Coral-Only tank--Do I need to cycle?

my pipes bearing eggs
WP_20181116_00_57_19_Pro.jpg
 
my pipes bearing eggs
WP_20181116_00_57_19_Pro.jpg
Do you have a pair in yours? If so, that’s very cool. When I first got mine, I reached out to Paul b for advice. He cautioned me that most lose their banded after the first month for inability to feed. Seems like people almost have a more difficult time feeding them than mandarins.

If your pipe is laying eggs then you definitely are doing it right!
 
4 yrs and counting never feed live on the bugs in the reef
 
no just to try, i succeded with horses in a dedicated tank figured why not ,but yellow stripe pair disaped in a couple of weeks,but they were skinny to start with,waset lack of food
 
no just to try, i succeded with horses in a dedicated tank figured why not ,but yellow stripe pair disaped in a couple of weeks,but they were skinny to start with,waset lack of food

Got it.

I had to start the culture for a unique situation. When my pipe proved ineffective at controlling the amphipods, I picked up a canary wrasse. My amphipod pop was so big that they had completely decimated my copepod pop. When the canary wrasse cut back the amphipods, neither the canary nor pipe had pods to graze on so I decided to just start the culture to keep them happy and to cut back feeding cyclops all day. Was getting annoying.

I’m sure with a tank your size it’s not hard to keep your copepod pop up at all times.
 
im sorry poor joshua going to have to read all this tomorrow,i just wanted to show not just blowing smoke,30yrs reefer have a great night

sorry joshua hit me up tomorrow
 
imo the black box if dimmable programable
 
arkansas,got to be kc tomorrow ? today
 
im sorry poor joshua going to have to read all this tomorrow,i just wanted to show not just blowing smoke,30yrs reefer have a great night

sorry joshua hit me up tomorrow
No...I enjoy learning all I can. One question: Why pipefish? I thought most people that use a fish for initial cycle, use a damsel or chromid///you know....something cheap and "disposable" so to say?
 
well clowns are damsels ,but if you use est water from other tank rock too ,what cycle
 
pipes just thought would be uniqe little live brine and then mix with frozen in week ,week later all frozen,will feed both rock coral and pipes
 
but read carefully above, start with a softie you can see open and close daily ,then add a sps frag,then good to go,do need decent skimmer
 
im sorry poor joshua going to have to read all this tomorrow,i just wanted to show not just blowing smoke,30yrs reefer have a great night

sorry joshua hit me up tomorrow
Did I say something incorrect about pipefish for you to think I’m blowing smoke?
 
no was refering to me with the no cycle
 
No...I enjoy learning all I can. One question: Why pipefish? I thought most people that use a fish for initial cycle, use a damsel or chromid///you know....something cheap and "disposable" so to say?

There is utility from pipe fish, specifically dragons, for an sps tank as they consume red bugs and other pests that plague certain sps.

If you are going fishless, the most simple way to keep things running well is to just do water changes with water from your main system. I know your goal is to keep things fishless and you really don't have to keep fish in the frag tank.

One piece of anecdotal experience, fishless frag tanks tend to mature a lot slower. Without the constant fish poop and surge of bacteria that grows from the poop/feeding, things just progress significantly slower than a fish system.

As long as your frag tank can process the ammonia you're adding, and your params are maintained at the levels you want, you can add in corals at any time. I have added corals as soon as a week after I set up the tank once the cycling was complete. There's no additional voodoo going on. Corals want small amounts of nitrates/phosphates, some trace elements, and their alk/calc/mag needs met. If you can satisfy that, you're good.

I would consider adding sand and rock from your main system to help this out a little bit. It's also just harder to maintain unless you're doing larger water changes with water from your main system. Fish really do keep everything in balance. I've seen others add a little bit of skimmate from their displays skimmer as an alternative. I've done it a bit but just prefer water from my main system.

It's 2020, to cycle, just get some pure ammonium chloride and a crap ton of bottled bacteria. Once the bacteria is able to clear ~1ppm of ammonia and nitrite in a 24 hour period, you're good.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top