I bought a trio of ricordea florida and a big, beautiful green toadstool leather from Pacific East Aquaculture. Their pictures were all accurate to what I received, and all of them were big, beautiful, and healthy. Pacific East Aquaculture periodically has major sales, which is when I bought my corals from them, so I was able to get all that for about $100, shipping included. My one complaint about them would be that they don't have soft corals available as often as I'd like.
Oh, and if you are going for gorgonians, KP Aquatics is 100% the way to go! They have beautiful, robust gorgonians, at fantastic prices, and often will throw in an extra goody or two (for example, I ordered one yellow sea whip from them and received one extra smaller one as a freebie).