Does Sand & Baking Soda bonded w/ Cyanoacrylate really work for Aquascaping?

Reefahholic

Acropora Farmer
View Badges
Joined
Sep 5, 2014
Messages
8,121
Reaction score
6,797
Location
Houston, TX
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Yes it does! ;)

It works very well. Just don't buy the Starbond EM-02 CA Super Glue. Starbond does say it's commercial strength, but it doesn't set as fast as GlueMasters or Axia 911. I can definitely echo what @Than at Tidal Gardens said. It just doesn't seem to bond fast enough, but after it has set for a while it does get very hard. The bond doesn't seem as strong as GlueMasters though.

Also, make sure you get water thin CA and wear a respiratory with "Vapor filters" if you plan to use this method inside a garage, house, or plan to work for a long time. The Vapors from these CA glues are no joke.

One last thing you need to know. Make sure you buy some larger grain sand to use along with your fine sand. The fine sand will fall straight through the bigger cracks. Also buy some wooden popsicle/craft sticks to help spread regular glue or mortar. Thin work gloves are helpful too.

Below are the two CA glue brands that work fast and bond well with sand:

Axia911.jpg
GlueMasters.jpg





Happy Aquascaping!
 
This is what I ended up with, but the majority of the scape was built with regular BSI Gel and accelerator. The CA and sand was used to bond a few joints, but I’m primarily using it to fill in and hide cracks/joints/mortar at the end and strengthen the structure in weak areas.
CBB119EA-3422-4F2C-ACB6-EF81771AE50A.jpeg
99792874-C2A6-4C19-B06D-ADBD37214EA1.jpeg
C87AD5C6-822E-40FB-AD76-635C2911F585.jpeg
BFC2B60D-93D2-407B-A04A-9E5BB13353B5.jpeg
 
Cool!! So you mixed the sand and glue as a mortar for bonding your rocks together?
Yeah, the sand is basically a mortar when soaked with CA. Our Korean friends started doing this along with other who figured out that baking soda and CA make an extremely strong bond.

There’s a few YouTube videos out on this method so I figured I’d try it to see if it’s as strong as it looks. The main draw for me was being able to scape fast and also hide cracks, mortar, etc. with the sand.
 
I wonder if this would work with wet rock? I've yet to find a good way to take my existing rock out of the tank, bond it together and put it back in. Right now, it's just gravity.
 
I wonder if this would work with wet rock? I've yet to find a good way to take my existing rock out of the tank, bond it together and put it back in. Right now, it's just gravity.
I think so. Should work pretty instant. Quick enough to only have it out for 15 minutes or so.
 
I was watching a video just a couple nights ago where a guy used water thin CA glue and powdered rock dust from the rocks he broke up to do his aqua scape. I assume this is the same method. Looked fast, easy and most of all, seamless. I think this is what I will do for my own scape project!

Thanks for the tip,
Steve
 

Reefahholic​


What is the deal with baking soda? Mix it with the rock powder? What ratio?

Thanks,
Steve
There’s really no ratio. Just squirt water thin CA glue into fine sand, Baking Soda, or even crushed up calcium carbonate rock. Make sure to use the glue brands listed above. Some others don’t work as well.
 
Thanks! Cant wait to try mine out! Would any super glue work though or it has to be glue masters?
 
This is what I ended up with, but the majority of the scape was built with regular BSI Gel and accelerator. The CA and sand was used to bond a few joints, but I’m primarily using it to fill in and hide cracks/joints/mortar at the end and strengthen the structure in weak areas.
CBB119EA-3422-4F2C-ACB6-EF81771AE50A.jpeg
99792874-C2A6-4C19-B06D-ADBD37214EA1.jpeg
C87AD5C6-822E-40FB-AD76-635C2911F585.jpeg
BFC2B60D-93D2-407B-A04A-9E5BB13353B5.jpeg
Nice!
 
I have found in playing with this, that you want to use either aragonite sand, or the pulverized bits of rubble from breaking your rocks. At first I tried Caribsea super natural sand, and it doesn't make a good bond. The special reef blend works great.
 
