Elegance withdrawn

  • Thread starter Thread starter Trever
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Trever

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 19, 2020
Messages
671
Reaction score
354
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Are elegance corals particularly sensitive to ALK/Calc/Mg changes?

Susceptible to disease related to algae bloom?

The TL;DNR:

8 days ago I added a "medium" sized elegance coral to my 3 month old tank.

About a half day or less after introduction, the coral appeared to thrive. Fully extended, and has colored up beautifully. Fantastic looking coral, all by itself on the bottom of the tank directly under a kessil A360WE, surrounded by rock but getting what appeared to me perfect flow for it.

Yesterday towards the end of the day after dosing (see below) I noticed that the tentacles looked a little off. "Sickly". Not something noticeable upon casual observation, but since I spend a lot of time looking at my tank and have a pretty good eye, it just looked like something wasn't right.

Today, so far, it is "out" but barely, meaning I can see the shell, etc. It has a slightly swollen look to it and the tentacles aren't extended as normal.

I have been slowly increasing my parameters which were low (ALK/Calc/Mg). I'm testing twice a day (before dosing and after dosing), at one point, my ALK did go up about .5 dkh. I've actually been trying to increase it that much per day, but always failing to reach that big a change (I'd rather fail than overshoot that). I've gone from 6.6 to 8.3 (targeting 9) over the course of a week. I have a number of beginner SPS (eg. purple stylophora), thus the quest for higher parameters. pH has gone from 8.15 to 8.25 over the week, salinity is stable (35), etc. AFAIC, everything looks good. As I have increased my parameters, the other corals have colored up well and showing some growth. At one point a forest fire digitada wasn't looking so happy, but that has come back to normal.

I've also had an algae bloom which had started shortly before introducing the elegance coral. Somewhat cloudy water during the middle part of the day, but in the last two days, all of this has gotten a lot better. The only thing I've done to combat the uglies has been to add 5 snails (had no CUC previously). The snails don't seem to do much IMO. Sure, they eat. But the bloom seems to be going away on its own. I haven't tested phosphate in awhile but that has always been low, nitrates were 10, last I checked a few days ago down to 2.5. My theory is the algae has burned off a lot of the nitrates.
 
Directly under the kessil? That may be a problem. Mine like lower light. I’d try moving towards the edge of the light source.

I had a similar aged tank to you when I first added mine and it did some weird stuff. Feeding it seemed to noticeably help. I do coral frenzy LPS pellets.
 
@colossal_tater for a variety of reasons, I'm convinced the light is perfect for it. PAR readings, advice of my LFS (trust her, she's one of the best reefers in the state), its first week of reacting to the light it is in, etc.. It also isn't showing any signs of issues related to the light that I'm aware of, in fact, the opposite (coloration has improved).
 
Mine is in the darkest corner of the tank in low flow on the sand bed. Likes to be fed mysis. They do change and inflate and deflate. One or two days i no reason for alarm.
 
I just saw your build thread. Really awesome rock you have there! If it’s dead center under that Kessil, that’s still my most suspect problem. But I’d try feeding it. In 2 days mine bounced back after a good feeding. If yours is still bad after that then maybe consider a move.
 
75 -125 par with a lower water flow. Under Kessel may be a bit much.
where Was it sourced from. indo has elegance has issues. Elegance coral syndrome
 
@colossal_tater I hear you about the light (and thanks for the compliment). However I just double checked. Based on the par readings where the elegance is, it's right within what most coral sellers recommend for it (80 - 125 par). I hear you though because I was concerned there was no way that would be a good location (too much light). I explained the situation to my LFS when I was considering buying it (I really do trust her), and she said "If it's on the bottom of the tank it will be fine, in fact a good location for it". Also as I said, the immediate reaction of the coral was to thrive. At "high noon" for my light program, it extends fully (it usually is fully extended but I notice that as it gets dark and at night, it does various things). I think if the light was too high, it would have reacted very differently in the first 8 days. It actually seems to like the light and (again) has colored up spectacularly.

I also think moving it now would just add more stress to it.

I have to assume it is not happy with my dosing. Algae kill coral by messing with bacterial populations in the water as well, so that would be a bigger worry.

@sfin52 I have wondered about that, however, this particular specimen has been at my LFS for at least a month and in any case, her stuff is top notch in terms of QT/disease free, that's why I buy there! BRS recommended place, etc.

@Bpfor3 you're pressing my confirmation bias button. :) It's actually looking better as time has gone on this afternoon- even since I posted. It's still just partially open but doesn't have this weird swollen thing going on, and I can't really describe but it but the tentacles and color looks a lot better- it doesn't have the sickly pale I was seeing throughout the day here previously.

Gonna wait and see.

Honestly, what I was most wondering was just whether other people have seen their elegance get upset when they adjust ALK/Calc/Mg. Should have put that in my subject line....

Fingers crossed. It's a glorious coral. I've been pinning for that thing for a year. Now that I have it, I love it.
 
@ExBevo just fine thanks! It recovered in a day. Has been fine since then, until a few days ago, it's been a bit withdrawn again. But it opens up enough to photosynthesize and I'm sure will be fine again.

Apparently I need to remove the PVC "stand" that it's resting in in the sand. That might be what's bothering it now.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top