Cycling a reef tank with a yellow tang

randy4083

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
1,241
Reaction score
285
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I just started cycling a tank and Saturday will be 2 weeks and today I noticed that my yellow tang that I'm using to cycle the tank has a little bit of ich on his fins what can I do?? Can I do hyposalinity and keep the tang in the tank or what since it's cycling I don't know what to do? Any help would be greatly appreciated thanks
 
Really should not be using a tang to cycle a tank. If the store you got it from would take it back.... give it back and do a fishless cycle, and let it go fallow, and you might want to think about setting a quarantine tank before you add fish again. You other option is to put the fish in quarantine and treat it for ich and do afishless cycle while letting your tank go fallow for 6 weeks to rid it of the ich.
 
Yeah +1 to the first response. Ich is now present in your tank and you either have to use copper to treat it which will screw up your process anyway and/or remove the tang and go fallow for 75 days if you want the ich gone. A tang is not a good choice to cycle a tank.
However, If you don’t plan on quarantining your future fish in a hospital tank for a couple weeks before putting them in the display- then I would say you will always have ich in the tank- keep great water quality and good food etc and most fish will survive it and the ich will come and go. So- you can keep the tang in there under those conditions but 1- he probably won’t survive, esp without treatment and 2- you are exposing all future fish to ich for sure- which is not really the way you want to start a tank. It will pop up every time you add a new fish, do a water change etc and you will loose fish to it.
I’d suggest 1. A hospital tank for treatment of the tang or return it, the Start your whole tank over/ (take everything out, empty it, dry everything out for a week completely etc) or keep it fallow for 6 weeks.
2. Treat the whole tank with copper for weeks, (assuming no inverts) then do water changes and run a lot of copper remover- then re-cycle without fish, then after cycle is complete- test for copper with an ICP test- add a hardy species of fish and a snail/crab as a test.
 
*1 or 2, you don’t need to do copper if you go fallow etc :)
 
here's where you stand on your cycle Randy

the fish would have died long ago if you lacked cycling bacteria. They get ich in all systems to the tune of 80% no matter who inputs them, yours isnt a cycling issue any longer you are past that stage.

Fish cannot survive ammonia burning, they die. yours lived because bottle bac handled everything, now you're at the fish disease protocol juncture
 
I
I read somewhere that Gem Tangs are much better for cycling a tank than yellow tangs. :eek:
like this. This is extremely valuable information. They already have the white spots too so you’re good they can’t get more right? Make sense.
 
Thread is four years old. However if you are super diligent about testing and seed your tank with established rock, sand and water it can be done without hurting the fish. I have done this before. And a fresh qt tank is basically a mini tank with less water. I never used to qt. Now with all the issues I would highly recommend qt.
 
ha 4 years nice catch
the chances this reef is even still running is negative two pct. nice date catch
 
Thread is four years old. However if you are super diligent about testing and seed your tank with established rock, sand and water it can be done without hurting the fish. I have done this before. And a fresh qt tank is basically a mini tank with less water. I never used to qt. Now with all the issues I would highly recommend qt.
Yes I wanted it revived. People are still doing this.


Just noticed this is a 4 year old thread. Good discussion, but at this point it's more about hypotheticals than an actual situation.
Yeah I felt it should come back. It seems people are going back to cycling with fish even though they’re aware of the information. This is still a relatively important subject that doesn’t get covered enough. Yes this is situation specific but it paves the way for all tangs.
 
its the disease part that kills them, not free ammonia. very valid point about fish-in cycling. disease losses are through the roof, because bottle bac is so strong at handling all dangerous ammonia right off the bat.
 
no this thread kicked up is a good one for the point it shows the years have passed and its still happening. check out this trainwreck I started on the matter it will save u headache lol:


I feel we've proved ammonia burning isn't happening, but disease wipeouts are causing us to literally waste thousands and thousands of fish, fish-in cycling isnt wise for preservation past a few months

what we explore in that thread is how the few seneye meters used during fish-in cycle showed total ammonia control and happy fish. but if we tracked fish for 8 mos used in a cycle, velvet brook and crypto wipes them back out.
 
Last edited:
Agree with everything that is said just want to throw in that if you use copper, you will never be able to have inverts in this tank.

thats not really true. I dosed a 220g reef with 150#s of live rock and a 2-4 inch sand bed with copper and after treatment and copper removal products and water changes at the end of treatment- no copper, no problems with re-introducing inverts.
 
thats not really true. I dosed a 220g reef with 150#s of live rock and a 2-4 inch sand bed with copper and after treatment and copper removal products and water changes at the end of treatment- no copper, no problems with re-introducing inverts.
Yeah I was just reading up this and i believe I was relying on outdated information.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top