ECC Hybrid and Bryan's Baby the Same Chalice?

Acroholic · Sep 22, 2009

I was on the Juicy Corals website, and they state they are the same here:

Eye Catching Corals's Hybrid Watermelon Chalice : Juicy Corals, Rare Corals, Exotic Corals, Live Corals, Aquarium Corals

Does this jibe with eyeryone's experience?
Dave

MikeB · Sep 22, 2009

No they state: "We have also heard this coral called "Bryan's Baby"" and "We have been told that is is the same coral as the SPStoner Hybrid, but we don;t have that piece and cannot be sure"

Stating that he has heard it called that and him saying it is that are two different things.

I think the way he wrote it can EASILY able to be misconstrued. I called him to inform him to reword it.

143gadgets · Sep 22, 2009

I have all three and all are different.

-Brian's Baby
-ECC Hybrid
-SPS Toner's Watermelon

MikeB · Sep 22, 2009

143gadgets said:
I have all three and all are different.

-Brian's Baby
-ECC Hybrid
-SPS Toner's Watermelon

Side x Side x Side pics if you can? That would be awesome :tongue:

Ian · Sep 22, 2009

143gadgets said:
I have all three and all are different.

-Brian's Baby
-ECC Hybrid
-SPS Toner's Watermelon

SAme here, I concur :nerd:

MikeB · Sep 22, 2009

bigian said:
SAme here, I concur :nerd:

Side x Side x Side pics if you can? That would be awesome :tongue: LOL

Acroholic · Sep 22, 2009

Browns said:
No they state: "We have also heard this coral called "Bryan's Baby"" and "We have been told that is is the same coral as the SPStoner Hybrid, but we don;t have that piece and cannot be sure"

Stating that he has heard it called that and him saying it is that are two different things.

I think the way he wrote it can EASILY able to be misconstrued. I called him to inform him to reword it.

Either way it communicates the possibility.

I have all three as well and was hoping I didn't have any duplicates. Thanks.
Dave

mpoletti · Sep 22, 2009

Does anyone know who Brian/Bryan is? I believe that Cherry Corals used to have it on their site as well. Thanks

holdyourlight · Sep 22, 2009

marko9 said:
Does anyone know who Brian/Bryan is? I believe that Cherry Corals used to have it on their site as well. Thanks

he goes by skyhigh, he is from tropicorium

JR's Reef · Sep 22, 2009

I would like to see some side by sides also

Acroholic · Sep 22, 2009

No offense to Juicy Corals intended here. I just wanted to know if I had any duplicates. I had a PM that told me I threw Juicy Corals "under the bus" and "called them out" by starting this thread.

Not intended that way at all.
Dave

Ian · Sep 22, 2009

There's nothing wrong with trying to verify posted information.

They threw themselves under the bus...

m and m · Sep 22, 2009

Acroholic said:
No offense to Juicy Corals intended here. I just wanted to know if I had any duplicates. I had a PM that told me I threw Juicy Corals "under the bus" and "called them out" by starting this thread.

Not intended that way at all.
Dave

You see that right there is shady, Why is he getting so deffencive, just because you asked a question about his coral. Those names where only in there to draw attenshion. If you noticed alot of his other corals are like " we dont say its somthing unless we have directe linage to that person" now on this one its like it may be from here or here but not sure we where only told.

Sikryd · Sep 22, 2009

I think its always good to ask and find out otherwise you'll never know.

I have talked to a lot of guys that are wondering the same thing about a lot of different pieces out there now since their are so many that look alike or are slightly different.

mpoletti · Sep 22, 2009

Acroholic said:
No offense to Juicy Corals intended here. I just wanted to know if I had any duplicates. I had a PM that told me I threw Juicy Corals "under the bus" and "called them out" by starting this thread.

Not intended that way at all.
Dave

I would of asked the same questions Dave. Its just too bad that people take it too far. Its propbably someone who is friends with the vendor. Oh well. Thanks for the topic and if we as consumers do not ask questions, then who will?

roscoe · Sep 22, 2009

Totally sucks that you can't question a corals origin without vendors getting offended. We as consumers have a right to know.

Acroholic · Sep 22, 2009

roscoe said:
Totally sucks that you can't question a corals origin without vendors getting offended. We as consumers have a right to know.

It wasn't the Vendor, but maybe someone that knows him?

roscoe · Sep 22, 2009

OK sorry bout that. I misread it. Anyhow it is still sad that one would get their feelings hurt because they want to make sure that something is what they claim it to be.

Acroholic · Sep 22, 2009

roscoe said:
OK sorry bout that. I misread it. Anyhow it is still sad that one would get their feelings hurt because they want to make sure that something is what they claim it to be.

I agree.