is getting is color again. Regarding soft corals i can't complain, they grow, slowly but they do grow. The colors are not awesome but atleast they dont die. In conclusion i would say that in my tanks I never saw the colors and growth I expected, especially from sps and lps. I do not consider myself an expert but i'm not really new in the hobby. I am a chemist and i try to read as much as i can on different topics related to the hobby. But after 2 years i am starting to feel frustrated. What can i do better? Should i have just more patience?
Thank you very much
Carlo
I have been reading and studying on this topic for so long but despite my efforts i still cant keep healthy and colourful sps. I have problem with some lps too. Softies do pretty well.
I have a Red Sea Reefer 170, i moved from a smaller system about 4 months ago. I had it for 1 year and a half (in which i had the exact same problem) for lighting i have the Ocean Revive leds at 30% blue and 10% whites, i have measured the PAR output and it is around 350 to 150 top to bottom. For flow i use a jebao rw-4 wich gives me around 40 times the volume of the tank per hour. In sump i have a coral box skimmer for roughly 300 liter and some carbon inside the filter sock. I have a dosing pump to replenish KH, Ca and Mg, and the values are really stable. I do 10% water changes monthly. I have done an ICP test recently and i had all parameters in good ranges except for Iodine which was pretty low. I have started dosing it and i will test it again soon. I recently added some Miracle Mud in the sump in the attempt to replenish all the elements slowly. I do not dose bacteria since the beginning of the system.
these are the parameters tested last week
salinity 1025
KH 8
Ca 430 mg/l
Mg 1290 mg/l
PO4 0,02 mg/l
NO3 4-8 mg/l
I have only 4 fish right now cos i had an ich outbreak about a month ago so I'm not adding anything else right now. I have a cleaner shrimp and many turbo snails. I feed twice a day different pellets.
Here are some pictures of the display, i will add some pictures of the sump too.
A month ago i have added 4 new corals, a healty deep purple milka, a orange montipora, a green caulastrea and a green motipora. All of them are slowly losing color and vibrancy. Strange thing is that some sps seems to do fine (for fine i mean not losing color and growing very very slowly) like a red motipora digitata and one anacropora. I have also a green pavona catctus which i thought it was dead but now is getting is color again. Regarding soft corals i can't complain, they grow, slowly but they do grow. The colors are not awesome but atleast they dont die. In conclusion i would say that in my tanks I never saw the colors and growth I expected, especially from sps and lps. I do not consider myself an expert but i'm not really new in the hobby. I am a chemist and i try to read as much as i can on different topics related to the hobby. But after 2 years i am starting to feel frustrated. What can i do better? Should i have just more patience?
Thank you very much
Carlo


