Duncan skeleton question

JCTReefer

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
1,081
Reaction score
1,471
Location
Lubbock, Texas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
IMG_2681.JPG
I recently acquired a neon green Duncan. Is the part where the flesh meets the hard skeleton actual skeleton or is this a part of a rock it was attached to? I know the new heads up above the flesh are part of its skeleton. Or is the part below the flesh, part of its old skeleton? Looking at the saw cut on the backside where it was propagated, I'm guessing old skeleton. Thanks for any input.
 
This looks like the heads were fragged and glued to a piece of rock to me.

Let’s see what others say as well.

Love the color!
 
This looks like the heads were fragged and glued to a piece of rock to me.

Let’s see what others say as well.

Love the color!
Thanks!!! I'll turn it around and get another shot on where it was cut! Here's a pic of the backside. And of course they just closed up when I moved them for the pic.
 
Wow. Looks totally different from this angle?

Now it looks like the heads are encrusting a Duncan stalk / skeleton.

Still looks great though!
 
Wow. Looks totally different from this angle?

Now it looks like the heads are encrusting a Duncan stalk / skeleton.

Still looks great though!
I was kinda leaning the same direction, but wasn't positive. Was thinking old skeletal growth they're incrusting on. It's my first Duncan and I did my research, but couldn't find a great deal on growth pattern. Besides that some are more branching with long stalks and some are more bunched up shorter/closer together. And also found a good bit of info on how they sprout heads. Was a beautiful wysiwyg specimen I acquired from Unique :)Thanks for your input!
 
Your welcome and I really like the color of that Duncan!

I hope it does well for you.
 
I was kinda leaning the same direction, but wasn't positive. Was thinking old skeletal growth they're incrusting on. It's my first Duncan and I did my research, but couldn't find a great deal on growth pattern. Besides that some are more branching with long stalks and some are more bunched up shorter/closer together. And also found a good bit of info on how they sprout heads. Was a beautiful wysiwyg specimen I acquired from Unique :)Thanks for your input!
Where did you find the info about how they sprout heads? Recently acquired one and I'm in love with it. Would love to know more about these guys. Here's a pic after a few hours in the tank.

I love that yours is all neon green! Amazing.

20181007_203024.jpg
 
Feed them and they will explode! This was a single head when I started my tank and thought it was a goner. I almost threw it out until I noticed a bit of flesh inside the skeleton so I put it back to see. Eventually a tentacle emerged (as my tank was maturing). I think it's three years old and about 2 since I saw that speck of flesh. I estimate it's doubled in size over the past year to a bit larger than a baseball. I have lost track of the number of heads. It is in a prime spot when I broadcast feed my fish and is responding accordingly. I try to keep my tank within the red sea mixed tank parameters but know that more wishful thinking than actual practice.


I wouldn't dismiss that your frag was a remnant piece from a larger fragging event (and thus the unusual cut) and recovered nevertheless. I have a softball sized frogspawn that my LFS gave me no charge that was a single tiny polyp remnant about the size of a large pin head.

awesome neon green in with your duncan. enjoy

IMG_0894.jpg
 
Feed them and they will explode! This was a single head when I started my tank and thought it was a goner. I almost threw it out until I noticed a bit of flesh inside the skeleton so I put it back to see. Eventually a tentacle emerged (as my tank was maturing). I think it's three years old and about 2 since I saw that speck of flesh. I estimate it's doubled in size over the past year to a bit larger than a baseball. I have lost track of the number of heads. It is in a prime spot when I broadcast feed my fish and is responding accordingly. I try to keep my tank within the red sea mixed tank parameters but know that more wishful thinking than actual practice.


I wouldn't dismiss that your frag was a remnant piece from a larger fragging event (and thus the unusual cut) and recovered nevertheless. I have a softball sized frogspawn that my LFS gave me no charge that was a single tiny polyp remnant about the size of a large pin head.

awesome neon green in with your duncan. enjoy

IMG_0894.jpg

Beautiful Duncan!!! It has really grown !!!
 
Last edited:
Nice specimen! Its growing heads from it's own skeleton which is attached to some artificial substrate. This particular specimen looks to be from the wild.

They do love to be fed and will grow quickly if consistantly fed. Duncan's are a great coral to keep for almost everyone as they accept a wide variety of flow and lighting.

Duncan's usually bud around existing polyps and grow apart from each other over time creating a branch. They also will sprout new polyps from where polyps have been propagated unlike euphyllia (frogspawn, hammers, torch)

I've been propagating Duncans for over 13 years from same colony's. Very tough dense skeletal structure.
 
Nice specimen! Its growing heads from it's own skeleton which is attached to some artificial substrate. This particular specimen looks to be from the wild.

They do love to be fed and will grow quickly if consistantly fed. Duncan's are a great coral to keep for almost everyone as they accept a wide variety of flow and lighting.

Duncan's usually bud around existing polyps and grow apart from each other over time creating a branch. They also will sprout new polyps from where polyps have been propagated unlike euphyllia (frogspawn, hammers, torch)

I've been propagating Duncans for over 13 years from same colony's. Very tough dense skeletal structure.

Awesome!!! Great information!!!! Thanks for your input!!!!
 
Glad I could help!! Duncans fascinate me and love that their skeleton is actually living. They are a very strong coral, and I seem to think they photosynthesize from their skeleton tissue along with their polyps.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top