Death of aiptasia?

Acro maniac

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 10, 2016
Messages
851
Reaction score
425
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I broke down my 180 because it was infested with aiptasia. I moved all the rock to a 150 gallon tub to house the fish for the time to dry out and recycle the system. I currently have saltwater back in the 180 and I have some older pukani rock that i have been cycling in a brute can.
I would like to remove the rock from the tub that is infested with aiptasia and dry it out. How long should i dry it out before it can go back in water or would an rodi water soak be better?
The other question is there enough bacteria on the walls, pipes, sock, and return pump to sustian the fish? Its been up for about a month and everything has been happy. Ask me anything that i forgot to add, thanks.
 
Do a muriatic acid wash and a bleach on the rocks if you want to kill everything on a rock without having a lot of dieoff. Doing a dry / rodi rinse will only cause you to have other issues as you’ll have a lot of dead organics still on the rock.

One way or another aptasia will find a way back to the tank IME, your best bet is to get fish/ inverts to keep it in check.

If you had a big infestation I’d bet you have some spores around in your sand, overflows, pipes, or sump still. Taking out the rock won’t solve it.
 
Do a muriatic acid wash and a bleach on the rocks if you want to kill everything on a rock without having a lot of dieoff. Doing a dry / rodi rinse will only cause you to have other issues as you’ll have a lot of dead organics still on the rock.

One way or another aptasia will find a way back to the tank IME, your best bet is to get fish/ inverts to keep it in check.

If you had a big infestation I’d bet you have some spores around in your sand, overflows, pipes, or sump still. Taking out the rock won’t solve it.
The system was dried out (refered to in 1st post as broke down )the rock is the only thing left with aiptasia.
I have other systems i have kept aiptasia out of. My 90 was converted to a frag tank from a DT and is 13 plus years old never completly dried out in that time and no aiptasia.
I have seen posts where people use bleach and acid. I just cant get over the chemical introduction. I have time, im in no hurry. Im more concerned with if the fish will be fine with me removing the rock and pitting pvc in place of it.
 
I just cant get over the chemical introduction.
I think bleach is feared for little reason. Liquid bleach is diluted NaClO (Sodium Hypochlorite). It works as a disinfectant because of the oxygen it contains. Once that oxidizer is used you are left with NaCl (sodium chloride) which is table salt. You do want to only work with bleach and organic compounds in a well ventilated area but there is little long term risk to the aquarium for its use. If you dry it when done, or just let it sit for a few days in the sun, it is very safe to use.
 
The system was dried out (refered to in 1st post as broke down )the rock is the only thing left with aiptasia.
I have other systems i have kept aiptasia out of. My 90 was converted to a frag tank from a DT and is 13 plus years old never completly dried out in that time and no aiptasia.
I have seen posts where people use bleach and acid. I just cant get over the chemical introduction. I have time, im in no hurry. Im more concerned with if the fish will be fine with me removing the rock and pitting pvc in place of it.

You said you tore it down then you were asking about bacteria in the pipes, so I was confused with that.

IME aptasia always finds a way in and I’ve been in the hobby 20+ years. In the end as long as they are taken care of and don’t get out of hand no issue. I have a 700g system with none in my 400g display due to a copperband and filefish, but I know there are some in the sump.

As for the bleach / acid wash. It’s very simple do the acid wash to etch the rock. You can do this in a garbage can outside. Let it sit. Once you’re done put some baking soda in to neutralize. After a good rinse do a bleach bath which will kill all the organics. A couple rinses and some air dry and you’re good. You can even soak in some dechlori, but bleach will evaporate if you dry it out in the sun. This is what I did with all of my old rock from my 400g system because it was loaded with gunk
 
You said you tore it down then you were asking about bacteria in the pipes, so I was confused with that.

IME aptasia always finds a way in and I’ve been in the hobby 20+ years. In the end as long as they are taken care of and don’t get out of hand no issue. I have a 700g system with none in my 400g display due to a copperband and filefish, but I know there are some in the sump.

