Filter socks yes or no

bigbrother14

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
28
Reaction score
7
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I've been debating on filter socks i have been using them an I'm alil tired of switching them out every 2-3 days do they surve another purpose besides making my water clearer is it ok to run my system without them
 
Yes.

There's a time and a place for a filter sock IME. (during a water change) Just as an example, my clownfish spawn on a regular basis now. Sometimes when I have to take a p!$$ in the middle of the night I'll shine a light into the tank to see what's going on. More times then none these little eyes are bouncing off the light. (babies/not mysid) My corals are having a field day when this happens, but I couldn't imagine all these tiny fish sitting in a filter sock for days on end. That stinks... ;)
 
Last edited:
I think people use them as physical filter. I too use them. They are pretty good in filtering out foods and other debris from your system but washing them is a pain:mad:. I don't think they have any other uses....or may be my knowledge is limited;).
 
I pulled mine out for awhile. Didn't want a nitrate factory. I ended up putting them back in because of detritus build up in the sump. I rather replace the filter sock then clean out my sump:)
 
I use them as well. Change out every 4 days or so. Try not running them for a week or 2 and see how the tank is without them. You might be able to get away with not needing them
 
Was going to make a new thread, then saw this one! How are you guys going days without a sock change? Mine clog in 1-4 hours, on my reefer 250, so they are 200 micron filters. Does Kalkwasser clog them?

Thanks!
Salt
 
I think people use them as physical filter. I too use them. They are pretty good in filtering out foods and other debris from your system but washing them is a pain:mad:. I don't think they have any other uses....or may be my knowledge is limited;).

Add LIFE to that list as well... If flow is important in a reef tank, a filter sock is hindering just that, flow. KISS, GL. :)
 
I ran two filter socks 24/7 on my system. It was a pita to change them out every few days but they did keep detritus from building up in my sump and kept things very sterile. I have since removed them because the maintenance was a pain. Its been close to a month and I have not seen any parameter change
 
Add LIFE to that list as well... If flow is important in a reef tank, a filter sock is hindering just that, flow. KISS, GL. :)

Oh yeah....I forgot about life....my pods generally love to be in there....its a very easy food source for them....

As far the flow concern I would say if you keep it clean no problem or else a significant decrease in flow rate....;)
 
I can't put it as eloquently as another member did, but "Everybody wants a pet these days but nobody wants to clean up after them it seems..." LARS? You tell me...
 
I can't put it as eloquently as another member did, but "Everybody wants a pet these days but nobody wants to clean up after them it seems..." LARS? You tell me...
Hmmmm....I would say.... No pain no gain.....;)
 
I ran socks for a while but got really tired of changing and cleaning, a few months ago i made a filter floss "holder?" with some 6 inch pvc a cap and reducer, drilled a bunch of holes. I love it. Every few days i pull out the floss, toss and change. Floss is cheap and it takes literally 2 min to change out.
 
NOOOOOOOO, I have been with no sock for 2 months vast improvement in my tank. But if your heavily stocked then maybe. I only have 4 fish in my 75 but heavy stocked sps, zoas, lPS.
 
I run four 7" 200 micron felt socks in my sump 24/7. I've been running them for 6 years now and never seen any downside to having them. Only upsides. My sump remains detritus free and contrary to popular belief, they aren't "nitrate factories". That is a complete misconception in my experience. If you don't have socks, any solids that they could have removed will be left in the tank to break down. As such, if some solids begin to break down in the socks between sock swaps, that's certainly better than all the solids remaining in the system to break down. Lower nutrient systems could see minor adverse effects from the socks in terms of the water being "too" clean but that is pretty rare. As far as pod removal, pods generally stay in or near the rocks and substrate. Any pods that find their way over the overflow and into your filter socks should be inconsequential in the grand scheme of things and shouldn't make a dent in pod populations. Fish will consume far more pods than the socks. As far as sock change intervals, that in my experience varies from tank to tank. I change mine out ever several days when they start to back up and overflow. Some tanks will clog socks faster depending on the sock size, number of socks, flow through the socks and of course the amount of solids in the water.

Bottom line, I am a firm believer in filter socks. I think people tend to get too anal when it comes to changing them out so frequently. The misconception of the nitrate factory thing leads people down that path. I surmise that if you are having nitrate issues, you have other problems and the socks are the least of them. Things like having enough bacterial surface for bacteria such as enough live rock, sand, DSB's etc play a much bigger role in nitrate control that sock change frequency. Reducing solids in the water can also help in that regard as can a good skimmer but enough bacteria in a healthy system is the biggest factor when it comes to maintaining low levels of nitrates. I have over 60 fish in my system with many being large 8" + fish and feed 3x a day and tend to over feed with my nightly feelings. My socks are changed ever week and sometimes even longer and I have no detectable nitrates, no nuisance algae issues and I don't dose carbon sources either. I attribute that to a well established system with a lot of live rock, a remote DSB in my refugium and lots of good flow to prevent detritus build up in the display coupled with filter socks and a great skimmer to export the solids from the system.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top