Dosing with Red Sea Part C Magnesium question.

  • Thread starter Thread starter abinder
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

abinder

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
423
Reaction score
57
Location
los angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My tank is a 45 gallon JBJ rimless with about 32 pounds of rock and 30 gallons of saltwater.

My magnesium is currently at about 1325 and I'd like to raise it to at least 1400. I'm using the Red Sea Part C Magnesium supplement. If I read the bottle correctly, I should use 70ml per 25 gallons of tank water to raise it from 1320 to 1390. If that is the correct dosage, what is the max amount that I should dose of the Red Sea Part C Magnesium per day to get it up to 1400?

Thanks for any info, suggestions, and/or help.


Allen
 
Randy, What type of impurities are you referring to? Is it more common in mg chloride or mg sulfate? Does it matter what grade it is? Industrial vs pharmaceutical? Why can my system allow it slowly? Is it not the Sam amount of impurities accumulating over 3 days? I once read it was ok to raise mg 100 ppm per day is that to much now?
 
Your mag.Is not that far off . As with any supplement you need to raise slowly.
 
Your mag.Is not that far off . As with any supplement you need to raise slowly.

Hmmmmmmm.
Ummm. He is not the one that posted the original question.

I have since found out that Red Sea doesn't recommend raising the Mg with their part C Mg more than 10ppm per day.
 
What i did to raise my mag i used kent tech-m and when i was done treating i useda poly filter pad which removes harmful metals from your system .
 
Randy, What type of impurities are you referring to? Is it more common in mg chloride or mg sulfate? Does it matter what grade it is? Industrial vs pharmaceutical? Why can my system allow it slowly? Is it not the Sam amount of impurities accumulating over 3 days? I once read it was ok to raise mg 100 ppm per day is that to much now?

I am referring to anything that might be in it. Iron, copper, cadmium, lead, ... In a chemical supplement, almost any ion will be there to some extent. I've measured such impurities in calcium chloride (Dowflake, ESV, Kent, and Warner brands), but never in magnesium supplements.

Some bulk sources of magnesium are also known to have ammonia in them. It is a main reason that some people rant against my recommendation of using MAG flake to supplement magnesium, although it has little ammonia, some bulk brands may. But if you add it slowly, it is not a concern. That use is very different than making a salt mix where you are adding all 1300 ppm instantly.

So the slower you go, the less likely there will be any problem, but the 100 ppm per day that many mention has been shown empirically to be fine for many people. Folks treating for bryopsis add a lot more than that and don't have an issue, although the fact that it kills bryopsis, possibly with an impurity, suggests that there are potential concerns.

So how slow you want to go should depend on what you are using (better grades are less risk, IMO) and whether you have used it previously with no issues. If you up it 20 ppm per day for several days and have no problem, the next time you need it, adding 40 ppm may be a fine plan. Just start slow with any new chemical supplement. :)

In addition top going slow so you can stop in an emergency, there are a variety of reasons why adding the same toxins over a few days is better than adding them all at once.

Ammonia can be processed by the tank bacteria to prevent it from rising too high.

Many metals will become bound to organics. Copper for example, is bound by organics in seawater. That tends to reduce the toxicity. That is well known, but Ron Shimek rediscovered it when he saw that copper in established aquarium water was not nearly as toxic as if one just added copper all at once to a salt mix. So adding such metals slowly keeps the more toxic "free" metal concentration from rising too high. It also allows them to precipitate or be taken up by the many systems in the tank (bacteria, macroalgae, filters, skimmers, etc.), potentially limiting the toxic concentration.
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top