Thanks! Cant wait to try mine out! Would any super glue work though or it has to be glue masters?

I had the same question.. I was watching a video earlier that basically said regular super glue would work. I think the benefit of the really liquid stuff is that it wicks through the sand, rock powder, ect more thoroughly, Basically what this is is welding rock... Just like welding metal, we add a filler to create a bond between two pieces. Just like metal welding, the filler has to bond fully to the main components
 
We’ve been using the baking soda & superglue thing for years in the UK for fixing broken slot car parts, as it sets it off instantly and makes a stronger bond than superglue alone, and you don’t get the white mist in plastic from the superglue vapours...
I’m wondering if this wouldn’t also work spectacularly well for mounting frags on plugs, as long as you don’t get clumsy and heap BS onto your prize Acro frag....!
 
I have to say that this method ABSOLUTELY works!!!

I picked up a small bottle of thin Locktite CA glue and started putting a few pieces together today. The bond is (dare I say it?) strong as a rock! Unfortunately, I ran out of glue after just a few pieces. Ordered a bottle of the Glue Masters stuff tonight but it won't be here for a couple weeks, so I guess my build is on hold again...
 
Thanks! Cant wait to try mine out! Would any super glue work though or it has to be glue masters?
You can use super glue, but it will not work as well as the Glue Masters CA glue. I tried some other brands of CA glue that didn’t bond as fast or as strong. The key is “speed” so you don’t have to wait. Otherwise just use some IC Gel and Mortar.
 
I have found in playing with this, that you want to use either aragonite sand, or the pulverized bits of rubble from breaking your rocks. At first I tried Caribsea super natural sand, and it doesn't make a good bond. The special reef blend works great.
Aragonite is the best sand. Don’t use play sand or anything not made for reef tanks.

Busting up Marco Rocks makes some beautiful material to work with of all different sizes including powder like sand. :-)
 
I had the same question.. I was watching a video earlier that basically said regular super glue would work. I think the benefit of the really liquid stuff is that it wicks through the sand, rock powder, ect more thoroughly, Basically what this is is welding rock... Just like welding metal, we add a filler to create a bond between two pieces. Just like metal welding, the filler has to bond fully to the main components
Exactly, you want it to fully saturated the substrate. Watch my wife squirt it into the sand and you’ll see it just absorb into the sand. That is what you want. Get water thin with fine point applicator tip. Works better if you wet the rocks first to help the sand stick. I ruined all my spray bottles trying to spray it. Don’t try it!



 
Last edited:
We’ve been using the baking soda & superglue thing for years in the UK for fixing broken slot car parts, as it sets it off instantly and makes a stronger bond than superglue alone, and you don’t get the white mist in plastic from the superglue vapours...
I’m wondering if this wouldn’t also work spectacularly well for mounting frags on plugs, as long as you don’t get clumsy and heap BS onto your prize Acro frag....!
If there is live tissue they will slime, but if dead tissue at base it would probably work. BSI IC Gel works well and is my go to for mounting Acro frags. I think it would probably be easier to use a frag glue/gel like that for mounting corals.
 
I have to say that this method ABSOLUTELY works!!!

I picked up a small bottle of thin Locktite CA glue and started putting a few pieces together today. The bond is (dare I say it?) strong as a rock! Unfortunately, I ran out of glue after just a few pieces. Ordered a bottle of the Glue Masters stuff tonight but it won't be here for a couple weeks, so I guess my build is on hold again...
The Glue Masters definitely works well with a very strong bond as you can see in the 2nd video posted above. Buy a good spray bottle and wet the rocks where you want to make the bond. Then use the sand to drizzle onto the joint. It’s good to have sand, and also other different sized small pieces to work with. Marco Rock makes a excellent powder and a lot of nice pieces when busted up with a hammer.
3F49BD09-E31F-412C-92C5-7D6A82F5AF57.jpeg
318214C9-B0A0-4165-86D3-BCE3A5A2423E.jpeg
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top