Coral ID if you would

TokenReefer

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 4, 2022
Messages
2,221
Reaction score
2,074
Location
Outer Space
What state or country do you live in
Connecticut
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've had this coral for a while now. Thought it was a trumpet all along and starting to split a few weeks back. Just mounted it in new tank and I'm not thinking so any more. Lobophyllia perhaps?
20230913_165749.jpg
 
I think this is one of the first times I’ve been stumped, It has to be an lps, and has similar colors to some candy canes. Not really sure though
 
I think this is one of the first times I’ve been stumped, It has to be an lps, and has similar colors to some candy canes. Not really sure though
Exactly! When it was one 'node' it looked like a candy cane. Then it started to pinch and grew a new mouth and I thought ok this is how they split... A few weeks later after a tank move I pick it up off the sand and it has ~5 mouths now :thinking-face:
 
I've had this coral for a while now. Thought it was a trumpet all along and starting to split a few weeks back. Just mounted it in new tank and I'm not thinking so any more. Lobophyllia perhaps?
20230913_165749.jpg
Can you post under white lighting? First glance said lobo but then can be bowerbanki or blasto as examples
 
Maybe a lobo?
too small and flesh texture is not right to be Lobophyllia

Platygyra?
Platygyra is meandroid to subcerioid, while this coral is flabello-meandroid

Looks like a small trachy. Could you get a picture under white lights or shine a flashlight on it?
too small to be Trachyphyllia, and the flesh texture is not right

Can you post under white lighting? First glance said lobo but then can be bowerbanki or blasto as examples
Homophyllia bowerbanki has larger, cerioid (not flabello-meandroid) corallites, and has a more "velvety" flesh texture. It's not a Blastomussa either, as Blastomussa does not become flabello-meandroid.

Where did you get your coral? If it was from a piece of maricultured live rock, my best guess would be Manicina areolata, although I doubt it, as your coral seems to be attatched to the rock.. Otherwise, my best guess would be Caulastraea or Astraeosmilia that is splitting. I've seen a few trumpets/candy cane colonies with a flabello-meandroid head or two; it seems to be more common in Astraeosmilia:
 
too small and flesh texture is not right to be Lobophyllia


Platygyra is meandroid to subcerioid, while this coral is flabello-meandroid


too small to be Trachyphyllia, and the flesh texture is not right


Homophyllia bowerbanki has larger, cerioid (not flabello-meandroid) corallites, and has a more "velvety" flesh texture. It's not a Blastomussa either, as Blastomussa does not become flabello-meandroid.

Where did you get your coral? If it was from a piece of maricultured live rock, my best guess would be Manicina areolata, although I doubt it, as your coral seems to be attatched to the rock.. Otherwise, my best guess would be Caulastraea or Astraeosmilia that is splitting. I've seen a few trumpets/candy cane colonies with a flabello-meandroid head or two; it seems to be more common in Astraeosmilia:
Looks like your ID is here haha
 
too small and flesh texture is not right to be Lobophyllia


Platygyra is meandroid to subcerioid, while this coral is flabello-meandroid


too small to be Trachyphyllia, and the flesh texture is not right


Homophyllia bowerbanki has larger, cerioid (not flabello-meandroid) corallites, and has a more "velvety" flesh texture. It's not a Blastomussa either, as Blastomussa does not become flabello-meandroid.

Where did you get your coral? If it was from a piece of maricultured live rock, my best guess would be Manicina areolata, although I doubt it, as your coral seems to be attatched to the rock.. Otherwise, my best guess would be Caulastraea or Astraeosmilia that is splitting. I've seen a few trumpets/candy cane colonies with a flabello-meandroid head or two; it seems to be more common in Astraeosmilia:
Very detailed reply. Much appreciated. Everyone else as well. I think you're right and it is a caulastrea after all. At least it looks the most like the ones I've seen online with an abnormal (flabello-meandroid?) head maybe still splitting. Very informative. Thank you
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top