@JoJosReef if you don’t mind can I ask you about the aquascaping comment you made. I have been trying to look up info on how to glue/cement together live rock (like KP base rock) and haven’t really found any detailed info. You mention using a cement for that. Can you say some more please. What long of cement and doesn’t it dry while the rocks are wet? And how long to dry the cement before placing the rock back into the water. I have been debating live rock but the aquascaping part has been holding me back. I don’t want to just stack the rocks in a pile (not into fancy NSSA aquascapes either, just something that looks nice and works for the fish)
Yes, aquascaping live rock is more frustrating than any pests they bring in. I prioritize keeping as much life as possible on the premium rock I buy, so I continually wet the rock while it is outside of the water.
This is going to get you wet.
I first take the pieces that make the most sense as the base rocks and start adding them to the tank. You have to be imaginative, unlike dry rock where you can arange pieces 100 ways first.
Next, I take the pieces I'm stacking, whether as a pointed mountain, horseshoe shaped island, or bridging two base rocks. Test them in the water to find where the key weight bearing points are. Does it sit by itself? If so, next step is take the rock back out, have your partner ready N balls of 2 part cement--my favorite is 2 Little Fishies, but others like Seachem, Nyos or Ocean Wonders--where N equals number of weight bearing points. Add super glue to the bottom of the rock on the weight bearing points (you can tap dry the points with paper towels to help the CA glue stick, keeping the rest of the rock wet with dripping tank water), half-smash the balls of cement onto the CA glue and wait a short while to let the CA glue set (here you can wiggle/twist the balls to get the glue adhering to the cement ball, just like for frags), then blob CA glue onto the bottom of the cement balls, turn the rock over and into the tank, settling the rock as best you can onto the weight bearing points, lightly pressing down to flatten the cement ball onto the base rock's weight beaing points.
Swear as you find out your points were off by a quarter inch, and try to reposition so that the cement is compressing around the real weight bearing points. Worst case, remove and repeat. I always have extra cement handy.
Use your gloved fingers to massage the cement ball that's sticking out from the weight bearing points so that it flattens against the bottom and top rocks, cradling both. Release and pray it stays where it is so you can let it set. If a third rock is going on top, go slam 3 shots and take a 5 min breather. Hopefully the middle rock sets enough so it doesn't all come apart when you press the third rock on top.
If a rock doesn't sit by itself in the position you want it, you can still cement it there, but that will require extreme patience holding the rocks in place or propping them while the cement cures in the water.
That's the basics of it. Find the weight bearing points and CA glue sandwich a cement ball at each point so that once it cures, the rocks are somewhat balancing but not moving side to side and are more stable than simple stacked rocks. If you lift the top rock up, it will likely comes loose from the cement because it is hard to get cement to fully form joints around weight bearing points like dry rock cemented outside the tank.
Keep the rocks wet, but feel free to dry the weight bearing points.
Hope that wasn't too long a read!