Eshopps S-120 vs Bubble Magus BM-NAC3.5

[meintn]

I've been looking for a cone skimmer and these two seem to fit the dimensions I need and have relatively good reviews. Anyone have any experience with these or recommendations of others I should consider? I need less than a 8" x 8" footprint and good for a 46 gallon tank but I'd like to "overskim" as much as possible. I also posted a topic in the selling forum if anyone has something to offer on hand. Thanks!

 

[Rob.D]

I run the Eshopps S-120 on my 30 cube, it performs well but I don't think you can overskim with either of the skimmers listed.
I also ran the BM-3.5 on the ETRC Club frag tank (30 cube) it also performed well, but it is shorter and has a lower ghp pump than the Eshopps.

 

[meintn]

Thanks for the info. What skimmer would you consider an upgrade over those two while keeping the smaller footprint?

 

[Rob.D]

I would like to upgrade soon, when I can afford the upgrade. I'll be choosing from this list.

RLSS R-6i

Reef Octopus 1000SSS

Bubble Magus Curve 5

SWC 160 cone

I know there are a few more skimmer models that could be on the list, so if anyone want's to jump in, go for it.

 

[rarelyseen]

I have the curve 5 and love it! Started skimming right out of the box. For the price you can't beat it!

 

[Rob.D]

I have the curve 5 and love it! Started skimming right out of the box. For the price you can't beat it!

Do you have a pic of it in your sump?