Doser suggestions Please! Best doser. Pros/Cons

Michael43

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 24, 2016
Messages
1,099
Reaction score
405
Location
Dirty Jersey
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My reef has been running 4 months now. Been dosing 2 part manually for the last 3 months. Its time for an apex and a doser. I fear the doser tho. I have read a lot about tank crashes due to broken dosers staying on. What's the most reliable doser out there? It doesn't need to necessarily be able to be controlled by apex I just need reliability in the long term. I narrowed it down to the DOS system made by Neptune for the apex but can only handle 2 things. For now that's ok but maybe not forever. I also have been recommended Bubble Magus so was thinkin gthe T11 which has its own control. Lastly BRS recommends there dosers which have great reviews. Id love to hear everyones opinion! Sorry if this is a beaten subject. I did a search found some info but wanted to start my own thread about my situation
 
It seems that neptune has figured out the ailments with the DOS system, so you could go with that. Or go with a standalone GHL which would be my choice.
 
I really like the DOS and have 3 of them. All had bad pump heads, but they were all from the initial release before they identified and corrected the issue. They are a little pricey for what they do, but they are also very flexible and can go from a dribble per day to gallons without issue. I also like that Fusion calculates the dosing schedule based on how many ml you want instead of having to manually calculate the time needed.
 
Most reliable is going to be the GHL Doser 2. Three or four pumps.
You'll need the "Stand Alone" unit if you don't have a GHL Profilux Controller.
 
Gotta say having no trouble with my jebao dp4 so far been on a few months now
 
The DoS and Resovoir are on sale as a package deal for around $450 which is an okay deal. Back when I was shopping The DOS was $349 and the Resovoir was 199 so it was $100 more and that is when they were getting a lot of complaints.

Were I shopping now I would probably jump on the combo deal but......I got two of the BRS dosers and as it turns out, if you have outlets 4 and 8 free on your apex you are just as well off with BRS. Just run each pump for 10 minutes and write with a piece of what tape on each pump the true flow rate (one of mine is 2.05ml/min and the other is 2.15. From there, if you can do math you can easily figure out how long to run the pumps and what part of the day.

I should point out that I am a registered nurse and used to mix emergency drugs for patients during codes and calculate drip rates pretty much in my head in things like ml/kilogram/min so what I find relatively trivial to do as far as the calculatios, I could forsee some having serious problems doing...... your mileadge may vary but for me they turned out to be so easy to program that I doubt ill ever use the DOS now. Ill probably use my extra 1-link connection for a COR (and hopefully a flow sensor) when apex releases those instead.

I set out to buy every single piece of equipment apex offers but it turns out a few things you just really don't need. A DOS, a salinity monitor/probe, and a dissolved oxygen sensor. Some will argue you don't need ORP but I actually find a lot of benefit to having continuous read out of basically what amounts to how much organics are in my water. I find the break out box and float switches indespinsible and I am looking forward to the fluid monitoring system coming out. The leak detectors and an extra EB8 also are things I couldn't do without....along with the pump and light modules for my hydras and vortechs. I don't have the PAR kit and I honestly just can't make up my mind on that one... Lighting is tricky..and I think the PAR kit might have some value even at the high cost.

Will I upgrade to a DOS one day? Possibly. They are extremely feature rich. Were I not so good at calculating drip rates I could see rationalizing the cost. One feature that kind of like is the resovoir gives you the fluid levels but unless you are dosing A LOT I find that I'm usually very well aware of when my levels are low and need filling.

What I would really like to see is something like a syneye that could give you real time measurements of calcium, alk, mg and possibly nitrates and phosphate levels via probes I would proably cought up big money to automate that.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top