As for the bleach / acid wash. It’s very simple do the acid wash to etch the rock. You can do this in a garbage can outside. Let it sit. Once you’re done put some baking soda in to neutralize. After a good rinse do a bleach bath which will kill all the organics. A couple rinses and some air dry and you’re good. You can even soak in some dechlori, but bleach will evaporate if you dry it out in the sun. This is what I did with all of my old rock from my 400g system because it was loaded with gunk
Thanks for the info... the pipes and walls etc i was referring to are the ones in tub system currently housing the fish. Im in no hurry to move anything into the 180. I would like to put all the rock in at the same time thats why i wanted to get it out of the the tub.
Just to clarify...
Aiptasia rock is in a tub with fish from 180.
180 just has saltwater, it was dried and cleaned.
55 gallon brute is half full of dry rock from a 90 dt that is now a frag/growout tank (no aiptasia).
I know where i recieved the aiptasia from it was cheato from a system told to be clean. Only later to admit to thinking he had beaten an aiptasia infestations.
That mistake will not happen again.
Ok so what is the mixture for the acid and bleach??
 
Thanks for the info... the pipes and walls etc i was referring to are the ones in tub system currently housing the fish. Im in no hurry to move anything into the 180. I would like to put all the rock in at the same time thats why i wanted to get it out of the the tub.
Just to clarify...
Aiptasia rock is in a tub with fish from 180.
180 just has saltwater, it was dried and cleaned.
55 gallon brute is half full of dry rock from a 90 dt that is now a frag/growout tank (no aiptasia).
I know where i recieved the aiptasia from it was cheato from a system told to be clean. Only later to admit to thinking he had beaten an aiptasia infestations.
That mistake will not happen again.
Ok so what is the mixture for the acid and bleach??

1:10 for both will work perfectly fine for both the acid and bleach. Get yourself a garbage can. Add the rock and water then slowly add the acid. Use gloves and eye wear and do it outside. It’s going to foam and make a bunch of nasty brown water as the acid is etching the rock 1/8th of a inch or less. Depends on how long it’s in the solution, but this is taking off po4 from the outer layer of the rock and taking organics with it.

Once you’re done with that , I believe I did it for about 20min when I did all of my rock. You can either use baking soda to neutralize or just bring them to a fresh water bath. I set mine out for about 5 min outside and put them in water. The acid potency isn’t as high because of the rock acting like a buffer. I soaked them in water for 2 days and rinsed them very well.

I wanted to make sure they were rinsed well before the bleach wash. I did this for about 4 days at 1:10 ratio. Just let them sit. After I rinsed them very well and let them sit again for a week or so. I added some pet store dechlori to it. I was in no rush so this was just something I took my time with so I could get them as clean as possible.

I let them sit out in the sun for a couple days after and in the tank they went. Zero issues whatsoever...
 
7c8f441ea3a7aa9c37ba0fbde664d246.jpg
720e8ff4f82cdfd9d12c009bd9351fe6.jpg


Unfortunately I can’t find the before photos. They were disgusting lol
 
1:10 for both will work perfectly fine for both the acid and bleach. Get yourself a garbage can. Add the rock and water then slowly add the acid. Use gloves and eye wear and do it outside. It’s going to foam and make a bunch of nasty brown water as the acid is etching the rock 1/8th of a inch or less. Depends on how long it’s in the solution, but this is taking off po4 from the outer layer of the rock and taking organics with it.

Once you’re done with that , I believe I did it for about 20min when I did all of my rock. You can either use baking soda to neutralize or just bring them to a fresh water bath. I set mine out for about 5 min outside and put them in water. The acid potency isn’t as high because of the rock acting like a buffer. I soaked them in water for 2 days and rinsed them very well.

I wanted to make sure they were rinsed well before the bleach wash. I did this for about 4 days at 1:10 ratio. Just let them sit. After I rinsed them very well and let them sit again for a week or so. I added some pet store dechlori to it. I was in no rush so this was just something I took my time with so I could get them as clean as possible.

I let them sit out in the sun for a couple days after and in the tank they went. Zero issues whatsoever...
Thanks for the directions..
How much baking soda is needed to neutralize acid? How did you dispose of the water when complete?
 
Thanks for the directions..
How much baking soda is needed to neutralize acid? How did you dispose of the water when complete?

I didn’t use baking soda after I was done. I have a lot of land so I just tossed it out on my property. If you neutralize it you can dump it anywhere.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top