Did I buy right fish, and is it sick?

Tiagofish

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 1, 2022
Messages
17
Reaction score
11
Location
Earth
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
At the LFS, I asked for a yellow Coris wrase. They caught a small yellow guy from their tank and put him in a bag. i was dumb enough not to inspect it closely, or at least it was hard to in the tank and in the bag at the store. Now that I'm home, i think it might not be a yellow Coris wrasse. And I think it's pretty sick - lots of spots in it's fins etc. Ive cured fish w this w about 30% success rate. Any one have any thoughts or clarifications to help me out - like is it sick and what type of fish is it? I got a QT for it regardless.

20220604_191058.jpg
 
Clown gobies can be finicky, and bashful
Acclimation important. Not sure I’d want to buy fish from them if they can’t identify a yellow coris wrasse
Assure any potential purchase:
-Eats
-Gets along with tankmates at store
- normal breathing rate
-No skin imperfections
 
I did research, but I was sloppy. The fish I pointed at I think was different from the one in the bag I got in the end and I was too trusting and the staff incompetent. I think ur right in all the comments. Just gotta figure out how to offload this guy asap. Will he live fine in the bag overnight floating in the QT? He's been in the bag for about 2 Hrs. He's pretty tiny. The store opens in ~14 hrs
 
I did research, but I was sloppy. The fish I pointed at I think was different from the one in the bag I got in the end and I was too trusting and the staff incompetent. I think ur right in all the comments. Just gotta figure out how to offload this guy asap. Will he live fine in the bag overnight floating in the QT? He's been in the bag for about 2 Hrs. He's pretty tiny. The store opens in ~14 hrs
It's probably fine in the bag if it's a big bag? I have received many mail order fish that were in the bag longer. But they may have been bagged with oxygen and may have not been fed the day before packaging. Let's put it this way. I would NOT EVER knowingly add a fish with ich to my reef tank. if that meant a fish died in the bag and I lost a few bucks, so be it.
 
I did research, but I was sloppy. The fish I pointed at I think was different from the one in the bag I got in the end and I was too trusting and the staff incompetent. I think ur right in all the comments. Just gotta figure out how to offload this guy asap. Will he live fine in the bag overnight floating in the QT? He's been in the bag for about 2 Hrs. He's pretty tiny. The store opens in ~14 hrs
I would just put it in the QT, save the bag, then catch and rebag tomorrow to return it. Far more likely for it to croak in the bag overnight than acclimating to your QT.
 
If anyone at the LFS thought this Clown Goby was a Coris Wrasse, don't shop there anymore.
(Was it petco? Cmon, you can tell us...)
 
I did research, but I was sloppy. The fish I pointed at I think was different from the one in the bag I got in the end and I was too trusting and the staff incompetent. I think ur right in all the comments. Just gotta figure out how to offload this guy asap. Will he live fine in the bag overnight floating in the QT? He's been in the bag for about 2 Hrs. He's pretty tiny. The store opens in ~14 hrs
Call and leave a message and/or send an email tonight explaining the problem(s). At least you will be "on record" today.
 
If anyone at the LFS thought this Clown Goby was a Coris Wrasse, don't shop there anymore.
(Was it petco? Cmon, you can tell us...)
Wasn't Petco. Sea king Bellevue WA.
 
Call and leave a message and/or send an email tonight explaining the problem(s). At least you will be "on record" today.
This post is my record. I tried calling. They're closed.
 
This post is my record. I tried calling. They're closed.
Just a follow-up- the guy survived the night in the bag just fine. I had other fish in the QT, and I didn't want to mix the two obviously. I had a different employee help me and they were surprised how this happened. They made it right and gave me the right fish and took back the goby.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top