UPDATE: Before considering construction of a v1, v2 or v3 controller, please see the post for the v4 controller which is a better option.
Disclaimer: This thread is intended to be an objective review of the features, performance, vulnerabilities, and experience of owning an Automatic Calcium Reactor by Aquarium Engineering. It is not a thread about the company, the owner, war stories, or what have you. Please join the conversation...
www.reef2reef.com
I have been working on a new version of my DIY controller that replaces the factory controller entirely and I am finally ready to share the details. This controller paired with an external peristaltic pump makes the ACR run much smoother than the factory one ever did and addresses all the former's short comings. The controller is easy to build (mostly just connecting of parts) and uses off the shelf industrial automation parts, intended for continuous duty.
Before I get into the controller, there are a couple of prerequisites that ever ACR owner should undertake.
Check Valve After Feed Pump
You should install a check valve after your feed pump and before the ACR. When the feed pump stops (for whatever reason, e.g. maintenance, power failure, etc.), the gas pocket in the ACR will drop in pressure to atmospheric and volume of the gas will expand displacing a fair bit of effluent back through the feed pump. The effluent will be at a very low PH and depending on the flow you are running at, the burst of effluent could spike your readings. Google
"Boyle's Law" to see why this occurs.
My ACR did not include a check valve, and AE has stated it was not needed, however I have noticed some new parts are being shipped with the latest ACR's. I am not sure if any of these extra bits include an embedded check valve. If not, you should still add one.
Note: using the factory controller with a check valve has some caveats. I found that when restarting the ACR after a vent/purge, the presence of a check valve caused the factory controller to fail to equalize and sync up with the float switch level. This would cause the water level to drop below the float valve and potentially build up a gas pocket big enough to stop the circulation pump. The solution is to install a bypass valve that you can open for startup, and then close once the ACR is running stable.
Volute Reinforcement for Sicce Pump
If you do any work on the ACR that involves removing the Sicce pump, you will want to reinforce the volute
before you put it back together. The wall on the volute is ridiculously thin and will crack just from screwing in the factory fitting. The o-ring on the fitting that provides for a nice water tight seal applies just a tad too much pressure and it is super easy to crack the volute. My suggestion is to reinforce the volute with a collar glued on to make it robust and not easily damaged.
Here is my solution to that. A piece of a CPVC fitting, sanded down and glued on. A 3D printed part would work even better.
Ok, now that those are out of the way, let's look at the replacement controller(s).
v1 Controller
Calling this version a controller at all, is a bit of a stretch. It is simply replacing the factory CO2 module with a Clippard valve and using the float switch in the ACR to energize the Clippard. This is exactly how the factory controller works (for CO2), the difference here is that I am using a robust industrial valve that is intended for continuous duty (unlike the factory parts). The valves are designed to operate for more a than a billion cycles before failure, can open an close in < 10ms and use a modest 19ma (at 24VDC). Keeping them energized 24x7 (as I do in my
CO2 Tank Auto Switcher), results in a temperature barely above body temperature. They are also very, very quiet during operation. You will be hard pressed to hear it cycle over the sound of the circulation pump.
You will need the following parts:
https://www.clippard.com/part/ET-2-24-V
https://www.clippard.com/part/ET-C48
You will also need (2) 10-32 to 1/4" adapters for connecting to your CO2 tubing. You can source these online.
v1 ACR Controller (PDF)
I don't recommend building the v1 controller. The v2 and v3 have much better features and make the ACR run smoother. However if your factory controller gives up the ghost, then the v1 can be built quickly and step in easily for the factory controller (when paired with a peristaltic pump).
v2 Controller
This is the version of controller that I recommend for most ACR owners. The change from the v1 is the addition of a programmable pressure sensor, in this case an IFM Efector PN5204, and a vent switch.
The IFM sensor is what gives this version extra features. This part is a programmable pressure sensor that has a single output that we can control. We use the output to drive the Clippard valve through the float switch (and vent switch). This allows us to see exactly what is happening inside the ACR at all times. The pressure displayed on the IFM will match what the ACR internal CO2 gas pocket pressure is. As well, we can clamp the maximum allowed pressure to programmatically run the ACR at a different pressure than the CO2 regulator is providing. This is very handy to protect the ACR from an over pressure situation that can burst it's welds, and to mitigate issues that cheap CO2 regulators can cause (like end of tank dumping). Plus users are forever fiddling with CO2 regulators, and posting questions to the forum about them, and this makes all that away go away.
The IFM parts can be sourced from Ebay. This particular model (there are
lots of models), is an obsolete part, no longer made, which works in our favour as they are easy to find cheaply. You should expect to pay about $30 for a used one in good condition. They were several hundred dollars new, and some vendor still try to charge a few hundred dollars for a use one, but don't pay more than $60 for one as there are lots around.
Operating instructions Pressure sensor PN52xx
In fact, you can buy a similar part, brand new for under $100. The
ProSense QPSL-AP-42 from Automation direct is only $76 and provides similar features (a bit more features actually) and is new and still being made. The specs are here
https://cdn.automationdirect.com/static/specs/prosensedigitalswtrans.pdf. They also provide direct replacements for the IFM's right down to the connector interface. They are $200 more than the cheaper version though.
For the IFM part, you will need a hookup cable:
M12 Sensor cable ifm efector EVC004
You will also need the Clippard valve, cables and connectors mentioned in the v1 controller version.
v2 ACR Controller (PDF)
The vent switch in this version is a feature I added that allows for easy manual venting of the ACR. That switch along with a
3-Way Ball Valve with John Guest 1/4" Push Connect from BRS, installed into the CO2 re-circulation line, provides a simple method of venting the ACR.
