Display tank... Rectangular or cube?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kilo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Kilo

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 26, 2016
Messages
113
Reaction score
31
Location
Singapore
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
All,
I am confused...should i get a 36"x24"x24" or 30"x30"x24"(not really a cube).
DT will be 12mm thick glass, 3 side crystal glass and rimless.

My first initial plan was the rectangular ones but saw some member cube in the forum and like them too which caused the confusion

Any points to help me make a decision?

Thanks in advance
 
They each have their strong points I think. Cubes are great to light because until they get huge one pendant can light the whole thing so that is cheaper and more efficient and you aren't wasting light bouncing it off the back and front of the aquarium as much. Until they get really big, your aquascape options are limited but that isn't really a bad thing, restrictions can actually help you create a better display.

Rectangles give you more options for aquascaping. I like them better than cubes for this reason. I also think that they are best when they have a lot of width and the water isn't too deep.
 
I would recommend you go with a rectangle. Cubes are great if you have a very specific plan/goal in mind or are limited in space. The only real benefit cubes have are that they generally speaking require less lighting and potentially power heads for flow. However, they have a long list of (potential) downsides.

1. Your sump size will be restricted considerably, and you'll be required to either a) buy a cube-specific sump which is usually more expensive than a DIY-possible glass tank with baffles. If you go with a "cube" sump you'll be fighting with yourself whenever you're shopping for a skimmer, return pump, etc etc. b) Get a regular sump and keep it outside of your stand, but this could potentially be unsightly or c) build a stand that is much longer than the tank in order to accomodate the filitration you need. This can work, but reinforcing the top of the stand for the footprint of the tank can be more convoluted than your typical DIY construction.

2. Cubes are shorter in general which means it will be more difficult to keep fish that grow past a few inches, and anything that generally enjoys swimming will feel restricted in the space.

3. This isn't really a con, but I personally think aquascaping a cube well is considerably more difficult than your average rectangle tank. Cubes require important focus on managing both depth and height due to the restricted length of the tank. Most people enjoy their tanks for the aesthetic, so this should not be overlooked.
 
62c31695d68fd1a075bc7c30f0bbbb41.jpg
6cb63a41e090cfb6e45f4d4aee22a9ca.jpg


It's true what is said I feel a cube you can fill it more quicker and it's cheaper

But a rectangle tank does look better but then you have to buy bigger wave makers to reach the other side

Hope I haven't sent you mental on choosing lol
 
I like cubes better because of the front to back depth. I like building high structures and I think cubes accommodate that more. BUT I only have nano cubes.
 
Thanks everyone for your valuable advice.

based on my needs for
1) aquascaping, i dont like to go high,
2) swim area
3) display, bigger screen TV is better right:)

i will go rectangular
 
I would like a 4ft by 4ft by 2ft height, a 4ft square tank will give a great space to aquascape and allows great swimming room, it's also 5ft.7is diagonal corner to corner
 
100% personal preference. I personally have a 30x30x18(maybe 20 cant remember) on order. I do not see how a cube or rectangle tank is easier or harder to light. or easier or hard to aquascape or get flow. Again it's all what you think looks good. Nothing to be confused about.
 
I've had both. and I prefer rectangle for aquascaping and swimming room for the fish. I felt restricted with a cube

I agree with you here "DracoKat"
I have both. I use the cube as a QT / semi display - the rectangular as a display tank.
 
Well 36x24 is 864 square inches, and 30x30 is 900 square inches. how someone can say a rectangle tank gives more swimming room then a cube tank makes no sense to me. The shape does not determine swimming space, the over all dimensions do. In "general" cube tanks proved more depth. I do think a 24 x 24 is to small though, all though I have seen very nice ones. If I had to chose between 36x24 or 30x30 I take 30x30 every time will be able to have move more depth in you aquascaping. If you make the 30x30 view able from all 3 sides you will have tons of room for coral and the depth makes it look killer.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top