Did my nutrient export REALLY kill ALL my GHA in a week?!

LilElroyJetson

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 21, 2015
Messages
1,153
Reaction score
2,118
Location
Charlotte, NC
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
When I was leaving to go out of town 10 days ago it looked like I had some Green Hair Algae coming in. I tested my parameters the day I left and I had ~2ppm Nitrates and 0.166 ppm Phosphates.

I got back last night and it looks like ALL the GHA is dead?! The chaeto in my reactor BOOMED while I was gone, I’ve been running a conservative amount of Rowaphos in a mini reactor. Tested my parameters. Nitrates are now at 0 ppm, Phosphates dropped to 0.144 ppm. All the corals look healthy except for one Zoa that just looks a little annoyed with the dead algae on its plug.

Can anyone confirm that this is dead GHA? Has anyone experienced this before? Plan tonight is to scrub it off the rock with a toothbrush, do a water change, and feed the corals to get nitrates up a tiny bit (I know this might feed the algae but I think the water is too clean for the zoas right now). Would appreciate any insight!

Here are some photos:
3/1/2019 (before)
440C55FA-758E-476F-98C1-615CB577F737.jpeg
AE25B0AA-6DCF-42CE-A6FA-1275933C7C10.jpeg
003AFAD2-20AC-488B-9728-F9B4325DCE32.jpeg


3/11/2019 (after)
C31AF687-AC15-4E60-9528-6A6FE1414815.jpeg
5AE42327-EC92-45AB-8FA0-BA37B688DE35.jpeg
E9ED04DE-87D8-46A3-A2C4-D7D4FEC04C62.jpeg
E059166E-1156-442D-BE9E-F37E5E11875D.jpeg
 
How old is your tank? My guess from the pictures not too old, few months at most.

My guess is that your cheato reactor could have lowered the nutrients enough to see the GHA start to fade. I have a buddy who set one up on his 90 reef and it lowered his nutrients very significantly....so it can work. I run an algae scrubber on my 220 twv reef ....and as it matured.... meaning the algae really started to fill in... it did a great job of also lowering nutrients.

Another thing to consider, did your feeding regimen change slightly while you were gone? In combination with the Chaeto.... that is most likely why your nutrients have fallen off.... which certainly helped reduce your GHA.
 
Also, looking at your pictures again, I dont see much in way of clean up crew. You might think about adding a variety of snails to help with any of the algae that remains.

Good Luck!
 
How old is your tank? My guess from the pictures not too old, few months at most.

My guess is that your cheato reactor could have lowered the nutrients enough to see the GHA start to fade. I have a buddy who set one up on his 90 reef and it lowered his nutrients very significantly....so it can work. I run an algae scrubber on my 220 twv reef ....and as it matured.... meaning the algae really started to fill in... it did a great job of also lowering nutrients.

Another thing to consider, did your feeding regimen change slightly while you were gone? In combination with the Chaeto.... that is most likely why your nutrients have fallen off.... which certainly helped reduce your GHA.

Correct. Tank is a few months old. I believe the chaeto reactor is outcompeting the algae, which is great and why I started my tank with one — in hopes of taking preventive measures or reducing the severity of my algae phases. Seems like it’s working!

I’m happy my nutrients are low. I will keep bringing down the phosphates. However, I have never fed the tank. Nitrates were at 2ppm and so I left it up to water changes thus far, especially given the tiny amount of livestock in the tank. Today will be my first feeding and it will be very light.

I mainly wanted to confirm that this is indeed GHA so I don’t misdiagnose something else and fail to treat or exacerbate my issues.
 
Also, looking at your pictures again, I dont see much in way of clean up crew. You might think about adding a variety of snails to help with any of the algae that remains.

Good Luck!

Clean up crew arrives Wednesday! Have some Trochus, some blue legs and some nassarius coming in. Didn’t want to introduce anything to my tank as I was going out of town but seems now they’ll have some food to eat. I wonder if they will eat the dying out algae?
 
Thought I should update everyone here. Hopefully this helps someone else who sees this for the first time and doesn’t know what it is.

After a great deal of research and with the help of this thread —
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/white-fuzzy-algae-looks-like-cotton.372737/
— among others, I have determined that the white stringy algae that I thought was dying GHA is highly probably a type of diatom called Licmophora sp.

If you get this right after your diatom bloom and it appears to be growing out of other established algae in the tank, it might be licmophora sp. Luckily, a majority of it came off pretty easily with a tooth brush. Hopefully the cleanup crew comin in on Wednesday takes care of the rest of it. And finally, maybe the green on the rocks was green coraline because it seems to be pretty hardened and was unaffected by the scrubbing of a toothbrush. Tank is looking a lot better now.

5B16F4F9-CD09-480C-8D2D-4FAE8DD8E0C9.jpeg
C8F5C79E-5913-4339-B93B-4975BF26AA9D.jpeg
643A5BE9-0C12-441D-8ADA-F03B176B14BE.jpeg
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top