To do a manual vent procedure, you toggle the vent switch, this will prevent the IFM from driving the Clippard valve open, and then move the manual 3-way valve installed in the CO2 re-circulation to the opposite direction. This will stop the venturi from pulling CO2 from the gas pocket, allowing the circulating gas to collect there, and vent the gas pocket out through the 3-way valve. When the escaping gas turns to effluent, simply switch the 3-way back and toggle the vent switch. The IFM sensor will then take over slowly re-establishing the gas pocket. The time it takes to re-establish the gas pocket can be adjusted by the pressure limits configured.
The programming to use with the IFM is mode HNC (Hysteris - Normally Closed). I was using a set pressure of 8 PSI and a reset pressure of 7 PSI, but have recently switched to 9 and 8 PSI respectively. I can provide assistance when you get to the programming part (if needed).
v3 Controller
This is the latest version of the controller and adds automatic periodic venting as a feature. This required the addition of some more hardware and a slight bit more complexity (but still quite easy to DIY). I will show my building of the v3 controller at the end of this post.
To add the automatic venting feature, an electronic 3-way valve, a 24VDC relay and a 24VDC timer module was added. The electronic 3-way gets installed in the CO2 re-circulation line just like the manual 3-way from the v2. The 24VDC relay goes in place of the vent switch, and finally, the 24VDC timer module replaces the user involvement to make it automatic.
I used the following parts (find these locally):
GAEYAELE GR8 AC DC 12V 24V 48V Intermediate Relay Auxiliary Relay 8A 16A SPDT Relays (GR8-116,AC/DC 24V)
7-Day Heavy Duty THC 15A Digital Timer Programmable Timer Relay 16 On & Off Digital Timer Switch (24V)
NH / NEPTUNE RESEARCH 648T032 3-WAY ISOLATION SOLENOID VALVE 24 VDC 30PSI
For the 3-way (on Ebay), I recommend that model (648T032) for ease of use. They are hard to find used, and go for $165 new. So don't over pay for a used one. If you attempt to buy the one from the linked auction, the guy will accept $60.
v3 ACR Controller (PDF)
For my build of a v3 controller, I used the following parts. Most of these are optional and were used for neatness or ease of use.
Dinkle Combiner DK2.5N 10 Gang Power Distribution Dk2.5N 10 Gang Box Connector DIN Rail Terminal Blocks, 12-22 AWG, 20 Amp, 600V Solar Combiner, Beige
Dinkle DSS2.5N-02P DIN Rail Terminal Block Press-Fit Jumper (Pack of 50)
LMioEtool ABS Plastic Dustproof Waterproof IP65 Junction Box Hinged Shell Universal Electrical Project Enclosure Gray 5.9 x 5.9 x 3.5 inch (150 x 150 x 90mm)
Here are the collected parts that I used in the v3 build.
The box I chose had mounting points for a DIN rail and was sized to fit the rail included with the combiner package. I drilled some holes for the cable gland, power jack and the mounting holes for the Clippard and NR 3-way.
The DIN contacts and the rail they came on, fit nicely in the box. You can see that I have cross connected the 3 contacts on the left, giving 6 common contacts. The ground will connect to 1 and the other 5 will be drops for ground connections. The next 2 contacts are jumped, and will provide 3 drops for 24VDC. The next 2 contacts are again jumped and provide 2 drops (and 1 spare) of the 24VDC signal from the timer when it triggers. These drive the 24VDC relay and the NR 3-way valve. The next contact is used to connect the float switch to the Clippard (easier to see in latter pics with wires installed), and finally the last 2 will be unused spares.
The Clippard and NR 3-way valve are screwed to the top of the project box.
Here the wiring is underway. Note, I had to swap the cable gland out for a larger size as the mid sized one I started with ran out of space before I got the float switch cable inserted.
The wiring is complete here. I shifted the relay over and used the end plate to hold it in place as it was a bit loose on the rail.
Here it is installed on my ACR equipment stand, and in the process of being debugged (I had a couple of wires swapped).
Finally how it looks when complete. The IFM sensor is not shown, but is mounted at the top of the stand for easy viewing.
Of course I was super excited to test the automatic venting feature. It works as expected. I have been doing the manual venting procedure for months, so I already knew that it would work if automated. The only thing that I was not overly excited about was how long it took to re-establish the CO2 pocket after being vented. Until it is fully re-established, there would be no/limited bubbles rising in the reactor. I am not sure if having no bubbles circulating during that time affects the performance, but I like the presence of the bubbles as it
looks more efficient.
I had worked out a plan that required adding a timed relay and a NC valve on the effluent drain to open the effluent for a few seconds after every vent cycle to allow the CO2 to rapidly rebuild the gas pocket, and then I decided to just try increasing the maximum allowed pressure on the IFM. I went from 8/7 PSI to 9/8 PSI and this noticeably sped up the rebuilding of the gas pocket. It turns out (I think), that the time it takes to rebuild the gas pocket is affected by the amount of pressure above the pump head pressure, that the IFM limits the ACR to. My pump's head pressure is about 5 PSI, adding 1 PSI to the headroom made a difference.
I have probably left a ton of stuff out. Feel free to contact me for assistance if you undertake to replace the factory controller.
Dennis